CFJ 2773: Called by Yally (01 Mar); Judged FALSE by Murphy (06 Mar) Wooble is a player. CFJ 2772: Called by ais523 (01 Mar); CASE OPEN The IBA is a player CFJ 2771: Called by comex (28 Feb); CASE OPEN When a proposal to create a new rule takes effect, two new rules are created. CFJ 2770: Called by Murphy (27 Feb); Judged TRUE by Yally (07 Mar); APPEAL PENDING Murphy satisfies the Winning Condition of Renaissance. CFJ 2769: Called by Yally (27 Feb); Judged UNDETERMINED by G. (01 Mar); OVERTURNED on Appeal (06 Mar); CASE OPEN The IBA is a player. CFJ 2768: Called by Yally (27 Feb); Judged UNDETERMINED by G. (01 Mar); OVERTURNED on Appeal (06 Mar); CASE OPEN The IBA is a person. CFJ 2767: Called by coppro (24 Feb); Judged TRUE by Yally (27 Feb) My Title is Purple CFJ 2766: Called by Yally (23 Feb); Judged TRUE by coppro (27 Feb) Proposal 6632 successfully amended Rule 2282. CFJ 2765: Called by Yally (23 Feb); Judged GUILTY/FINE by G. (10 Mar); APPEAL PENDING coppro violated Rule 1922, a power-1 Rule, by failing to award me the Patent Title Three Months Long Service as soon as possible after I had continuously held the office for three months. CFJ 2764: Called by coppro (22 Feb); Judged FALSE by comex (22 Feb) If the election for IADoP were resolved right now, ais523's conditional vote would resolve to an endorsement of myself. CFJ 2763: Called by ais523 (20 Feb); Judged TRUE by Murphy (06 Mar) In an AI 4 proposal, "Change gamestate value X from 'Y' to 'Z'" has the same meaning as "If gamestate value X is currently 'Y', change it to 'Z'". CFJ 2762: Called by Yally (11 Feb); Judged FALSE by Murphy (20 Feb) If the above proposal were to pass, the title of Rule 2284 would change to "Fee-based Actions". CFJ 2761: Called by comex (07 Feb); Judged NOT GUILTY by G. (10 Feb) comex (c.) violated the power 3 Rule 101 by infringing the several rights of the collective Citizens United, when e caused them to cease to be persons. CFJ 2760: Called by coppro (22 Jan); Judged FALSE by Yally (30 Jan) Murphy CAN award me at least 20 x-points. CFJ 2759: Called by coppro (09 Jan); Judged GUILTY/SILENCE by Yally (19 Jan) Murphy violated the 1-power Rule 2168 by failing to issue a publicly humiliating message to slackers re Proposal 6604's voting period being extended. CFJ 2758: Called by Wooble (09 Dec); Judged GUILTY/COMMUNITY SERVICE by Murphy (08 Jan) c. violated Rule 2143 and committed the Class-3 Crime of Tardiness by failing to publish a Notary's monthly report last month. CFJ 2757: Called by Wooble (09 Dec); Judged GUILTY/COMMUNITY SERVICE by Murphy (08 Jan) c. violated Rule 2143 and committed the Class-3 Crime of Tardiness by failing to publish a Notary's weekly report last week. CFJ 2756: Called by Murphy (07 Dec); Judged TRUE by comex (08 Jan) Voting limits on an Agoran decision are measured when it is resolved, rather than when its voting period ends. CFJ 2755: Called by Murphy (06 Dec); Judged TRUE by comex (08 Jan) An Agoran decision for which the voting period has ended, but the decision has not yet been resolved, is ongoing. CFJ 2754: Called by Yally (05 Dec); Judged TRUE by coppro (08 Jan) Walker is currently (at the time of the calling of this CFJ) a player. CFJ 2753: Called by Pavitra (02 Dec); Judged FALSE by comex (06 Dec) If adopted, the effects of "Library of Senate" would be canceled by R1698 (Agora Is a Nomic). CFJ 2752: Called by G. (02 Dec); Judged TRUE by comex (06 Dec) It is POSSIBLE to make a rule change to Rule 104 in a four-week period. CFJ 2751: Called by G. (30 Nov); Judged FALSE by Murphy (06 Dec) G.'s voting limit on the current decision to award coppro a thesis is 15. CFJ 2750: Called by Murphy (29 Nov); Judged UNDETERMINED by ais523 (02 Dec) If the Chief Whip announced that 2 + 2 = 5, it would be legal to publicly agree. CFJ 2749: Called by coppro (29 Nov); Judged TRUE by Murphy (29 Nov) If the Admiral of the Navy initiated a coup right now, and purported to give the CotC the Justiciar card when e Formed the Government, eir coup would be a chicken coup. CFJ 2748: Called by coppro (27 Nov); Judged GUILTY/SILENCE by Yally (14 Dec) Murphy, by failing to publish a CotC report in the week beginning 2009-11-09, violated Rule 2143 and committed the Class-3 Crime of Tardiness. CFJ 2747: Called by coppro (26 Nov); Judged UNDETERMINED by G. (01 Dec) If an active player were awarded 5 instances of Champion right now, e would be Speaker. CFJ 2746: Called by coppro (26 Nov); Judged FALSE by G. (01 Dec) A player can appear more than once on the List of Succession. CFJ 2745: Called by coppro (26 Nov); Judged TRUE by G. (01 Dec) Wooble is on the List of Succession. CFJ 2744: Called by Murphy (24 Nov); Judged FALSE by coppro (29 Nov) In the hypothetical situation described in evidence, player 3 CAN transfer at least one Dunce Cap on December 11, 2009. CFJ 2743: Called by Murphy (24 Nov); Judged TRUE by coppro (29 Nov) In the hypothetical situation described in evidence, player 2 CAN transfer at least one Dunce Cap on December 11, 2009. CFJ 2742: Called by Murphy (24 Nov); Judged FALSE by coppro (29 Nov) In the hypothetical situation described in evidence, player 1 CAN transfer at least two Dunce Caps on December 11, 2009. CFJ 2741: Called by Murphy (24 Nov); Judged TRUE by coppro (29 Nov) In the hypothetical situation described in evidence, player 1 CAN transfer at least one Dunce Cap on December 11, 2009. CFJ 2740: Called by Wooble (24 Nov); Judged TRUE by Yally (29 Nov) It is POSSIBLE to assign a judgment of UNDETERMINED to this CFJ. CFJ 2739: Called by G. (24 Nov); Judged FALSE by ais523 (02 Dec); AFFIRMED on Appeal (14 Dec) Taral has earned a white ribbon. CFJ 2738: Called by coppro (17 Nov); Judged FALSE by comex (29 Nov) If it were ADOPTED right now, the Citrine Fix proposal would amend a rule. CFJ 2737: Called by G. (17 Nov); Judged FALSE by Murphy (19 Jan) G. has cast an infinite number of votes on proposal 6581. CFJ 2736: Called by Murphy (17 Nov); Judged FALSE by Yally (24 Nov); AFFIRMED on Appeal (01 Dec) ais523 has initiated a CFJ on the statement 'This is a CFJ.' within the past 24 hours. CFJ 2735: Called by Murphy (17 Nov); Judged TRUE by comex (07 Dec) This is a CFJ. CFJ 2734: Called by Yally (17 Nov); Judged TRUE by Murphy (28 Nov) Publishing exactly one report that is not in plain text is the Class 2 Crime of Making My Eyes Bleed. CFJ 2733: Called by Tiger (14 Nov); Judged TRUE by G. (13 Jan) The decision on whether to adopt the proposal Pragmatize Strict Ordering has been initiated. CFJ 2732: Called by coppro (09 Nov); Judged by comex (30 Jan) BobTHJ abused eir position as Secretary of Agriculture to award emself points and grant emself a victory when others were awaiting eir actions and report - myself in particular, waiting on a rather large sum of points to be awarded to myself. CFJ 2731: Called by Tiger (08 Nov); Judged UNDETERMINED by comex (14 Nov) the decision on whether to adopt the proposal Pragmatize Strict Ordering has been initiated. CFJ 2730: Called by comex (06 Nov); Judged NOT GUILTY by coppro (09 Nov) c. violated Rule 2253 (Power-2) by creating the card Presto! in eir possession. CFJ 2729: Called by BobTHJ (04 Nov); Judged TRUE by ais523 (12 Nov) The Assumption of the Registrar is Postulated. CFJ 2728: Called by ais523 (03 Nov); Judged FALSE by coppro (06 Nov); REMANDED on Appeal (28 Nov); Judged TRUE by coppro (28 Nov) G. has opined REASSIGN on CFJ 2696a. CFJ 2727: Called by BobTHJ (26 Oct); Judged TRUE by Yally (27 Oct) On or around Sat, Oct 24 2009 01:20 BobTHJ destroyed a total of 26 rests in eir possession. CFJ 2726: Called by BobTHJ (26 Oct); Judged TRUE by Yally (27 Oct) On or around Sat, Oct 24 2009 01:20 BobTHJ destroyed 24 rests in eir possession. CFJ 2725: Called by Murphy (14 Oct); Judged UNDETERMINED by coppro (14 Oct) ais523 acted on behalf of Murphy to publish a message resolving the Agoran Decision on whether to adopt proposal 6514, as quoted in evidence. CFJ 2724: Called by coppro (13 Oct); Judged TRUE by comex (25 Oct) If it is determined that ais523 cannot act on behalf of Murphy to resolve the Agoran decision to adopt 6514, ais523's message purporting to do so is self-ratifying. CFJ 2723: Called by coppro (12 Oct); Judged GUILTY/DISCHARGE by Murphy (25 Oct) BobTHJ violated Rule 2230, a Power-2 Rule, by failing to announce publicly the validity of the NoV identified as #9 in eir reports. CFJ 2722: Called by coppro (12 Oct); Judged GUILTY/DISCHARGE by Murphy (25 Oct) BobTHJ violated Rule 2230, a Power-2 Rule, by failing to announce publicly the validity of the NoV identified as #5 in eir reports. CFJ 2721: Called by coppro (12 Oct); Judged GUILTY/APOLOGY by Murphy (25 Oct) BobTHJ violated Rule 2230, a Power-2 Rule, by failing to announce publicly the validity of the NoV identified as #1 in eir reports. CFJ 2720: Called by comex (12 Oct); Judged FALSE by ais523 (20 Oct) Wooble is the Admiral of the Navy. CFJ 2719: Called by coppro (08 Oct); Judged FALSE by Tiger (26 Oct) If judged to be UNDECIDABLE, the CFJ initiated in the quoted text would be a tortoise. CFJ 2718: Called by ais523 (08 Oct); Judged UNDETERMINED by coppro (25 Oct) At no point in time between the moment this CFJ is assigned to a judge, and the next moment at which either rule 2215 is repealed, amended, or otherwise fails to be enforceable with its current meaning, will it be legal for the judge of this CFJ to publically make an undisclaimed statement with the same meaning as this one (i.e. replacing 'the judge of this CFJ' with the actual judge, etc.). CFJ 2717: Called by BobTHJ (07 Oct); Judged FALSE by Tiger (15 Oct) On or around Wed, 07 Oct 2009 20:37 the office of Grand Poobah successfully audited ais523. CFJ 2716: Called by ais523 (07 Oct); Judged TRUE by Walker (15 Oct) "Break the Presto Picking Loop" is Distributable. CFJ 2715: Called by comex (06 Oct); Judged FALSE by Murphy (25 Oct) I am party to the Livenomic Partnership contract. CFJ 2714: Called by Murphy (06 Oct); Judged FALSE by coppro (14 Oct) If a criminal case based on the NOV noted in evidence were judged GUILTY / SILENCE, it would create at least one Rest in Wooble's possession. CFJ 2713: Called by Murphy (06 Oct); Judged FALSE by coppro (14 Oct) If a criminal case based on the NOV noted in evidence were judged GUILTY / SILENCE, it would create at least one Rest in coppro's possession. CFJ 2712: Called by Murphy (06 Oct); Judged TRUE by coppro (14 Oct) If a criminal case based on the NOV noted in evidence were judged GUILTY / SILENCE, it would create at least one Rest. CFJ 2711: Called by coppro (05 Oct); Judged TRUE by Walker (14 Oct) A Government was Formed on September 1. CFJ 2710: Called by Wooble (04 Oct); Judged GUILTY/SILENCE by Walker (06 Oct) coppro violated the power-2 Rule 1742 by failing to ensure that É™ fulfilled all its obligations, specifically the obligation to assign a judgment to CFJ 2700. CFJ 2709: Called by coppro (04 Oct); Judged GUILTY/SILENCE by Walker (05 Oct) Wooble violated the power-2 Rule 1742 by failing to ensure that É™ fulfilled all its obligations, specifically the obligation to assign a judgment to CFJ 2700. CFJ 2708: Called by Wooble (02 Oct); Judged FALSE by Walker (04 Oct) The Short Logical Ruleset is neither short nor logical. CFJ 2707: Called by comex (24 Sep); Judged TRUE by Murphy (26 Sep) It is LEGAL to methodically spam the email accounts of former players. CFJ 2706: Called by ehird (24 Sep); Judged UNDETERMINED by ais523 (14 Oct) A player that "hard deregisters" (totally dissociating themselves from the game with eir R101(vii) right, as opposed to the action of deregistering) is a person. CFJ 2705: Called by Pavitra (24 Sep); Judged TRUE by comex (26 Sep) If Pavitra were to deregister now, explicitly invoking eir R101(vii) right, the only appropriate judgement in a criminal CFJ against em for violating the Power-2 R1742 by violating Acid Test by deregistering would be GUILTY/DISCHARGE. CFJ 2704: Called by ais523 (23 Sep); Judged TRUE by Murphy (25 Oct) Darth Cliche (Kenner Gordon) registered yesterday. CFJ 2703: Called by coppro (22 Sep); Judged UNDETERMINED by ais523 (28 Sep) I is a player. CFJ 2702: Called by BobTHJ (21 Sep); Judged TRUE by coppro (23 Sep) On or about Sept 20, 2009 22:51 (UTC) ais523 terminated Contract B. CFJ 2701: Called by ais523 (20 Sep); Judged TRUE by G. (29 Nov) The LNP is a player CFJ 2700: Called by Murphy (19 Sep); Judged FALSE by Tiger (15 Oct) ais523 has amended the Fantasy Rules Contest contract within the past 24 hours. CFJ 2699: Called by ais523 (19 Sep); Judged FALSE by Murphy (26 Sep) Murphy was audited today CFJ 2698: Called by ais523 (19 Sep); Judged TRUE by Murphy (25 Oct) If a player had a reasonable opportunity to review a change, then that player had notice of the change. CFJ 2697: Called by ais523 (19 Sep); Judged UNDETERMINED by comex (03 Oct) Intending to perform a change in a public forum, then waiting 4 days, is sufficient to give players a reasonable opportunity to review the change, for the purpose of rule 101(iv). CFJ 2696: Called by Murphy (19 Sep); Judged FALSE by coppro (20 Oct); OVERTURNED on Appeal (03 Nov); Judged FALSE by G. (08 Nov) ais523 successfully amended Points Party in the message quoted in evidence. CFJ 2695: Called by BobTHJ (18 Sep); Judged FALSE by Pavitra (24 Sep) c. awarded emself 70 x-points via the Contract B contest. CFJ 2694: Called by Murphy (18 Sep); Judged FALSE by ais523 (21 Sep) If the Chief Whip has caste 1 and 0 rests, then e CAN cast a second valid vote on an ordinary proposal. CFJ 2693: Called by Pavitra (18 Sep); Judged TRUE by BobTHJ (23 Sep) If G.'s possible registration in the above message were successful, then G. would now be a party to the Fantasy Rules Contest. CFJ 2692: Called by G. (18 Sep); Judged FALSE by comex (19 Sep) G. is a player. CFJ 2690: Called by comex (17 Sep); Judged by BobTHJ (01 Oct) ais523 intended to amend The Cookie Jar to become a mousetrap, and claims to be able to go through with the amendment despite objections. CFJ 2689: Called by Wooble (17 Sep); Judged TRUE by Walker (20 Sep); REMANDED on Appeal (24 Sep); Judged FALSE by Walker (27 Sep) The most recent Scorekeepor's report was correct in reporting that BobTHJ revoked 3 points from ais523. CFJ 2687: Called by Murphy (15 Sep); Judged FALSE by Wooble (17 Sep) Murphy awarded at least one point on or about Tue, 15 Sep 2009 01:19:56 -0700. CFJ 2686: Called by Murphy (15 Sep); Judged FALSE by Wooble (17 Sep) Murphy awarded at least one point in the message in which this case was initiated. CFJ 2685: Called by ais523 (14 Sep); Judged FALSE by coppro (18 Sep) I favoured a CFJ by Murphy with the statement 'It is legal to announce that CFJ 2670 was appealed.' CFJ 2684: Called by Walker (13 Sep); Judged GUILTY/APOLOGY by É™ (19 Sep) BobTHJ violated Rule 2143, a Power 1 Rule, by publishing an Anarchist's report on the 10th of September, 2009 claiming that C-walker does not own any cards from the Deck of Change. CFJ 2683: Called by coppro (13 Sep); Judged GUILTY/SILENCE by Wooble (17 Sep) Murphy violated R208, a 3-power Rule, by failing to resolve the Agoran Decision to adopt proposal 6473 as soon as possible after the voting period ended. CFJ 2682: Called by Wooble (11 Sep); Judged TRUE by BobTHJ (18 Sep) It is POSSIBLE to increase a player's voting limit on an ordinary decision by playing a Roll Call card. CFJ 2681: Called by comex (10 Sep); Judged NOT GUILTY by coppro (15 Sep) BoBTHJ violated Rule 911 (Power-1.7) by failing to publish an opinion on CFJ 2670a ASAP after a panel containing em was assigned. CFJ 2680: Called by Murphy (10 Sep); Judged FALSE by É™ (19 Sep) It is legal to announce that CFJ 2670 was appealed. CFJ 2679: Called by ais523 (09 Sep); Judged FALSE by coppro (16 Sep); REMANDED on Appeal (26 Sep); Judged TRUE by coppro (04 Oct) ais523 owns a Dunce Cap card CFJ 2678: Called by Walker (05 Sep); Judged TRUE by woggle (18 Sep); REMANDED on Appeal (30 Sep); Judged FALSE by woggle (03 Oct) The proposals FRC Recognition and No Vacancy v.2 are both Distributable. CFJ 2677: Called by Tiger (05 Sep); Judged TRUE by Pavitra (16 Sep) The cards named in the above message were destroyed due to C-walker's self-auditing. CFJ 2676: Called by ais523 (02 Sep); Judged TRUE by Murphy (22 Sep) It is POSSIBLE to CoE on the identity of a message posted by the PerlNomic Partnership since 6pm today. CFJ 2675: Called by Wooble (01 Sep); Judged FALSE by Murphy (05 Sep) The Livenomic Partnership is a player. CFJ 2674: Called by coppro (31 Aug); Judged GUILTY/SILENCE by woggle (05 Sep); REMANDED on Appeal (13 Oct); REMANDED on Appeal (13 Oct); Judged GUILTY by woggle (13 Oct); Judged GUILTY/SILENCE by ais523 (14 Oct) BobTHJ violated Rule 2143, committing the Class-N Crime of Tardiness (with N=1) by failing to publish a Herald's report in the week prior to the one in which this message is published. CFJ 2673: Called by coppro (30 Aug); Judged GUILTY/SILENCE by ais523 (08 Sep) BobTHJ violated Rule 2143 and committed the Class-N (N=2) Crime of Tardiness by failing to pick one or more rules and submit proposals to repeal each of those rules in the week of August 17-23. CFJ 2672: Called by Wooble (27 Aug); Judged FALSE by Pavitra (29 Aug) CFJ 2654 exists. CFJ 2671: Called by ais523 (27 Aug); Judged GUILTY/SILENCE by coppro (29 Aug) comex violated R1504, committing the Class-3 Crime of Failure to Apologise, by failing to publish eir apology as soon as possible after the judgement for CFJ 2550 was delivered. CFJ 2670: Called by ais523 (28 Aug); Judged TRUE by comex (28 Aug) Agora can be Satisfied with an intent to perform a dependent action With 2 Support (that does not also specify being performed With Notice). CFJ 2669: Called by Tiger (24 Aug); Judged TRUE by Murphy (27 Aug) The Grand Poobah is the dealer of the Deck of Government. CFJ 2668: Called by coppro (23 Aug); Judged TRUE by Walker (28 Aug) If I resolved the first quoted intent, a player who had given notice both 6 and 60 days previously would be able to join É™. CFJ 2667: Called by coppro (21 Aug); Judged TRUE by BobTHJ (31 Aug) I have at least 1 zm CFJ 2666: Called by G. (17 Aug); Judged UNDETERMINED by woggle (19 Aug) This is to decide. CFJ 2665: Called by coppro (16 Aug); Judged NOT GUILTY by ais523 (24 Aug) coppro violated power=2 rule R2259 by deputizing for the Anarchist to deal emself cards before hand limits had been enforced for the month. CFJ 2664: Called by BobTHJ (14 Aug); Judged TRUE by Murphy (16 Sep) The Ambassador has a weekly report CFJ 2663: Called by Murphy (13 Aug); Judged TRUE by Wooble (24 Aug) When a Rule is repealed, it continues to exist as a non-Rule instrument. CFJ 2662: Called by Yally (10 Aug); Judged TRUE by Pavitra (19 Aug) When a judge with judicial rank 1 has eir judgement overruled on appeal, then it is decreased by 1 and e CANNOT increase it for 30 days afterward. CFJ 2661: Called by ais523 (09 Aug); Judged TRUE by coppro (21 Aug) No Call for Judgement before this one has had the same statement as this one. CFJ 2660: Called by Murphy (09 Aug); Judged FALSE by É™ (23 Aug) The pledge quoted in evidence terminated when coppro performed the card transfers described by it. CFJ 2659: Called by Murphy (07 Aug); Judged FALSE by Wooble (13 Aug) "Viva la fuente!" is a Flag Candidate. CFJ 2658: Called by Murphy (07 Aug); Judged FALSE by Wooble (13 Aug) Rule 2105 (The Map of Agora) is a Flag Candidate. CFJ 2657: Called by Murphy (07 Aug); Judged TRUE by Wooble (13 Aug) Rule 2265 (Placeholder Arms), paragraph 2, sentence 1 should be interpreted as "...a [possibly hypothetical] Power-1 rule...". CFJ 2656: Called by Wooble (07 Aug); Judged TRUE by woggle (08 Aug); REMANDED on Appeal (09 Aug); Judged FALSE by woggle (17 Aug) coppro's destruction of Wooble's Lobbyist and Debate-o-Matic cards in the quoted message was LEGAL CFJ 2655: Called by coppro (07 Aug); Judged FALSE by comex (16 Aug); REMANDED on Appeal (25 Aug); Judged FALSE by comex (01 Sep) I am owed a draw from the Government deck. CFJ 2653: Called by G. (07 Aug); Judged GUILTY/SILENCE by BobTHJ (16 Aug) coppro broke Rule 2253 (power-2) by creating the second in a set of Local Election Cards in a way not explicitly permitted by the rules. CFJ 2652: Called by G. (07 Aug); Judged GUILTY/SILENCE by BobTHJ (16 Aug) coppro broke Rule 2253 (power-2) by creating the first in a set of Local Election Cards in a way not explicitly permitted by the rules. CFJ 2651: Called by comex (07 Aug); Judged FALSE by Murphy (19 Aug) If I don't receive 15 objections, it will be POSSIBLE for me to indirectly cause a Rule Change using Contract A. CFJ 2650: Called by coppro (07 Aug); Judged UNDECIDABLE by Pavitra (12 Aug) I CAN destroy The Pier by announcement. CFJ 2649: Called by coppro (07 Aug); Judged FALSE by woggle (08 Aug) Warrigal is owed the patent Title Champion. CFJ 2648: Called by BobTHJ (05 Aug); Judged FALSE by É™ (09 Aug) BobTHJ has a Cyan ribbon CFJ 2647: Called by comex (05 Aug); Judged UNDETERMINED by coppro (08 Aug) There is exactly one possible text and title for a valid Flag Candidate. CFJ 2646: Called by BobTHJ (03 Aug); Judged FALSE by Walker (08 Aug) On or about Mon, 03 Aug 2009 19:15 a person with the e-mail address of yd17.agora@gmail.com registered. CFJ 2645: Called by G. (03 Aug); Judged FALSE by Wooble (09 Aug) G. published a monthly Herald's report on Aug 3, 2009 thus satisfying the Herald's requirement to publish a monthly report in August. CFJ 2644: Called by Wooble (31 Jul); Judged FALSE by Walker (16 Aug) The owner of a Local Election card CAN play it, causing it to be destroyed. CFJ 2643: Called by comex (30 Jul); Judged TRUE by Murphy (31 Jul) It is generally POSSIBLE, if allowed by Rule 2264, to act on behalf of a player to deregister by announcement. CFJ 2642: Called by comex (30 Jul); Judged TRUE by Murphy (31 Jul) It is generally POSSIBLE, if allowed by Rule 2264, to act on behalf of a player to deregister. CFJ 2641: Called by BobTHJ (30 Jul); Judged NOT GUILTY by ais523 (02 Aug) BobTHJ violated R2143, a Power-1 rule, by publishing an Insulator's report with incorrect information on 23 July by means of claiming that C-walker had 0 rests. CFJ 2640: Called by Murphy (24 Jul); Judged FALSE by comex (03 Aug) BobTHJ CAN cast more than 2 valid votes on Proposal 6413. CFJ 2639: Called by ehird (23 Jul); Judged TRUE by G. (02 Aug) Quazie is active. CFJ 2638: Called by BobTHJ (23 Jul); Judged FALSE by Murphy (08 Aug) BobTHJ's voting limit on proposal 6413 is 2. CFJ 2637: Called by Murphy (21 Jul); Judged FALSE by Taral (01 Aug) Sending a public message is equivalent to acting on behalf of onself (in the absence of an attempt to act on behalf of someone else), and is thus restricted by the rule "Acting on Behalf". CFJ 2636: Called by coppro (19 Jul); Judged by Taral (09 Aug) - The IBA does not have a functioning offer system as it cannot platonically act on behalf of a player. - The Rates of assets have not been kept updated. - The President has not recently published a report. CFJ 2635: Called by G. (15 Jul); Judged TRUE by coppro (19 Jul) The Promotor is a high-priority office. CFJ 2634: Called by coppro (14 Jul); Judged FALSE by Wooble (16 Jul) comex is the Executor of this message. CFJ 2633: Called by coppro (13 Jul); Judged TRUE by G. (20 Jul) The Can exists. CFJ 2632: Called by Walker (10 Jul); Judged TRUE by Pavitra (16 Jul) The Conductor CAN publish a self-ratifying report. CFJ 2631: Called by Wooble (10 Jul); Judged FALSE by comex (16 Jul); AFFIRMED on Appeal (31 Jul) Rule 2254 has power 2. CFJ 2630: Called by coppro (07 Jul); Judged FALSE by G. (16 Jul) There is an election for Janitor in its nomination period. CFJ 2629: Called by coppro (07 Jul); Judged FALSE by woggle (10 Jul) My judicial rank is 42. CFJ 2628: Called by coppro (07 Jul); Judged FALSE by woggle (10 Jul) My judicial rank is 4. CFJ 2627: Called by Wooble (06 Jul); Judged GUILTY/SILENCE by ais523 (18 Jul) C-walker violated the Power 1 Rule 2215 by making the above statement while not reasonably believing the cited private contract existed, and thus not reasonably believing e could cause Lynn Shawcroft to register. CFJ 2626: Called by ais523 (06 Jul); Judged IRRELEVANT by É™ (14 Jul) Earlier today I nkeplwgplxgioyzjvtxjnncsqscvntlbdqromyeyvlhkjgteaqnneqgujjpwcbyfrpueoydjjked. CFJ 2625: Called by ais523 (06 Jul); Judged TRUE by É™ (14 Jul) Earlier today I retracted my vote on proposal 6397. CFJ 2624: Called by ais523 (02 Jul); Judged TRUE by coppro (19 Jul) If the Grand Poobah does not do a caste rotation within the first week of July, and I do not make any further intents to deputise until I attempt to deputise, I CAN deputise for em after the first week of July ends. CFJ 2623: Called by ehird (02 Jul); Judged by Taral (21 Jul) comex - who (dubiously) counts as the CotC when performing Justiciar duties - rotated the bench without intending to mislead others as to the pointless conceptual games indulged in by mistake; furthermore, there hasn't been, to my knowledge, a case of two appeals panels trying said action - apparently an experiment - beforehand. Indeed, I cannot even find any record of em *asking* one to do so! CFJ 2622: Called by Murphy (01 Jul); Judged FALSE by coppro (07 Jul); REMANDED on Appeal (19 Jul); Judged FALSE by Pavitra (03 Aug) If a judicial case is submitted to and accepted by the Justiciar, then the CotC CAN change its Interest Index without 3 objections. CFJ 2621: Called by coppro (29 Jun); Judged TRUE by Murphy (16 Jul) I have a Magenta Ribbon. CFJ 2620: Called by Wooble (29 Jun); Judged GUILTY/APOLOGY by comex (04 Jul) 2.71828183... violated R2170, a Power-3 rule, by choosing the confusing nickname "e" as a short form. CFJ 2619: Called by comex (01 Jul); Judged UNDETERMINED by Pavitra (12 Jul) Wooble is party to at least one private contract containing the word "inferences". CFJ 2618: Called by comex (01 Jul); Judged UNDETERMINED by ais523 (02 Jul) ais523 is party to at least one private contract containing the word "inferences". CFJ 2617: Called by comex (01 Jul); Judged TRUE by Warrigal (01 Jul) 1 + 1 = 2 CFJ 2616: Called by allispaul (27 Jun); Judged FALSE by G. (06 Jul) Mojo's Disclosure has been flipped. CFJ 2615: Called by Wooble (26 Jun); Judged FALSE by ais523 (04 Jul) Goethe is the current Grand Poobah CFJ 2614: Called by Yally (25 Jun); Judged FALSE by Murphy (25 Jun) If the Janitor submits an interested proposal and claims it to be a part of eir weekly duties, then it becomes Distributable upon entering the Proposal Pool. CFJ 2613: Called by ais523 (25 Jun); Judged TRUE by Taral (02 Jul) The Speaker CAN publish an Honors List. CFJ 2612: Called by ais523 (25 Jun); Judged TRUE by Taral (02 Jul) On 29 February 2004, root called for (or attempted to call for) the appeal of the judgement of CFJ 1492. CFJ 2611: Called by allispaul (24 Jun); Judged TRUE by Warrigal (26 Jun) The Grid's Disclosure has been flipped. CFJ 2610: Called by Yally (21 Jun); Judged TRUE by allispaul (24 Jun); REMANDED on Appeal (10 Jul); Judged FALSE by woggle (19 Jul) The PerlNomic Partnership was an eligible voter in the recent Grand Poobah election. CFJ 2609: Called by Pavitra (21 Jun); Judged FALSE by Murphy (21 Jun) Quazie MAY join Edge Case. CFJ 2608: Called by Pavitra (21 Jun); Judged FALSE by Murphy (21 Jun) Pavitra MAY leave Edge Case. CFJ 2607: Called by Pavitra (21 Jun); Judged FALSE by BobTHJ (24 Jun) Taral is sitting. CFJ 2606: Called by coppro (21 Jun); Judged by Taral (07 Jul) I accidentally published the list of what contracts are what and the contract provides no suitable remedy to ensure the integrity of the game. CFJ 2605: Called by teucer (21 Jun); Judged FALSE by Pavitra (05 Jul) Bdi ta Askatasuna joined Warrigal's unnamed contract. CFJ 2604: Called by Rodlen (21 Jun); Judged FALSE by Yally (21 Jun) Rodlen and Rolden are different players. CFJ 2603: Called by Quazie (14 May); Judged TRUE by Wooble (23 Jun) Quazie is a caller of this CFJ CFJ 2602: Called by Quazie (14 May); Judged FALSE by Wooble (23 Jun) OscarMeyr is a caller of this CFJ CFJ 2601: Called by Quazie (14 May); Judged FALSE by Wooble (23 Jun) Human Point Two is the caller of this CFJ CFJ 2600: Called by ais523 (20 Jun); Judged FALSE by Rodlen (21 Jun) In the above-quoted message, coppro went on hold CFJ 2599: Called by ais523 (19 Jun); Judged FALSE by coppro (26 Jun) Before immibis decided to no longer agree to 'that agreement', ais523 could act on behalf of immibis to cause em to register. CFJ 2598: Called by ais523 (19 Jun); Judged FALSE by coppro (26 Jun) ais523 CAN act on behalf of immibis to cause em to register. CFJ 2597: Called by Warrigal (18 Jun); Judged FALSE by ais523 (24 Jun) For the next second, I continuously CFJ on this statement. CFJ 2596: Called by coppro (18 Jun); Judged TRUE by Taral (24 Jul) I can deregister Tiger Jr. CFJ 2595: Called by Tiger (18 Jun); Judged TRUE by coppro (21 Jun) Tiger Jr. is a player. CFJ 2594: Called by coppro (18 Jun); Judged TRUE by Pavitra (21 Jun) The proposal entitled It's the Thought That Counts, if adopted, would successfully cause the second Rule Change described in its text. CFJ 2593: Called by coppro (18 Jun); Judged TRUE by Pavitra (21 Jun) The proposal entitled It's the Thought That Counts, if adopted, would successfully cause the first Rule Change described in its text. CFJ 2592: Called by Murphy (18 Jun); Judged TRUE by Wooble (16 Jul) The declaration of a Skunk is part of a specific Win by High Score's cleanup procedure, and does not affect any other Win by High Score's cleanup procedure simultaneously in progress. CFJ 2591: Called by Yally (18 Jun); Judged FALSE by BobTHJ (24 Jun) I cast a valid vote in the recent Promotor election. CFJ 2590: Called by Yally (17 Jun); Judged TRUE by Wooble (23 Jun) It would be legal for for the IADoP to submit eir report with the date the report is being submitted, not the date eir previous report was submitted. CFJ 2589: Called by comex (17 Jun); Judged NOT GUILTY by ehird (03 Jul) Taral violated the Power=4 Rule 2029 by failing to Dance a Powerful Dance. CFJ 2588: Called by comex (17 Jun); Judged FALSE by Murphy (21 Jun) CFJ 2543 is a tortoise. CFJ 2587: Called by coppro (17 Jun); Judged FALSE by Murphy (21 Jun) CFJ 2543 is a tortoise. CFJ 2586: Called by Wooble (16 Jun); Judged UNDETERMINED by Walker (17 Jun); OVERRULED to FALSE on Appeal (07 Jul) Myndzi is a player. CFJ 2585: Called by allispaul (16 Jun); Judged FALSE by ais523 (17 Jun) It is ILLEGAL for me to vote for Quazie in the ongoing Janitor election. CFJ 2584: Called by Yally (15 Jun); Judged FALSE by Rodlen (17 Jun); REMANDED on Appeal (28 Jun); Judged TRUE by É™ (19 Jul) Murphy cast two votes in the recent Anarchist election. CFJ 2583: Called by ais523 (14 Jun); Judged TRUE by Wooble (01 Jul) G. made a pledge in the above-quoted message. CFJ 2582: Called by ais523 (14 Jun); Judged TRUE by Rodlen (17 Jun); REMANDED on Appeal (04 Jul); Judged FALSE by comex (16 Jul) A Powerful Dance is an instrument. CFJ 2581: Called by G. (14 Jun); Judged TRUE by Yally (21 Jun) Intents to perform multiple dependent actions were announced in the first message in the Evidence section, and each intent was resolved and made each Proposal in the Proposal Pool (at the time of resolution) distributable. CFJ 2580: Called by Murphy (12 Jun); Judged FALSE by BobTHJ (23 Jun) On or about Thu, 11 Jun 2009 11:02:15 -0700, Rodlen initiated an inquiry case on the statement "What is forced by rule 2029 to Dance a Powerful Dance?". CFJ 2579: Called by Rodlen (11 Jun); Judged FALSE by allispaul (15 Jun) An election for the office of Anarchist was initiated on June 11, 2009. CFJ 2578: Called by Wooble (11 Jun); Judged FALSE by coppro (17 Jun) A proposal was added to the Pool as a result of Tiger publishing the above-quoted message. CFJ 2577: Called by coppro (11 Jun); Judged FALSE by Tiger (11 Jun) Sgeo has cast an unconditional vote on the Decision to adopt Proposal 6345 CFJ 2576: Called by Pavitra (09 Jun); Judged TRUE by Wooble (11 Jun) Rolden has published a message. CFJ 2575: Called by Pavitra (09 Jun); Judged TRUE by Wooble (11 Jun) The recent Scorekeepor's report included Rodlen's score. CFJ 2574: Called by Pavitra (06 Jun); Judged TRUE by ehird (07 Jun); OVERRULED to FALSE on Appeal (18 Jun) In the above-quoted message, comex attempted to flip eir key to Gravity Circumference Line Deja Vu Cardboard Duck e^(-kt). CFJ 2573: Called by Wooble (06 Jun); Judged TRUE by ais523 (13 Jun) I am the same person who held the office of IADoP for 12 months. CFJ 2572: Called by Wooble (05 Jun); Judged GUILTY/APOLOGY by Murphy (03 Jul) You May Call Me Big Fucking Edward violated the Power 2 Rule 2158 by failing to assign a judgement to CFJ 2537 as soon as possible after it was assigned to em. CFJ 2571: Called by Rodlen (05 Jun); Judged FALSE by ehird (26 Jun) If the proposal called Newbie Friendly passes, and someone called Joe wished to register, if they said "JOE IZ HARE", that would be enough to register in Agora. CFJ 2570: Called by Wooble (05 Jun); Judged FALSE by Pavitra (07 Jun) C-walker recently submitted a proposal containing the 'word' 'registeredcontinuously'. CFJ 2569: Called by zeckalpha (04 Jun); Judged FALSE by Wooble (06 Jun) The first game of Agora lasted 100 years. CFJ 2568: Called by teucer (04 Jun); Judged TRUE by coppro (06 Jun) Luke Lockhart is a player. CFJ 2566: Called by Wooble (03 Jun); Judged TRUE by allispaul (24 Jun) Pavitra owns at least 1 crop. CFJ 2565: Called by allispaul (03 Jun); Judged FALSE by Walker (06 Jun) I was a player before the seventh sentence in this message. CFJ 2564: Called by allispaul (03 Jun); Judged FALSE by Walker (06 Jun) I was a player before the sixth sentence in this message. CFJ 2563: Called by allispaul (03 Jun); Judged FALSE by Walker (06 Jun) I was a player before the fifth sentence in this message. CFJ 2562: Called by allispaul (03 Jun); Judged FALSE by Walker (06 Jun) I was a player before the fourth sentence in this message. CFJ 2561: Called by allispaul (03 Jun); Judged FALSE by Walker (06 Jun) I was a player before the third sentence in this message. CFJ 2560: Called by coppro (02 Jun); Judged FALSE by ais523 (09 Jun) I can initiate an equity case regarding Test Subject 2. CFJ 2559: Called by coppro (01 Jun); Judged FALSE by ais523 (09 Jun) Test Subject is Yellow. CFJ 2558: Called by coppro (01 Jun); Judged FALSE by ais523 (09 Jun) Test Subject is Green. CFJ 2557: Called by Rodlen (01 Jun); Judged TRUE by ehird (06 Jun); OVERTURNED on Appeal (24 Jun); Judged FALSE by comex (25 Jun) Swine flu counts as pigs flying. CFJ 2556: Called by Quazie (01 Jun); Judged TRUE by Rodlen (06 Jun); REMANDED on Appeal (11 Jun); Judged TRUE by Rodlen (13 Jun); OVERTURNED on Appeal (17 Jun); Judged TRUE by Pavitra (26 Jun) A pledge I created that included the text 'pigs fly' has been terminated CFJ 2555: Called by Rodlen (01 Jun); Judged FALSE by Pavitra (07 Jun) Rule 105 is the only instrument that can be used to create, modify, or destroy rules. CFJ 2554: Called by Rodlen (01 Jun); Judged TRUE by allispaul (07 Jun) Rule 2029 consists of two sentences. CFJ 2553: Called by Quazie (01 Jun); Judged TRUE by Rodlen (06 Jun); REMANDED on Appeal (11 Jun); Judged TRUE by Rodlen (13 Jun); OVERTURNED on Appeal (17 Jun); Judged FALSE by Pavitra (26 Jun) My nomination for Cleck of the Courts has been accepted CFJ 2552: Called by coppro (01 Jun); Judged FALSE by Murphy (06 Jun) Canada bears the Patent Title Minister Without Portfolio. CFJ 2551: Called by Yally (01 Jun); Judged GUILTY/SILENCE by Tiger (06 Jun) OscarMeyr violated Rule 2019, a power-2 rule, by failing to assign prerogatives in a timely fashion before the beginning of the month of June. CFJ 2550: Called by Yally (31 May); Judged GUILTY/APOLOGY by ais523 (06 Jun) comex violated R1504, committing the Class-3 Crime of Failure To Apologize, by failing to publish eir apology as soon as possible after the judgment for CFJ 2531 was delivered. CFJ 2549: Called by Wooble (30 May); Judged TRUE by G. (07 Jun) zeckalpha is a Player. CFJ 2548: Called by comex (30 May); Judged FALSE by ehird (06 Jun) Proposal 6335 had the effect of submitting a proposal. CFJ 2547: Called by comex (30 May); Judged TRUE by Pavitra (18 Jun) Yally created a pledge in the above message CFJ 2546: Called by coppro (28 May); Judged FALSE by Wooble (02 Jun) In the quoted text, Yally supported a dependent action. CFJ 2545: Called by ais523 (28 May); Judged GUILTY/SILENCE by coppro (29 May); AFFIRMED on Appeal (08 Jun) Yally violated Rule 2143, committing the Class-6 Crim of Making My Eyes Bleed, by means of publishing eir most recent IADoP's report in HTML. CFJ 2544: Called by ais523 (26 May); Judged TRUE by Tiger (06 Jun); OVERTURNED on Appeal (11 Jun); Judged FALSE by G. (12 Jun) The signature in the above quote is a self-ratifying that ais523 was the Herald for a brief period of time. CFJ 2543: Called by Yally (26 May); Judged UNDECIDABLE by BobTHJ (02 Jun) The IADoP's report includes the date eir previous report was submitted, not the date eir current report is being submitted. CFJ 2542: Called by Quazie (26 May); Judged TRUE by Rodlen (30 May) R2239 has now been repealed CFJ 2541: Called by Quazie (26 May); Judged FALSE by Rodlen (30 May) R2239 has been repealed CFJ 2540: Called by comex (26 May); Judged TRUE by Murphy (11 Jun) It is POSSIBLE for a proposal to change the Rules. CFJ 2539: Called by comex (26 May); Judged TRUE by Murphy (11 Jun) It is POSSIBLE for ratification (e.g. by proposal) to change the Rules. CFJ 2538: Called by coppro (25 May); Judged FALSE by Wooble (26 May) Tiger has two Rests. CFJ 2537: Called by comex (25 May); Judged NOT GUILTY by OscarMeyr (09 Jun) Wooble violated R2202 and committed the Class-8 Crime of Endorsing Forgery by knowingly using Ratification Without Objection to ratify a (prior to ratification) incorrect document when a corrected document could be produced with reasonable effort. CFJ 2536: Called by Wooble (24 May); Judged TRUE by BobTHJ (26 May) The nickname 'Goethe' unambiguously identifies the player who generally sends messages to the list from the address 'kerim@u.washington.edu'. CFJ 2535: Called by comex (20 May); Judged FALSE by ais523 (28 May) root violated R2143 by failing to publish a Scorekeepor's report in the week from 20-26 April. CFJ 2534: Called by ais523 (20 May); Judged TRUE by Rodlen (29 May) Warrigal would be party to all Agoran public contracts that allow em to join by announcement, if the fact were announced in an Agoran public forum. CFJ 2533: Called by ais523 (19 May); Judged TRUE by Murphy (19 May) Quazie is a party to a pledge called '50/50 crop splitting' CFJ 2532: Called by ais523 (19 May); Judged TRUE by G. (25 May) A proposal with almost the same text as proposal 5269, but without the line 'I make the following proposal:' at the start, is in the Proposal Pool. CFJ 2531: Called by Wooble (19 May); Judged GUILTY/APOLOGY by OscarMeyr (21 May) comex violated the Power 2 Rule 2158 by failing to assign a judgement to CFJ 2499 as soon as possible after e was assigned as its judge. CFJ 2530: Called by ais523 (18 May); Judged FALSE by Quazie (18 May) ais523 published the NoVs which are the subject of CFJ 2480. CFJ 2529: Called by comex (17 May); Judged by Tiger (26 May) BobTHJ promoted me one time, not four times, even though I sent em 4*8=32 crops. CFJ 2528: Called by Murphy (17 May); Judged FALSE by coppro (23 May) On or about Sat, 16 May 2009 20:15:44 -0500, Yally resolved the Agoran decision to decide the holder of the IADoP office. CFJ 2527: Called by Yally (16 May); Judged FALSE by Murphy (06 Jun) Wooble initiated an election for Registrar on 14 May, 2009. CFJ 2526: Called by Quazie (15 May); Judged TRUE by Yally (31 May) In a message sent on may 14th, in which Quazie acted on behalf of Human Point Two, CFJs were initiated CFJ 2525: Called by coppro (12 May); Judged GUILTY/APOLOGY by Yally (20 May) coppro violated the 1-Power Rule 2143 by publishing a report stipulating the Proposal Pool to be empty when it in fact contained a proposal entitled {Judicial Sanctions}. CFJ 2524: Called by Tiger (11 May); Judged by coppro (26 May); OVERRULED on Appeal (01 Jun) c-walker flipped the contestmaster of the C# Party to Murphy. CFJ 2523: Called by Quazie (11 May); Judged TRUE by Wooble (18 May) A pledge that Quazie made on 1 May this year regarding musicianship still exists. CFJ 2522: Called by comex (11 May); Judged TRUE by G. (11 May) If the contestmaster of a contest is flipped to a person who is already the contestmaster of another contest, that person thereby becomes a contestmaster. CFJ 2521: Called by ais523 (10 May); Judged FALSE by Human Point Two (03 Jun) I awarded 5 x-points to Rodlen this week. CFJ 2520: Called by ais523 (10 May); Judged TRUE by Rodlen (11 May) A pledge that Quazie made on 5 My this year still exists. CFJ 2519: Called by ais523 (10 May); Judged TRUE by Tiger (11 May) At least one contract is Legalistic. CFJ 2518: Called by ais523 (10 May); Judged TRUE by Tiger (11 May) At least one contract is Public. CFJ 2517: Called by Yally (10 May); Judged FALSE by Murphy (12 May) A single attempted action that fails in part fails completely. CFJ 2516: Called by Quazie (10 May); Judged TRUE by coppro (12 May) Flipping the contestmaster of a contract to Human Point Two would fail CFJ 2515: Called by Rodlen (08 May); Judged TRUE by ais523 (14 May) 'Please treat Agora right good forever' in rule 101 can be violated. CFJ 2514: Called by G. (07 May); Judged TRUE by Yally (15 May) The phrase "This takes precedence over any other rule" in Rule 2229/1 takes precedence over the first sentence in Rule 1482/2 for a matter of spending rests. CFJ 2513: Called by G. (07 May); Judged TRUE by Yally (15 May) The phrase "This takes precedence over any other rule" in Rule 2229/1 attempts to specify a means of determining precedence between rules of unequal as well as equal power for a particular matter of spending rests. CFJ 2512: Called by coppro (07 May); Judged TRUE by Wooble (13 May) If there were no rules of power greater than 3, it would be POSSIBLE to enact a power-3 rule reading in part {This rule takes precedence over all other rules with which it conflicts.} CFJ 2511: Called by coppro (07 May); Judged TRUE by Wooble (13 May) If there were no rules of power greater than 3, it would be POSSIBLE to enact a power-3 rule reading in part {This rule takes precedence over all other rules.} CFJ 2510: Called by coppro (07 May); Judged TRUE by ais523 (22 May) It is POSSIBLE to enact a power-3 rule reading in part {This rule takes precedence over all other rules with which it conflicts.} CFJ 2509: Called by coppro (07 May); Judged TRUE by ais523 (22 May) It is POSSIBLE to enact a power-3 rule reading in part {This rule takes precedence over all other rules.} CFJ 2508: Called by coppro (07 May); Judged TRUE by ais523 (22 May) It is POSSIBLE to enact a power-4 rule reading in part {This rule takes precedence over all other rules with which it conflicts.} CFJ 2507: Called by coppro (07 May); Judged TRUE by ais523 (22 May) It is POSSIBLE to enact a power-4 rule reading in part {This rule takes precedence over all other rules.} CFJ 2506: Called by Yally (06 May); Judged UNDETERMINED by Quazie (08 May) If a member of an entity's basis nominates that entity for an election, then that entity has been self-nominated. CFJ 2505: Called by Rodlen (06 May); Judged IRRELEVANT by Murphy (06 May) Rodlen is here. CFJ 2504: Called by Rodlen (06 May); Judged UNDETERMINED by G. (06 May) Not treating Agora right good forever violates rule 101. CFJ 2503: Called by Taral (05 May); Judged FALSE by Murphy (17 May) comex has sent a message from a device with power 1. CFJ 2502: Called by ais523 (05 May); Judged TRUE by BobTHJ (22 May) CFJ 2500 has been appealed. CFJ 2501: Called by Wooble (05 May); Judged TRUE by coppro (12 May) "As soon as possible" means "within 168 hours". CFJ 2500: Called by Wooble (05 May); Judged FALSE by ehird (05 May); OVERTURNED on Appeal (14 May); Judged FALSE by Rodlen (15 May) A player who does not deregister in the interval becomes a Senator exactly 1440 (60 * 24) hours after e registers. CFJ 2499: Called by Rodlen (05 May); Judged TRUE by ehird (17 May) Two players may play Agora using the same email address. CFJ 2498: Called by gwen (05 May); Judged TRUE by ais523 (09 May) gwen is the initiator of this cfj CFJ 2497: Called by Quazie (05 May); Judged TRUE by ais523 (09 May) Quazie is the initiator of this CFJ CFJ 2496: Called by Quazie (05 May); Judged FALSE by ais523 (09 May) Gwen is the initiator of this CFJ CFJ 2495: Called by comex (04 May); Judged TRUE by Tiger (05 May) Murphy published at least one on-time judgement in the below-quoted message. CFJ 2494: Called by G. (04 May); Judged FALSE by Quazie (08 May); REMANDED on Appeal (19 May); Judged TRUE by Quazie (20 May) Rule 2221/1 describes a method for a player to amend a rule. CFJ 2493: Called by Rodlen (04 May); Judged TRUE by coppro (05 May) A proposal that fixes an obvious grammatical error that completely changes the meaning of a rule counts as modifying a substantive aspect of the meaning of the rule. CFJ 2492: Called by coppro (04 May); Judged FALSE by Yally (05 May); AFFIRMED on Appeal (21 May) If the next Registrar's report did not list me as a player, and I subsequently ratified it using the mechanism specified in R2202 (Ratification Without Objection), I would be able to go on hold. CFJ 2491: Called by coppro (04 May); Judged TRUE by Yally (05 May) If, on April 26th, an IADoP's report had been published, listing Rodlen as holder of the Anarchist office, the report subsequently self-ratified, and Rodlen fulfilled all the Anarchist's duties during the month of May, e would earn a Green Ribbon at the end of May. CFJ 2490: Called by root (04 May); Judged TRUE by comex (04 May) root has a rest. CFJ 2489: Called by ais523 (04 May); Judged FALSE by Tiger (05 May) root has won by Championship CFJ 2488: Called by ais523 (04 May); Judged FALSE by G. (18 May) The prohibition on excessive Notices of Violation in rule 2230 is ineffective due to rule 101 CFJ 2487: Called by G. (04 May); Judged FALSE by Murphy (04 May) The person who was deemed to be a player by CFJ 2461 has an Agoran nickname that must be tracked by the Registrar. CFJ 2486: Called by coppro (03 May); Judged FALSE by Wooble (04 May) A Rule and its text can have different power. CFJ 2485: Called by Wooble (02 May); Judged by OscarMeyr (19 May) The Lender has not been keeping track of Debt and Credit for the Agoran Loan Service. CFJ 2484: Called by Yally (02 May); Judged FALSE by ehird (04 May) ais523, Murphy, and coppro won the game on 02 May, 2009. CFJ 2483: Called by comex (02 May); Judged FALSE by Murphy (04 May) It is ILLEGAL to grant certain powers (in the ordinary-language sense) and privileges to Agora's ambassador if one is not a nomic. CFJ 2482: Called by Murphy (02 May); Judged TRUE by ais523 (04 May); REMANDED on Appeal (12 May); Judged TRUE by ais523 (18 May) The right of participation in the fora (Rule 101) takes precedence over the prohibition against excessive Notices of Violation (Rule 2230). CFJ 2481: Called by Murphy (02 May); Judged TRUE by Tiger (17 May) ais523 has published a Notice of Violation alleging that Ben Daniel claimed that there are five lights. CFJ 2480: Called by Murphy (02 May); Judged GUILTY/SILENCE by Taral (12 May); REMANDED on Appeal (23 May); Judged NOT GUILTY by Taral (05 Jun) ais523 violated Rule 2230 (Notices of Violation), committing the Class-4 Crime of Libel, twenty times by publishing the Notices of Violation in step 1 above. CFJ 2479: Called by Yally (02 May); Judged GUILTY/SILENCE by OscarMeyr (26 May) root violated Rule 2143, a power-1 rule by failing to publish the Herald's monthly report for the month of April. CFJ 2478: Called by ais523 (28 Apr); Judged FALSE by Wooble (30 Apr) The Herald CAN award comex a second instance of Champion. CFJ 2477: Called by coppro (28 Apr); Judged TRUE by ais523 (02 May) coppro has won the game at least once. CFJ 2476: Called by root (27 Apr); Judged FALSE by coppro (01 May) The statement of CFJ 2469 is about the possibility of winning the game by announcement. CFJ 2475: Called by root (27 Apr); Judged TRUE by Wooble (07 May) Winning the game is a rule-defined action. CFJ 2474: Called by Quazie (27 Apr); Judged FALSE by ais523 (29 Apr) Quazie registered via eir recent public message stating "May I register?" CFJ 2473: Called by Quazie (27 Apr); Judged FALSE by ais523 (29 Apr) Quazie registered via eir recent public message containing the capitol letters 'IREGISTER' CFJ 2472: Called by Quazie (27 Apr); Judged FALSE by ais523 (29 Apr) Quazie registered via eir recent private message to Registrar Yally stating 'I request registration' CFJ 2471: Called by Quazie (27 Apr); Judged FALSE by ais523 (29 Apr) Quazie became a player after his message stating "I registered" CFJ 2470: Called by comex (27 Apr); Judged FALSE by Murphy (04 May) ais523 CAN win the game by announcement. CFJ 2469: Called by ais523 (27 Apr); Judged TRUE by ehird (27 Apr); OVERRULED to UNDECIDABLE on Appeal (28 Apr) Interpreting 'If ... then' in the logical sense: If this statement is true, then it is possible for ais523 to win the game by announcement. CFJ 2468: Called by Wooble (27 Apr); Judged FALSE by comex (27 Apr) Quazie is a player. CFJ 2467: Called by comex (26 Apr); Judged TRUE by coppro (01 May) The Executor of the first public message sent by agoran@live.com can be determined within reasonable effort. CFJ 2466: Called by Yally (26 Apr); Judged FALSE by comex (27 Apr) Arnold Bros (est. 1905) is a confusing nickname. CFJ 2465: Called by coppro (26 Apr); Judged TRUE by ais523 (27 Apr) If two players satisfy the Winning Condition of High Score, and exactly one of them has a Rest, the score of the player with the Rest is set to 0. CFJ 2464: Called by coppro (24 Apr); Judged TRUE by Murphy (27 Apr) The PNP has more than one G# Note. CFJ 2463: Called by ais523 (24 Apr); Judged TRUE by root (28 Apr) It is possible for the Ambassador to flip the Recognition of Einos (http://einos-nomic.blogspot.com/) to Friendly. CFJ 2462: Called by Wooble (23 Apr); Judged TRUE by Tiger (23 Apr) Agoran Decisions on whether to adopt comex's proposals "Extra votes?" and "wrong paragraph" have been initiated. CFJ 2461: Called by Nameless (22 Apr); Judged TRUE by Murphy (23 Apr) I (that is, the person who is requesting judgment here) am a player. CFJ 2460: Called by ais523 (22 Apr); Judged TRUE by ehird (24 Apr) It is POSSIBLE for a player to register with a nickname that was used by a now-deregistered former player. CFJ 2459: Called by Yally (20 Apr); Judged NOT GUILTY by comex (20 Apr) Yally violated Power=3 Rule 2202 by failing to list the date of most recent ratification of the Registrar's Report. CFJ 2458: Called by Yally (20 Apr); Judged GUILTY/APOLOGY by Taral (21 Apr); REMANDED on Appeal (22 Apr); Judged GUILTY/APOLOGY by Taral (01 May) Yally violated Power=2 Rule 1789 by failing to ensure that henceforth all may know that Kelly deregistered in a Writ of FAGE. CFJ 2457: Called by ais523 (20 Apr); Judged FALSE by Tiger (28 Apr) In the message in which I initiated this CFJ, I created three Water Rights Vouchers in my own possession. CFJ 2456: Called by coppro (20 Apr); Judged TRUE by root (27 Apr) On April 1, 2009, Goethe legally flipped j to Beta. CFJ 2455: Called by coppro (20 Apr); Judged NOT GUILTY by comex (20 Apr) Wooble violated R2230 and committing the Class-4 Crime of Libel by publishing a NoV regarding Andre's Writ of FAGE. CFJ 2454: Called by Wooble (19 Apr); Judged TRUE by Yally (21 Apr); REMANDED on Appeal (22 Apr); Judged TRUE by Yally (23 Apr); OVERTURNED on Appeal (24 Apr); Judged TRUE by coppro (26 Apr) A player CAN deputize for the IADoP to end an election before its voting period has ended. CFJ 2453: Called by Wooble (19 Apr); Judged FALSE by Tiger (23 Apr) Wooble cast a vote in the recent Herald election. CFJ 2452: Called by ais523 (17 Apr); Judged TRUE by Yally (10 May) Actions can be taken in plain-text attachments sent via a Public Forum. CFJ 2451: Called by Tiger (17 Apr); Judged GUILTY/SILENCE by Taral (24 Apr); AFFIRMED on Appeal (03 May) comex broke the power=3 rule 2125 six times by making the announcement "I hereby announce that I performed duties related to Enigma in a timely manner during this month." six times. CFJ 2450: Called by comex (17 Apr); Judged TRUE by ais523 (25 Apr) The Scorekeepor SHALL award me 6N points as defined by Rule 2234 in relation to Enigma. CFJ 2449: Called by Yally (14 Apr); Judged TRUE by ais523 (26 Apr) If a legal voter votes to endorse an officer, but, after the casting of the original voter's vote and before the resolution of the decision, the holder of that office changes, then the voter has endorsed the final officer rather than the initial. CFJ 2448: Called by ais523 (14 Apr); Judged TRUE by coppro (15 Apr) Puzzles submitted by Enigma's contestmaster to emself count as puzzles within the definitions given by Enigma. CFJ 2447: Called by coppro (13 Apr); Judged IRRELEVANT by ehird (13 Apr) Immediately after this case is assigned to a judge, the set of appropriate judgments for this case is a subset of {FALSE, UNDECIDABLE}. CFJ 2446: Called by coppro (13 Apr); Judged UNDECIDABLE by Murphy (13 Apr) This statement is FALSE. CFJ 2445: Called by ais523 (12 Apr); Judged TRUE by BobTHJ (13 Apr) agora-business is a public forum CFJ 2444: Called by Yally (12 Apr); Judged TRUE by Wooble (16 Apr) Rule 2221 permits a method by which a Rule's title can be changed. CFJ 2443: Called by ais523 (07 Apr); Judged FALSE by Yally (08 Apr) CFJ 2423 is a tortoise. CFJ 2442: Called by ais523 (06 Apr); Judged FALSE by Murphy (10 Apr) A correct Win Announcement that states that a player has a score x + yi such that xy >= 2500 causes that player to satisfy a Winning Condition, even if that Win Announcement contains extra information not required by the rules. CFJ 2441: Called by Yally (06 Apr); Judged FALSE by ehird (07 Apr) An officer CAN submit an attachment in lieu of a plain text email to satisfy his report provided the attachment in question contains all necessary materials. CFJ 2440: Called by Murphy (02 Apr); Judged TRUE by Wooble (03 Apr) coppro's caste flips on or about Wed, 01 Apr 2009 22:08:13 -0600 were illegal. CFJ 2439: Called by root (01 Apr); Judged FALSE by woggle (04 Apr) A non-player who is a party to a contest is a contestant in that contest. CFJ 2438: Called by root (01 Apr); Judged FALSE by woggle (04 Apr) The contestmaster of a contest is a contestant in that contest. CFJ 2437: Called by Wooble (01 Apr); Judged TRUE by coppro (02 Apr); REMANDED on Appeal (09 Apr); Judged FALSE by coppro (11 Apr) Goethe recently flipped the Caste of at least 2 players to Alpha. CFJ 2436: Called by Wooble (26 Mar); Judged by Taral (15 Apr); REMANDED on Appeal (22 Apr); Judged by Rodlen (06 May) comex willfully used the Partnership to distribute a proposal in eir own self interest which included a false statement of the proposal pool being empty. CFJ 2435: Called by ais523 (26 Mar); Judged NOT GUILTY by Taral (01 Apr) comex broke Power-2 Rule 1742 by failing to act in accordance the PerlNomic Partnership contract by failing to ensure the PNP obeys the rules of Agora to the maximum extent by causing the PNP to publish that the proposal pool was empty when it was not. CFJ 2434: Called by Murphy (26 Mar); Judged TRUE by BobTHJ (30 Mar) Rests are fungible. CFJ 2433: Called by comex (26 Mar); Judged TRUE by Murphy (28 Mar) I CAN spend 'one of my cubes'. CFJ 2432: Called by comex (26 Mar); Judged TRUE by Murphy (28 Mar) I CAN spend 'the cube that person A gave me'. CFJ 2431: Called by coppro (24 Mar); Judged TRUE by Warrigal (07 Apr) At the instant the quoted call for judgment was called, The Shell had an owner CFJ 2430: Called by coppro (24 Mar); Judged TRUE by Warrigal (07 Apr) At the instant this call for judgment was called, The Shell was owned by the Lost and Found Department CFJ 2429: Called by Murphy (23 Mar); Judged FALSE by ais523 (25 Mar) Proposal 6122 has taken effect. CFJ 2428: Called by coppro (22 Mar); Judged FALSE by G. (25 Mar) If a proposal is caused to take effect without explicitly being allowed to cause rule changes, it can cause rule changes CFJ 2427: Called by coppro (22 Mar); Judged TRUE by G. (25 Mar) Rule 105 can, in whole or in part, prevent an instrument from taking effect CFJ 2426: Called by ehird (20 Mar); Judged TRUE by coppro (23 Mar) This thing is a CFJ. CFJ 2425: Called by ais523 (16 Mar); Judged FALSE by ehird (23 Mar); REMANDED on Appeal (04 Apr); Judged FALSE by ehird (07 Apr); REMANDED on Appeal (12 Apr); Judged FALSE by Yally (26 Apr) Murphy's recent attempt to cause Rule 2223 to amend itself to read 'This rule intentionally left blank' failed because it attempted to claim indirect authority from the non-existent Rule 6130. CFJ 2424: Called by ais523 (16 Mar); Judged TRUE by ehird (23 Mar); REMANDED on Appeal (04 Apr); Judged TRUE by ehird (07 Apr); REMANDED on Appeal (15 Apr); Judged FALSE by ehird (15 Apr) Murphy's recent attempt to cause Rule 2223 to amend itself to read 'This rule intentionally left blank' failed because it was ambiguous which of two mechanisms were used to do the amendment. CFJ 2423: Called by ais523 (16 Mar); Judged UNDECIDABLE by ehird (23 Mar) Murphy's recent attempt to cause Rule 2223 to amend itself to read 'This rule intentionally left blank' was using the mechanism specified in rule 2223, rather than the mechanism specified in the rule created by proposal 6130. CFJ 2421: Called by comex (16 Mar); Judged FALSE by woggle (19 Mar) A rule was amended in the message in which this CFJ was called. CFJ 2420: Called by G. (16 Mar); Judged TRUE by Murphy (16 Mar) There is at least one player who is currently the ambassador (as the term "the ambassador" is used in the Rules). CFJ 2419: Called by Murphy (16 Mar); Judged FALSE by coppro (16 Mar) Spent assets are transferred to the Lost and Found Department, unless they are specified as being transferred to a different owner than either their previous owner or the Lost and Found Department. CFJ 2418: Called by Murphy (16 Mar); Judged TRUE by coppro (16 Mar) Spent assets are destroyed, unless they are specified as being transferred to a different owner than their previous owner. CFJ 2417: Called by Murphy (16 Mar); Judged FALSE by Wooble (17 Mar) Murphy destroyed at least one Rest in the same message in which e initiated this CFJ. CFJ 2416: Called by comex (15 Mar); Judged TRUE by ais523 (23 Mar) The Promotor MAY distribute a proposal that is not in the Proposal Pool. CFJ 2415: Called by comex (15 Mar); Judged TRUE by ais523 (23 Mar) The Promotor CAN distribute a proposal that is not in the Proposal Pool. CFJ 2414: Called by ais523 (14 Mar); Judged FALSE by woggle (19 Mar) coppro has won at least once CFJ 2413: Called by ais523 (14 Mar); Judged UNDETERMINED by woggle (19 Mar) If a high-power rule states that a players SHOULD interpret a definition in a particular way, and a low-power rule implies that that particular definition is correct (or at least that all other alternative definitions are wrong), an interpretation of the definition other than the one suggested by the high-power rule can be correct. CFJ 2412: Called by G. (13 Mar); Judged TRUE by ehird (14 Mar) If Rule A says that a person SHALL perform an action by a specific mechanism, but Rule B says a person SHALL NOT perform an action by the mechanism, and no other mechanism for performing the action is specified, then the person CAN perform the action via the mechanism (though perhaps breaking Rule B). CFJ 2411: Called by coppro (13 Mar); Judged TRUE by G. (13 Mar) If a rule requires a player to perform an action without making it possible for em to do so, and there is a rule forbidding em from doing so, e can take no action that is not in violation of a rule. CFJ 2410: Called by ais523 (11 Mar); Judged TRUE by G. (18 Mar) coppro is a party to the Cookie Jar. CFJ 2409: Called by ehird (10 Mar); Judged FALSE by ais523 (18 Mar) I am obligated to post "ooɯ" to a Public Forum CFJ 2408: Called by ehird (10 Mar); Judged FALSE by ais523 (18 Mar) I am obligated to post "moo" to a Public Forum CFJ 2407: Called by ais523 (10 Mar); Judged TRUE by woggle (19 Mar) this is a call for judgement. CFJ 2406: Called by ais523 (09 Mar); Judged FALSE by comex (12 Mar) If an officer violates a time limit to perform a required action, then another player CAN perform that action as if e held that office via deputisation even if the officer in question performed the action after the time limit expired but before the deputisation, as long as it would be possible (but not necessarily mandatory) for the officer to perform the action in question a second time. CFJ 2405: Called by ais523 (09 Mar); Judged NOT GUILTY by comex (28 Mar) Taral violated the power-2 rule 2234 by not awarding me points as contestmaster of Enigma as soon as possible after the beginning of March. CFJ 2404: Called by G. (09 Mar); Judged FALSE by Wooble (18 Mar) If the scorekeepor announces that a contestmaster is not to be awarded points for a particular month as e did not perform duties for the contest, then the scorekeepor has performed all duties required by Rule 2234 with respect to that contest. CFJ 2403: Called by comex (09 Mar); Judged TRUE by coppro (13 Mar) It is POSSIBLE for the Scorekeepor to R2234-award points to Wooble for the AAA. CFJ 2402: Called by Wooble (09 Mar); Judged GUILTY/SILENCE by ehird (10 Mar); REMANDED on Appeal (19 Mar); Judged GUILTY/SILENCE by ehird (23 Mar); OVERRULED to NOT GUILTY on Appeal (28 Mar) Taral violated R2234, a power-2 rule, by not awarding me points as soon as possible after the end of February for completing the contestmaster duties for the AAA. CFJ 2401: Called by Warrigal (07 Mar); Judged TRUE by G. (08 Mar) If a person can take an action by announcement, then e can take it by announcing that e "is taking" the action. CFJ 2400: Called by G. (06 Mar); Judged FALSE by comex (13 Mar) If a non-IADoP initiates an election decision via deputisation, e CAN resolve the decision immediately after its voting period ends, without announcing intent to deputise to resolve it. CFJ 2399: Called by comex (04 Mar); Judged NOT GUILTY by Murphy (12 Mar) The PNP violated Power=2 Rule 2215 by distributing proposals without taking appropriate measures to prevent errors in them. CFJ 2398: Called by Murphy (03 Mar); Judged UNDETERMINED by ais523 (05 Mar) Murphy's daughter Victoria is a person. CFJ 2397: Called by comex (03 Mar); Judged TRUE by G. (05 Mar) ais523 can act on Murphy's behalf to cause Murphy to support ais523's own intent to make Einos (http://einos-nomic.blogspot.com/) a protectorate. CFJ 2396: Called by G. (02 Mar); Judged TRUE by Murphy (12 Mar) A conditional vote which would be clearly identify an option as defined by R2127 would clearly identify an option for the purposes of satisfying Rule 683(c). CFJ 2395: Called by G. (01 Mar); Judged FALSE by Wooble (05 Mar) If a player is required by a rule to do something by a time limit, and e deregisters before the time limit, then re-registers after the time limit expires (and didn't do the action), e has broken the rule either at, or immediately after, the time of eir re-registration. CFJ 2394: Called by Murphy (28 Feb); Judged FALSE by ais523 (03 Mar) A Notice of Violation pertaining to failure to act on time is necessarily invalid if the duty was first imposed before the adoption of Rule 2239, even if the deadline was not missed until after its adoption. CFJ 2393: Called by Murphy (28 Feb); Judged TRUE by Wooble (01 Mar) A Notice of Violation pertaining to failure to act on time is necessarily invalid if the deadline occurred before the adoption of Rule 2239, even if the action remained unperformed after its adoption. CFJ 2392: Called by G. (27 Feb); Judged FALSE by Murphy (28 Feb) The rulekeepor published the Short Logical Ruleset, on or about 19-Feb-09, in such a way as to satisfy that part of eir weekly duties. CFJ 2391: Called by Murphy (24 Feb); Judged FALSE by woggle (03 Mar) If a Power=1 rule was created with text "Upon the creation of this rule, the text of Proposal 6116 is changed to read 'CREAMPUFF'.", then it would succeed in changing the text of Proposal 6116. CFJ 2390: Called by Murphy (24 Feb); Judged TRUE by ehird (27 Feb) ehird initiated an inquiry case in the message archived at http://www.agoranomic.org/cgi-bin/mailman/private/agora-business/2008-November/016124.html CFJ 2389: Called by ais523 (21 Feb); Judged TRUE by woggle (24 Feb) The message with message-ID 499FB01A.1060101@socal.rr.com was successful in assigning an appeals opinion to CFJ 2355a. CFJ 2388: Called by G. (19 Feb); Judged NOT GUILTY by Taral (27 Feb) comex broke Rule 2215 by attempting to mislead persons as to the contents of R2125 in eir publication of the SLR on or about Feb 19, 2009. CFJ 2387: Called by ais523 (19 Feb); Judged TRUE by woggle (19 Mar) Warrigal is a party to The Small Partial Mousetrap. CFJ 2386: Called by Murphy (18 Feb); Judged TRUE by Wooble (25 Feb) On or about Wed, 18 Feb 2009 22:28:36 +0000, a rule was created or amended to contain the text "comex and ais523 were here". CFJ 2385: Called by Murphy (18 Feb); Judged FALSE by G. (24 Feb) On or about Wed, 18 Feb 2009 22:28:36 +0000, the AFO ceased to be a player. CFJ 2384: Called by Murphy (18 Feb); Judged TRUE by G. (24 Feb) On or about Tue, 10 Feb 2009 19:25:48 -0800, the AFO ceased to be a player. CFJ 2383: Called by ais523 (17 Feb); Judged GUILTY/SILENCE by Taral (24 Feb); AFFIRMED on Appeal (26 Feb) Sgeo violated rule 1750 by failing to read the ruleset during Read the Ruleset week, and also failing to understand or to carefully weigh the consequences of this failure. CFJ 2382: Called by Pavitra (13 Feb); Judged FALSE by G. (17 Feb) Warrigal CAN deregister. CFJ 2381: Called by Warrigal (13 Feb); Judged UNDETERMINED by G. (17 Feb) I am a party to some contract CFJ 2380: Called by Warrigal (13 Feb); Judged FALSE by G. (17 Feb) I am a player CFJ 2379: Called by comex (13 Feb); Judged TRUE by Murphy (14 Feb) It is possible to change the contestmaster of a contest through a contract-defined dependent action. CFJ 2378: Called by G. (11 Feb); Judged FALSE by ais523 (24 Feb) Rule 2238 is a power-3 rule. CFJ 2377: Called by ais523 (11 Feb); Judged TRUE by Wooble (15 Feb) Rule 2211 is a proposal. CFJ 2376: Called by comex (11 Feb); Judged FALSE by Murphy (14 Feb); OVERTURNED on Appeal (24 Feb); Judged TRUE by G. (24 Feb) It is possible for a Rule to change a proposal's text. CFJ 2375: Called by comex (09 Feb); Judged GUILTY/APOLOGY by woggle (10 Feb); REMANDED on Appeal (21 Feb); Judged GUILTY/DISCHARGE by woggle (24 Feb) Murphy violated R1868 (power 2) by failing to assign a judge to CFJ 2201 as soon as possible after it came to require a judge. CFJ 2374: Called by comex (09 Feb); Judged GUILTY/DISCHARGE by woggle (10 Feb) Murphy violated R1868 (power 2) by failing to assign a judge to CFJ 2171 as soon as possible after it came to require a judge. CFJ 2373: Called by comex (09 Feb); Judged GUILTY/APOLOGY by woggle (10 Feb); REMANDED on Appeal (21 Feb); Judged GUILTY/DISCHARGE by woggle (24 Feb) Murphy violated R1868 (power 2) by failing to assign a judge to CFJ 2163 as soon as possible after it came to require a judge. CFJ 2372: Called by comex (09 Feb); Judged GUILTY/DISCHARGE by woggle (10 Feb) Murphy violated R1868 (power 2) by failing to assign a judge to CFJ 2141 as soon as possible after it came to require a judge. CFJ 2371: Called by comex (09 Feb); Judged GUILTY/DISCHARGE by woggle (10 Feb) Murphy violated R1868 (power 2) by failing to assign a judge to CFJ 2140 as soon as possible after it came to require a judge. CFJ 2370: Called by comex (09 Feb); Judged GUILTY/SILENCE by woggle (10 Feb) Murphy violated R1868 (power 2) by failing to assign a judge to CFJ 2139 as soon as possible after it came to require a judge. CFJ 2369: Called by Wooble (06 Feb); Judged GUILTY/DISCHARGE by ais523 (10 Feb) Murphy violated R911 by failing to publish an appeals opinion to CFJ 2346a as soon as possible after the panel was assigned. CFJ 2368: Called by Wooble (06 Feb); Judged GUILTY/DISCHARGE by Taral (13 Feb) comex violated R911 by failing to publish an appeals opinion to CFJ 2346a as soon as possible after the panel was assigned. CFJ 2367: Called by ais523 (05 Feb); Judged TRUE by comex (21 Feb) There is a rule with ID number 2105. CFJ 2366: Called by comex (03 Feb); Judged FALSE by Wooble (10 Feb) Rule 2238's Power is over 9000. CFJ 2365: Called by comex (03 Feb); Judged TRUE by Wooble (10 Feb) Rule 2238 exists. CFJ 2364: Called by ais523 (02 Feb); Judged FALSE by G. (10 Feb) An Enforceable judgement in an equity case CAN generally create an ability for arbitrary persons to act on behalf of persons bound by the judgement CFJ 2363: Called by comex (01 Feb); Judged FALSE by Murphy (21 Feb) Rule 2198 was amended recently. CFJ 2362: Called by ais523 (31 Jan); Judged FALSE by Murphy (14 Feb) ais523 has the patent title of H. CFJ 2361: Called by G. (26 Jan); Judged FALSE by ais523 (18 Feb) If the Rules specify that a player is to receive a Note for performing a required (i.e. a SHALL) action, and e fails to perform it, the withholding of the Note is, for the purposes of R101(vi), a penalty for breaking the SHALL. CFJ 2360: Called by Wooble (26 Jan); Judged TRUE by G. (04 Feb) Assessor is a high-priority office. CFJ 2359: Called by Wooble (26 Jan); Judged FALSE by G. (04 Feb) Speaker is a high-priority office. CFJ 2358: Called by ehird (26 Jan); Judged FALSE by ais523 (02 Feb) If I submitted "The following is my Cantus Cygneus: {pigs are delicious!!}" to the Registrar, it would be a Cantus Cygneus CFJ 2357: Called by Murphy (26 Jan); Judged FALSE by woggle (28 Jan) On or about January 7, 2009, Wooble won. CFJ 2356: Called by comex (26 Jan); Judged GUILTY/DISCHARGE by Taral (15 Feb); REMANDED on Appeal (24 Feb); Judged NOT GUILTY by Taral (04 Mar) Wooble violated R2157 (power 1.7) by failing, collectively with woggle and comex, to ensure that the panel {woggle, comex, Wooble} assigned a judgement to CFJ 2087a. CFJ 2355: Called by comex (26 Jan); Judged GUILTY/DISCHARGE by Taral (15 Feb); REMANDED on Appeal (24 Feb); Judged NOT GUILTY by Taral (04 Mar) Wooble violated R2157 (power 1.7) by failing, collectively with woggle and comex, to ensure that the panel {woggle, comex, Wooble} assigned a judgement to CFJ 2086a. CFJ 2354: Called by ehird (26 Jan); Judged GUILTY/DISCHARGE by Taral (15 Feb) Wooble violated R2157 (power 1.7) by failing, collectively with cdm014 and avpx, to ensure that the panel {Wooble, cdm014, avpx} assigned a judgement to CFJ 2069a. CFJ 2353: Called by Wooble (26 Jan); Judged GUILTY/DISCHARGE by Taral (26 Jan) comex violated R2158 (power 2) by failing to assign a judgement to CFJ 2317 as soon as possible after e become assigned to it as Judge. CFJ 2352: Called by Wooble (26 Jan); Judged GUILTY/SILENCE by Taral (26 Jan) comex violated R2158 (power 2) by failing to assign a judgement to CFJ 2316 as soon as possible after e become assigned to it as Judge. CFJ 2351: Called by comex (26 Jan); Judged by woggle (07 Feb) ehird has, by repeatedly promising but neglecting to bring rutian up, caused Bayes to violate Rule 2143, which was not envisioned by the contract. CFJ 2350: Called by ais523 (20 Jan); Judged FALSE by comex (26 Jan) Any player can flip the Conductor's Key by announcement, at most once per month. CFJ 2349: Called by ais523 (20 Jan); Judged FALSE by G. (25 Jan) Murphy is leaning. CFJ 2348: Called by Wooble (17 Jan); Judged GUILTY/SILENCE by OscarMeyr (25 Jan) H. Notary w1n5t0n violated R2143 by failing to publish the Notary's monthly report in December. CFJ 2347: Called by ais523 (15 Jan); Judged GUILTY/APOLOGY by Taral (25 Jan) ehird selected a confusing nickname (the null string), which violates the power-3 Rule 2170. CFJ 2346: Called by ais523 (26 Dec); Judged by Wooble (27 Jan); REMANDED on Appeal (06 Feb); Judged by Wooble (06 Feb) ehird blatantly broke a SHALL requirement in the Scam Secrecy Contract by revealing my mousetrap (or attempted mousetrap) to a person who was not a member of that contract. CFJ 2345: Called by ais523 (12 Jan); Judged by Taral (25 Jan) The Fantasy Rules Contest contestmaster's inactivity has meant that a large number of points which should have been awarded by the contract have gone unawarded. CFJ 2344: Called by ais523 (12 Jan); Judged TRUE by ehird (25 Jan) Props are a type of asset. CFJ 2343: Called by ehird (10 Jan); Judged FALSE by Murphy (23 Jan) WoodsPam is a Player CFJ 2342: Called by Murphy (09 Jan); Judged FALSE by ais523 (21 Jan) ehird has gained a non-integral number of rests due to sentencing in CFJ 2326. CFJ 2341: Called by Murphy (09 Jan); Judged FALSE by ais523 (21 Jan) ehird has gained at least 4 rests due to sentencing in CFJ 2326. CFJ 2340: Called by Murphy (09 Jan); Judged FALSE by ais523 (21 Jan) ehird has gained at least 3 rests due to sentencing in CFJ 2326. CFJ 2339: Called by Murphy (09 Jan); Judged FALSE by ais523 (21 Jan) ehird has gained at least 2 rests due to sentencing in CFJ 2326. CFJ 2338: Called by Murphy (09 Jan); Judged TRUE by ais523 (21 Jan) ehird has gained at least 1 rest as a direct result of a message published by Murphy. CFJ 2337: Called by Murphy (09 Jan); Judged TRUE by ais523 (21 Jan) ehird has gained at least 1 rest as a direct result of a message published by OscarMeyr. CFJ 2336: Called by Murphy (09 Jan); Judged FALSE by ais523 (21 Jan) ehird has been sentenced in CFJ 2326 as a direct result of a message published by Murphy. CFJ 2335: Called by Murphy (09 Jan); Judged TRUE by ais523 (21 Jan) ehird has been sentenced in CFJ 2326 as a direct result of a message published by OscarMeyr. CFJ 2334: Called by ais523 (08 Jan); Judged TRUE by Murphy (23 Jan) If a player gives consent for other players to act on eir behalf without creating or modifying a contract for the purpose, such consent actually does allow those players to act on eir behalf. CFJ 2333: Called by ais523 (08 Jan); Judged FALSE by Murphy (04 Feb) If a rule were created with the text {{Wooble SHALL NOT Dance a Powerful Dance. Neither sentence of this rule has an effect.}}, then it would be ILLEGAL for Wooble to Dance a Powerful Dance. CFJ 2332: Called by Murphy (08 Jan); Judged FALSE by comex (20 Jan) In the message quoted in caller's evidence, ehird acted on behalf of Wooble to judge CFJ 2321. CFJ 2331: Called by w1n5t0n (07 Jan); Judged FALSE by comex (08 Jan) The current Speaker is Michael Norrish. CFJ 2330: Called by ais523 (07 Jan); Judged FALSE by Wooble (16 Jan) On or about December 28, 2008, ais523 achieved a Win by Points. CFJ 2329: Called by Sgeo (06 Jan); Judged FALSE by Wooble (08 Jan) On or about December 28, 2008, comex achieved a Win by Points CFJ 2328: Called by Wooble (06 Jan); Judged by OscarMeyr (25 Jan) ehird has failed, for 8 consecutive weeks, to publish a report as required by section 13 of the People's Bank of Agora contract. CFJ 2327: Called by ehird (06 Jan); Judged IRRELEVANT by Murphy (15 Jan) Michael Norrish is obligated to be Michael Norrish CFJ 2326: Called by Wooble (05 Jan); Judged GUILTY/SILENCE by OscarMeyr (09 Jan) ehird violated R2169 by eir continued failure to refuse to comply with the judgment in CFJ2239. CFJ 2325: Called by comex (05 Jan); Judged NOT GUILTY by Taral (08 Jan) j violated Rule 2170 by selecting (in B Nomic) a nickname that has generally been used to refer to another entity within the past three months. CFJ 2324: Called by Murphy (03 Jan); Judged TRUE by ais523 (12 Jan) Craig is a player. CFJ 2323: Called by Murphy (29 Dec); Judged TRUE by G. (08 Jan) ehird is a player. CFJ 2322: Called by Wooble (24 Dec); Judged TRUE by Murphy (15 Jan) It is possible for a private contract to create an ability of one party to act on behalf of another party. CFJ 2321: Called by G. (24 Dec); Judged FALSE by Wooble (07 Jan); OVERTURNED on Appeal (15 Jan); Judged FALSE by woggle (23 Jan) Rule 9842 exists. CFJ 2320: Called by ehird (23 Dec); Judged TRUE by ais523 (07 Jan) Four days and 5 hours from the time this CFJ was/will be called, it will be possible to object to the above intent. CFJ 2319: Called by ais523 (22 Dec); Judged FALSE by comex (23 Dec) 'e' is primarily used in a mathematical context, and therefore means 'approximately 2.718281828' when used in rules. CFJ 2318: Called by ehird (22 Dec); Judged NOT GUILTY by OscarMeyr (25 Dec) BobTHJ violated rule 2158 by assigning an inappropriate judgment in the message quoted in the message quoted in the message quoted. CFJ 2317: Called by Murphy (22 Dec); Judged UNDETERMINED by G. (26 Jan) No objection made by ehird in the message labeled "Caller's evidence, part 1 of 2" remained unwithdrawn after the publication of the message labeled "Caller's evidence, part 2 of 2". CFJ 2316: Called by Murphy (22 Dec); Judged FALSE by G. (26 Jan) Objecting to the performance of a dependent action is not ineffective solely because the objection is published before the intent to perform that action is published. CFJ 2315: Called by ais523 (20 Dec); Judged UNDETERMINED by G. (23 Dec) It is legal for a judge to judge FALSE on at least one CFJ that Warrigal called between 21:00 -0500 and 22:00 -0500 on Thu, 2008-12-18. CFJ 2314: Called by Warrigal (19 Dec); Judged FALSE by woggle (15 Jan) If a CFJ were called on X on December 20 this year, it would be legal to judge FALSE on the CFJ, where X is defined as the following string, followed by a quotation mark, followed by the same string, followed by a quotation mark: "If a CFJ were called on X on December 20 this year, it would be legal to judge FALSE on the CFJ, where X is defined as the following string, followed by a quotation mark, followed by the same string, followed by a quotation mark: " CFJ 2313: Called by Warrigal (16 Dec); Judged IRRELEVANT by BobTHJ (22 Dec) If a CFJ were called on X, it would be legal to judge FALSE on the CFJ, where X is defined as the following string, followed by a quotation mark, followed by the same string, followed by a quotation mark: "If a CFJ were called on X, it would be legal to judge FALSE on the CFJ, where X is defined as the following string, followed by a quotation mark, followed by the same string, followed by a quotation mark: " CFJ 2312: Called by comex (15 Dec); Judged GUILTY/SILENCE by OscarMeyr (09 Jan) root violated Rule 2143 by not publishing the Conductor's report last week. CFJ 2311: Called by ehird (15 Dec); Judged TRUE by G. (05 Jan) I have some rests. CFJ 2310: Called by ais523 (12 Dec); Judged by Taral (28 Dec) Warrigal informed the PerlNomic server that e wished to be a party to the PNP (by taking a PerlNomic game action), and yet claimed to Agora that e was not party to the contract. CFJ 2309: Called by ehird (11 Dec); Judged TRUE by Wooble (23 Dec) ehird is a party to the Vote Market CFJ 2308: Called by ehird (10 Dec); Judged GUILTY/DISCHARGE by Taral (19 Dec) The PNP violated rule 1607 by distributing a retracted proposal. CFJ 2307: Called by Warrigal (10 Dec); Judged NOT GUILTY by OscarMeyr (19 Dec) The PerlNomic Partnership violated Rule 2215 by announcing that I am a party to it in the quoted message. CFJ 2306: Called by Sgeo (09 Dec); Judged TRUE by comex (23 Dec) P17 has the Patent Title of Left in a Huff CFJ 2305: Called by ais523 (08 Dec); Judged TRUE by Murphy (23 Dec) If BobTHJ does not retract nor cast any further votes on the Agoran decision on whether to adopt proposal 6011 for the rest of its voting period, nor explicitly define eir current votes on that proposal in the future, e will have at least one valid vote on that decision" CFJ 2304: Called by Warrigal (08 Dec); Judged UNDETERMINED by Wooble (10 Dec) It is a thing. CFJ 2303: Called by OscarMeyr (07 Dec); Judged TRUE by harblcat (11 Dec); REMANDED on Appeal (18 Dec); Judged FALSE by ais523 (15 Jan) ehird successfully changed eir name to a null string on or about 5 December 2008 21:53:02 UTC. CFJ 2302: Called by ehird (07 Dec); Judged TRUE by G. (12 Dec) Warrigal MAY transfer assets CFJ 2301: Called by Wooble (25 Nov); Judged GUILTY/FINE by OscarMeyr (10 Dec) BobTHJ violated Rule 2143 by not publishing the Scorekeepor's report last week. CFJ 2300: Called by ais523 (05 Dec); Judged FALSE by Murphy (11 Dec) The Executor of the public message that purported to initiate the Agoran Decisions on whether to adopt proposals 5686-5687 cannot be determined with reasonable effort, other than via a judicial declaration. CFJ 2299: Called by Sgeo (05 Dec); Judged TRUE by BobTHJ (11 Dec) Pavitra has won on or about December 3rd, 2008. CFJ 2298: Called by Wooble (04 Dec); Judged TRUE by ais523 (07 Jan) Pavitra has a Violet ribbon. CFJ 2297: Called by comex (04 Dec); Judged TRUE by Wooble (07 Dec) The office of Notary has at least one Vote Point. CFJ 2296: Called by Murphy (03 Dec); Judged TRUE by harblcat (07 Dec) Pavitra gained 20 points due to the Werewolves contract within the past week. CFJ 2295: Called by Sgeo (01 Dec); Judged GUILTY/FINE by Taral (11 Dec) BobTHJ failed to assign prerogatives for December in a timely fashion before the beginning of the month, as required by Rule 2019. CFJ 2294: Called by Wooble (29 Nov); Judged FALSE by Elysion (13 Dec) Warrigal has a Red Ribbon. CFJ 2293: Called by comex (26 Nov); Judged ALREADY TRIED by Taral (28 Nov) I violated Rule 1742 by violating the P100 contract by causing P100 to register with the same basis as another player. CFJ 2292: Called by Warrigal (26 Nov); Judged TRUE by G. (04 Dec) Right now, I send a message to a public forum explicitly stating that I do not deregister. CFJ 2291: Called by 0x44 (26 Nov); Judged FALSE by Warrigal (28 Nov) Are 100 chaos potential mass chaos? CFJ 2290: Called by ais523 (25 Nov); Judged UNDETERMINED by BobTHJ (27 Nov) The Ambassador CAN flip Wooble's Recognition to Friendly without objection. CFJ 2289: Called by ehird (25 Nov); Judged TRUE by Elysion (01 Dec) The PRS is a contest CFJ 2288: Called by ehird (25 Nov); Judged TRUE by ais523 (30 Nov) The Vote Market is a contract. CFJ 2287: Called by Wooble (25 Nov); Judged FALSE by comex (26 Nov) Fookiemyartug is a party to the Vote Market contract. CFJ 2286: Called by Warrigal (24 Nov); Judged TRUE by Murphy (11 Dec) As Rule 1023 defines the terms, a unit of text consisting entirely of the string "CHAPTER I" is enumerated. CFJ 2285: Called by Warrigal (24 Nov); Judged TRUE by Murphy (11 Dec) As Rule 1023 defines the terms, a unit of text consisting entirely of the string "1993:" is enumerated. CFJ 2284: Called by OscarMeyr (23 Nov); Judged FALSE by Murphy (25 Nov) Pet A is a player. CFJ 2283: Called by Warrigal (22 Nov); Judged FALSE by G. (25 Nov) Becoming a player of B Nomic constitutes Agoran agreement to its ruleset. CFJ 2282: Called by ehird (19 Nov); Judged FALSE by Murphy (25 Nov); REMANDED on Appeal (19 Jan); Judged FALSE by Murphy (23 Jan) comex's annotation to Rule 1367 worked. CFJ 2281: Called by Murphy (19 Nov); Judged TRUE by BobTHJ (05 Dec) CFJ 2252 exists. CFJ 2280: Called by ais523 (17 Nov); Judged SLIPPERY by Taral (30 Nov) Wooble violated rule 2215 by making a public statement in the above-quoted message designed to mislead others as to its effectiveness. CFJ 2279: Called by Murphy (18 Nov); Judged TRUE by G. (19 Nov) ehird did not create a rule titled "Last Resort" on or about Tue, 18 Nov 2008 16:34:39 +0000. CFJ 2278: Called by Murphy (18 Nov); Judged TRUE by Wooble (20 Nov); AFFIRMED on Appeal (12 Dec) Proposal 5962 has not been adopted. CFJ 2277: Called by Murphy (18 Nov); Judged TRUE by Wooble (20 Nov); AFFIRMED on Appeal (12 Dec) Proposal 5961 has not been adopted. CFJ 2276: Called by Murphy (18 Nov); Judged TRUE by Wooble (20 Nov); OVERRULED to FALSE on Appeal (12 Dec) Proposal 5956 has not been adopted. CFJ 2275: Called by Sgeo (18 Nov); Judged FALSE by ais523 (22 Nov) "P2, at least you get the little lowercase w in the Registrar's Report, and a Patent Title, as compensation." correctly awards P2 the Patent title Left in a Huff CFJ 2274: Called by root (17 Nov); Judged TRUE by Warrigal (20 Nov); OVERTURNED on Appeal (03 Dec); Judged TRUE by Elysion (13 Dec) The Agoran decisions of whether to adopt proposals 5956 and 5962 are democratic. CFJ 2273: Called by woggle (17 Nov); Judged GUILTY/CHOKEY by OscarMeyr (25 Nov); AFFIRMED on Appeal (04 Dec) comex violated rule 1742 by violating the P100 contract by causing P100 to register with the same basis as another player. CFJ 2272: Called by Murphy (17 Nov); Judged IRRELEVANT by Elysion (22 Nov) Rule 2192 does not allow ehird to act on its behalf to create a new Rule by announcement which includes the title, text, and power of the new rule. CFJ 2271: Called by Elysion (17 Nov); Judged FALSE by BobTHJ (20 Nov) None of the attempted registrations (P1 through P100) in comex's quoted message were succesful. CFJ 2270: Called by Murphy (17 Nov); Judged FALSE by ais523 (08 Dec) Neither Proposal 5956 nor Proposal 5962 has been adopted. CFJ 2269: Called by comex (17 Nov); Judged IRRELEVANT by Murphy (17 Nov) ehird is a Walrus. CFJ 2268: Called by comex (17 Nov); Judged IRRELEVANT by Murphy (17 Nov) ehird is a Walrus. CFJ 2267: Called by ais523 (15 Nov); Judged FALSE by Wooble (15 Nov) P9 is a contest CFJ 2266: Called by root (14 Nov); Judged TRUE by comex (26 Nov) The Burgundy Contract is a partnership. CFJ 2265: Called by Wooble (14 Nov); Judged TRUE by comex (26 Nov) The Corleone Partnership was a player at some time in the past. CFJ 2264: Called by Wooble (11 Nov); Judged TRUE by ais523 (22 Nov) Contracts CAN be amended by a mechanism other than unanimous consent of all parties. CFJ 2263: Called by ehird (11 Nov); Judged TRUE by Murphy (11 Nov) SDONATE(1VP - FOR) is a valid conditional vote. CFJ 2262: Called by ais523 (09 Nov); Judged TRUE by root (13 Nov) Warrigal submitted exactly one proposal in the quoted message CFJ 2261: Called by ehird (09 Nov); Judged UNDETERMINED by Warrigal (11 Nov) (see evidence) CFJ 2260: Called by ehird (08 Nov); Judged IRRELEVANT by comex (11 Nov); REMANDED on Appeal (20 Nov); Judged IRRELEVANT by G. (15 Jan) If the purported backing document for Annoyances as specified in the message purporting to define them existed, at least one Annoyance would exist CFJ 2259: Called by Wooble (06 Nov); Judged FALSE by BobTHJ (11 Nov) A passed proposal CAN flip a switch to a value to which, by rule, the switch CANNOT be flipped. CFJ 2258: Called by root (06 Nov); Judged TRUE by Murphy (08 Nov) The proposal submitted by root at or around Wed, 5 Nov 2008 22:03:48 UTC has been distributed. CFJ 2257: Called by Murphy (06 Nov); Judged FALSE by ais523 (14 Nov) Creating a pledge in a public message constitutes an implicit but nevertheless clear indication that it will be public when it forms, unless published with an explicit and clear indication to the contrary. CFJ 2256: Called by Murphy (06 Nov); Judged FALSE by ais523 (14 Nov) Creating a contract in a public message constitutes an implicit but nevertheless clear indication that it will be public when it forms, unless published with an explicit and clear indication to the contrary. CFJ 2255: Called by BobTHJ (04 Nov); Judged by OscarMeyr (25 Nov) The buggy automated WRV enforcement e-mail should not have been sent. CFJ 2254: Called by Sgeo (03 Nov); Judged by OscarMeyr (23 Nov) ehird, comex, Quazie, and myself have failed to meet their obligations per section 10 of the Vote Market agreement. CFJ 2253: Called by comex (03 Nov); Judged FALSE by BobTHJ (10 Nov) Filling out this form and forwarding the result to a Public Forum would cause a person to become a player: http://www.registrar.uwaterloo.ca/forms/LetterOfPermission.pdf CFJ 2252: Called by ehird (03 Nov); Judged IRRELEVANT by comex (25 Nov) (the rules of Agora) CFJ 2251: Called by Murphy (02 Nov); Judged FALSE by Wooble (08 Nov) At least one Annoyance exists. CFJ 2250: Called by G. (02 Nov); Judged FALSE by root (13 Nov) All non-public pledges with no more than one party that existed at the time of passage of Proposal 5817 are null and void (i.e. no longer exist). CFJ 2249: Called by Warrigal (31 Oct); Judged TRUE by ais523 (14 Nov) There is an asset known as the Terre Haute CFJ 2248: Called by G. (30 Oct); Judged FALSE by Murphy (02 Nov); AFFIRMED on Appeal (12 Nov) Goethe is required by the GREETINGS TO YOU SIR pledge to send a United States Dollar that is issued/backed by the United States government (outside of Agora) to root asap. CFJ 2247: Called by ais523 (30 Oct); Judged FALSE by G. (08 Nov) The Notary SHALL publish the fact that ais523 owns a Pain called "xyzzy" as part of eir weekly report. CFJ 2246: Called by Taral (30 Oct); Judged FALSE by ais523 (10 Nov) CFJ 2245 was retracted. CFJ 2245: Called by BobTHJ (30 Oct); Judged by Taral (25 Nov) The Protection Racket was clearly not envisioned as an entrapment scheme for one or more of its parties. CFJ 2244: Called by G. (27 Oct); Judged FALSE by Murphy (30 Oct) "CFJ 2223" is an equity case. CFJ 2243: Called by BobTHJ (27 Oct); Judged by Taral (11 Nov) ais523 should only have gotten 1 point from the above cashout since e only had 1 PV. He attempted to withdraw a second PV from the PBA, but this transaction failed (something which I only now discovered). CFJ 2242: Called by ais523 (27 Oct); Judged FALSE by root (13 Nov) The Internomic Investment Bank is a player CFJ 2241: Called by ais523 (27 Oct); Judged by OscarMeyr (13 Nov) due to comex's actions with respect to the PBA, it is now very difficult to determine the number of AAA-defined assets comex and the PBA hold without unreasonable effort on the part of multiple recordkeepors. CFJ 2240: Called by OscarMeyr (25 Oct); Judged TRUE by ais523 (30 Oct) The player ais523 sent the above message. CFJ 2239: Called by Wooble (23 Oct); Judged by root (13 Nov) ehird and BobTHJ are, and have been for quite some time, in material breach of Section 11 of the contract by remaining Supine and thus ineligible to judge CFJs. CFJ 2238: Called by comex (22 Oct); Judged TRUE by Wooble (04 Nov) When a person performs an action that takes parameters, e must unambiguously specify the parameters. CFJ 2237: Called by ais523 (22 Oct); Judged FALSE by root (27 Oct) Warrigal is party to a public contract called the UNDAD CFJ 2236: Called by Wooble (22 Oct); Judged TRUE by BobTHJ (02 Nov) The Ambassador CAN, without objection, flip the recognition of the nomic played in the IRC channel ##nomic with the name 'One True Agora' to Hostile. CFJ 2235: Called by Wooble (21 Oct); Judged TRUE by root (13 Nov) The IADoP SHALL initiate an Agoran Decision to choose the Registrar with the options of Bayes and ais523. CFJ 2234: Called by Wooble (21 Oct); Judged FALSE by root (13 Nov) The Monster is the Registrar. CFJ 2233: Called by G. (18 Oct); Judged FALSE by comex (27 Oct) HAL is a first-class player. CFJ 2232: Called by Warrigal (17 Oct); Judged FALSE by ais523 (27 Oct) A moment ago, I satisfied the Winning Condition of Renaissance. CFJ 2231: Called by ais523 (17 Oct); Judged FALSE by Murphy (26 Oct) Ivan Hope CXXVII was a player at the time e most recently attempted to ratify the Registrar's Report. CFJ 2230: Called by Murphy (16 Oct); Judged FALSE by root (29 Oct) The Mad Scientist CAN act on behalf of the Monster to take an action that the Monster MAY, but CANNOT, take. CFJ 2229: Called by ais523 (14 Oct); Judged INNOCENT by OscarMeyr (21 Oct) Goethe violated rule 2173 by neither informing the Notary of the text and set of parties of UNDEAD, nor understanding and carefully weighing the full implications of failing to do so. CFJ 2228: Called by root (15 Oct); Judged FALSE by Wooble (30 Oct) ais523 or the Monster resolved the Agoran Decision to to choose the holder of the Mad Scientist office on or around October 13, 2008. CFJ 2227: Called by Warrigal (15 Oct); Judged FALSE by ais523 (20 Oct) I created a pledge in the above quote from ##nomic. CFJ 2226: Called by Taral (14 Oct); Judged FALSE by Murphy (23 Oct) People who do not control the bayes.py script CANNOT join Bayes. CFJ 2225: Called by Taral (13 Oct); Judged FALSE by comex (30 Oct) Taral's attempted vote of SELL(3VP) on the most recent Mad Scientist election constitutes a pledge. CFJ 2224: Called by Taral (13 Oct); Judged FALSE by comex (30 Oct) Taral directly or indirectly voted for someone in the most recent Mad Scientist election. CFJ 2222: Called by ais523 (13 Oct); Judged FALSE by Wooble (16 Oct) Ivan Hope CXXVII has the Patent Title of Left in a Huff. CFJ 2221: Called by Wooble (13 Oct); Judged FALSE by G. (08 Nov) Wooble caused the Reformed Bank of Agora to transfer 3 crops to em a moment ago. CFJ 2220: Called by Wooble (11 Oct); Judged UNDETERMINED by G. (20 Oct) If Ivan Hope takes actions in the PerlNomic game which cause em to become an active player of PerlNomic, e will become a party to the PerlNomic Partnership contract. CFJ 2219: Called by Warrigal (10 Oct); Judged FALSE by root (16 Oct) Nomic 217 is a nomic. CFJ 2218: Called by ehird (10 Oct); Judged by BobTHJ (02 Nov); OVERTURNED on Appeal (02 Nov); Judged by OscarMeyr (13 Nov) It was clearly not envisioned that the Russian Roulette text inside the zip would be revealed. CFJ 2217: Called by Murphy (10 Oct); Judged FALSE by woggle (20 Oct) If only comex had been given the password referenced in the Russian Roulette contract and a reasonable amount of time to review the section of the contract encrypted using that password, then the AFO would be bound by that contract. CFJ 2216: Called by Murphy (10 Oct); Judged FALSE by woggle (20 Oct) If only Murphy had been given the password referenced in the Russian Roulette contract and a reasonable amount of time to review the section of the contract encrypted using that password, then the AFO would be bound by that contract. CFJ 2215: Called by woggle (10 Oct); Judged by Taral (12 Nov) BobTHJ created 11 crops in ais523's possession when e should have only created 9 [3 for harvesting 911, 6 for harvesting 869]. CFJ 2214: Called by ehird (07 Oct); Judged INNOCENT by Taral (13 Oct) Wooble violated 2170 for claiming to be tusho (an old name of mine). CFJ 2213: Called by comex (07 Oct); Judged TRUE by ais523 (09 Oct); OVERTURNED on Appeal (24 Oct); Judged FALSE by G. (07 Nov) The Patent Title Scamster has been revoked from come. CFJ 2212: Called by Wooble (07 Oct); Judged TRUE by Murphy (16 Oct) An IRC channel is a forum. CFJ 2211: Called by root (07 Oct); Judged TRUE by comex (22 Oct) It is POSSIBLE to perform game actions via the #really-a-cow forum. CFJ 2210: Called by woggle (05 Oct); Judged GUILTY/APOLOGY by Taral (22 Oct) The Law-abiding Partnership broke Rule 2148 by claiming to be the ambassador. CFJ 2209: Called by comex (05 Oct); Judged TRUE by root (13 Oct) There exists at least one partnership that is a person. CFJ 2208: Called by comex (05 Oct); Judged TRUE by root (13 Oct) The Law-abiding Partnership is a person. CFJ 2207: Called by comex (03 Oct); Judged UNDETERMINED by Wooble (23 Oct) I am Dvorak Herring. CFJ 2206: Called by ais523 (02 Oct); Judged FALSE by G. (09 Oct) I transferred at least 2 Chits to the PerlNomic Partnership today CFJ 2205: Called by ehird (02 Oct); Judged FALSE by woggle (15 Oct) This CFJ was initiated or will be initiated at midnight, 1 July 2008. CFJ 2204: Called by ais523 (02 Oct); Judged FALSE by Wooble (09 Oct) At the end of the voting period of the Agoran Decision on whether to adopt proposal 5707, BobTHJ had 5 valid unretracted conditional votes that resolved to votes FOR that decision. CFJ 2203: Called by root (01 Oct); Judged TRUE by Wooble (02 Oct); OVERRULED to FALSE on Appeal (29 Oct) root cast at least one unretracted vote of AGAINST on Proposal 5707. CFJ 2202: Called by Wooble (01 Oct); Judged FALSE by root (07 Oct) Proposal 5707 is a democratic proposal. CFJ 2201: Called by Wooble (30 Sep); Judged TRUE by ais523 (08 Oct) The ratification of the Short Logical Ruleset CAN cause the text of a rule to change. CFJ 2200: Called by Warrigal (28 Sep); Judged TRUE by Sir Toby (04 Oct) This CFJ will exist one second from now. CFJ 2199: Called by Warrigal (27 Sep); Judged FALSE by Murphy (28 Sep) Including "From: root <root@normish.org>" in the email header constitutes a claim to be Ian Kelly (a.k.a. root). CFJ 2198: Called by root (26 Sep); Judged FALSE by ais523 (24 Oct) BobTHJ and root won the game on September 26, 2008 UTC. CFJ 2197: Called by ais523 (25 Sep); Judged FALSE by G. (29 Sep) The CotC CAN assign a judge to a CFJ initiated in the quoted message. CFJ 2196: Called by Wooble (25 Sep); Judged TRUE by ais523 (01 Oct); REMANDED on Appeal (16 Oct); Judged TRUE by ais523 (21 Oct); OVERRULED to FALSE on Appeal (23 Oct) The nomic in which this CFJ is being judged is a foreign nomic. CFJ 2195: Called by ehird (25 Sep); Judged FALSE by ais523 (28 Sep) The computer by which I am sending this email is a nomic. CFJ 2194: Called by ais523 (24 Sep); Judged FALSE by G. (29 Sep) Phill has a White Ribbon. CFJ 2193: Called by G. (24 Sep); Judged GUILTY/CHOKEY by OscarMeyr (07 Oct) tusho violated Rule 2170 by publishing a message purportedly from "phill" and registering as a player. CFJ 2192: Called by ehird (24 Sep); Judged TRUE by Wooble (29 Sep) tusho has been a player at some point in time CFJ 2191: Called by ehird (24 Sep); Judged TRUE by Wooble (29 Sep) tusho is a player CFJ 2190: Called by ehird (24 Sep); Judged TRUE by Wooble (29 Sep) tusho is a person CFJ 2189: Called by ehird (24 Sep); Judged TRUE by Sir Toby (04 Oct) Phill is a player CFJ 2188: Called by ehird (24 Sep); Judged TRUE by Sir Toby (04 Oct) Phill is a first-class person CFJ 2187: Called by ehird (24 Sep); Judged TRUE by Sir Toby (04 Oct) Phill is a person CFJ 2186: Called by ehird (24 Sep); Judged TRUE by woggle (02 Oct) Phill sent the message quoted (as evidence #1 - eir registration) CFJ 2185: Called by ehird (24 Sep); Judged TRUE by Murphy (28 Sep) I am tusho. CFJ 2184: Called by ehird (24 Sep); Judged TRUE by Murphy (28 Sep) I am Phill. CFJ 2183: Called by Sir Toby (24 Sep); Judged TRUE by root (07 Oct) It is impossible to assign a judge to the CFJ allegedly initiated in the message sent by "agoran@live.com" on "Tue, 16 Sep 2008 20:16:23 +0000" (see evidence 1) without revealing some information regarding who did or did not send the message. CFJ 2182: Called by Sir Toby (24 Sep); Judged FALSE by comex (28 Sep) The message sent by "celestialcognition@gmail.com" on "Sat, 20 Sep 2008 22:21:09 -0500" (see evidence 1) was successful in initiating a CFJ. CFJ 2181: Called by root (23 Sep); Judged UNIMPUGNED by Taral (05 Oct) root broke Rule 2170 by making the statement "I am comex.". CFJ 2180: Called by Anonymous (23 Sep); Judged UNDETERMINED by Sir Toby (04 Oct) The message sent by "agoran@live.com" on "Mon, 15 Sep 2008 20:15:58 +0000" was successful in submitting a proposal. CFJ 2179: Called by Sir Toby (23 Sep); Judged TRUE by woggle (02 Oct) The message sent by "agoran@live.com" on "Tue, 16 Sep 2008 20:16:23 +0000" (see evidence 1) was successful in initiating a CFJ. CFJ 2178: Called by ais523 (23 Sep); Judged FALSE by Murphy (28 Sep) If a non-pledge contract has no parties, it can be amended by unanimous consent of its parties. CFJ 2177: Called by Warrigal (22 Sep); Judged FALSE by Wooble (28 Sep) I am Mr. Elbow. CFJ 2176: Called by Warrigal (22 Sep); Judged TRUE by G. (29 Sep) Wolfram Blitzen is the owner of a Twin Sister. CFJ 2175: Called by Warrigal (22 Sep); Judged FALSE by woggle (01 Oct) Mr. Elbow SHALL register as soon as possible. CFJ 2174: Called by Warrigal (22 Sep); Judged TRUE by woggle (01 Oct) Ivan Hope CXXVII can act on behalf of Mr. Elbow by announcement CFJ 2173: Called by Warrigal (22 Sep); Judged TRUE by woggle (01 Oct) Mr. Elbow is a person. CFJ 2172: Called by ais523 (22 Sep); Judged TRUE by root (07 Oct); REMANDED on Appeal (02 Nov); Judged FALSE by root (13 Nov) The Monster is a person CFJ 2171: Called by Sgeo (20 Sep); Judged TRUE by ais523 (28 Sep) If a person who is bound by an equity agreement fails to fulfill eir obligations to the agreement, and the judge attempts to act on eir behalf, but there are 3 or more objections to the attempt, the person who failed to fulfill eir obligations may be liable for a criminal punishment other than discharge. CFJ 2170: Called by ais523 (20 Sep); Judged FALSE by woggle (23 Sep) There is a contract called The Agoran Civil Service. CFJ 2169: Called by Warrigal (18 Sep); Judged FALSE by root (25 Sep) If two persons agreed to Normish, it would become a contract. CFJ 2168: Called by Warrigal (18 Sep); Judged TRUE by root (25 Sep) Normish is a nomic. CFJ 2167: Called by ais523 (18 Sep); Judged TRUE by Murphy (16 Oct) ais523 is the Monsterkeepor. CFJ 2166: Called by G. (16 Sep); Judged FALSE by ais523 (26 Sep) This is a CFJ. CFJ 2165: Called by comex (16 Sep); Judged UNDETERMINED by G. (23 Sep) Attributes of a person such as whether e is biological, wearing a hat, the same as another person, etc. can be ratified. CFJ 2164: Called by comex (16 Sep); Judged UNDETERMINED by Sir Toby (23 Sep) I submitted a proposal in my recent post CFJ 2163: Called by comex (14 Sep); Judged TRUE by Murphy (28 Sep) The text of a proposal cannot have any effect whatsoever on whether the proposal takes effect, except by influencing votes on the proposal, and as explictly stated by the Rules. CFJ 2162: Called by root (14 Sep); Judged TRUE by comex (20 Sep) A proposal that takes retroactive effect does so by modifying the gamestate of the present, not by altering events in the past. CFJ 2161: Called by root (14 Sep); Judged TRUE by Wooble (23 Sep) If Rule 1742 is upmutated to power 2, and the /dev/null contract continues to have no parties, it will remain a contract. CFJ 2160: Called by root (14 Sep); Judged TRUE by Wooble (23 Sep); OVERRULED to FALSE on Appeal (24 Sep) The /dev/null contract has at least one party. CFJ 2159: Called by root (14 Sep); Judged TRUE by Wooble (23 Sep) /dev/null is a contract. CFJ 2158: Called by comex (14 Sep); Judged by woggle (23 Sep) Goethe pledged to lead / an effort to grant title / but no new Bard yet. CFJ 2157: Called by ais523 (09 Sep); Judged FALSE by Wooble (08 Oct) Any player may terminate the above-quoted pledge by announcement. CFJ 2156: Called by ais523 (09 Sep); Judged FALSE by Wooble (08 Oct) Sgeo may terminate the above-quoted pledge by announcement. CFJ 2155: Called by Warrigal (08 Sep); Judged FALSE by Murphy (20 Sep) The Speaker for the current game of Agora shall be Michael Norrish. CFJ 2154: Called by Warrigal (08 Sep); Judged TRUE by Murphy (20 Sep) The Speaker for the first game shall be Michael Norrish. CFJ 2153: Called by comex (08 Sep); Judged FALSE by Wooble (14 Sep) Randy Pausch is a person. CFJ 2152: Called by G. (02 Sep); Judged GUILTY/APOLOGY by OscarMeyr (28 Sep) pikhq violated rule 2019 by failing to assign prerogatives for August 2008 in a timely fashion before August 1. CFJ 2151: Called by Warrigal (05 Sep); Judged TRUE by G. (08 Oct) A moment ago, I revealed that my age is a composite number by announcement. CFJ 2150: Called by Warrigal (05 Sep); Judged FALSE by G. (20 Oct) A moment ago, I landed on the moon by announcement. CFJ 2149: Called by Warrigal (05 Sep); Judged TRUE by G. (08 Oct) A moment ago, I celebrated by announcement. CFJ 2148: Called by comex (03 Sep); Judged by Wooble (03 Nov) tusho has violated section 15 of the AAA agreement. CFJ 2147: Called by ais523 (04 Sep); Judged FALSE by comex (14 Sep) This CFH has ID number 1. CFJ 2146: Called by ais523 (04 Sep); Judged TRUE by comex (14 Sep) This CFJ has ID number 2146. CFJ 2145: Called by ehird (29 Aug); Judged UNDETERMINED by BobTHJ (08 Sep) People will thank me for this fifth CFJ. CFJ 2144: Called by ehird (29 Aug); Judged UNDETERMINED by BobTHJ (08 Sep) People will thank me for this fourth CFJ. CFJ 2143: Called by ehird (29 Aug); Judged UNDETERMINED by BobTHJ (08 Sep) People will thank me for this third CFJ. CFJ 2142: Called by ehird (29 Aug); Judged UNDETERMINED by BobTHJ (08 Sep) People will thank me for this second CFJ. CFJ 2141: Called by ehird (29 Aug); Judged UNDETERMINED by BobTHJ (08 Sep) People will thank me for this first CFJ. CFJ 2140: Called by Warrigal (29 Aug); Judged TRUE by Murphy (08 Sep) The rulesets of Agoroo A and Agoroo B are separate nomic rulesets. CFJ 2139: Called by Warrigal (29 Aug); Judged TRUE by Murphy (08 Sep) Agoroo A and Agoroo B are separate nomics. CFJ 2138: Called by Murphy (15 Aug); Judged FALSE by G. (15 Aug) If a partner acts on behalf of a partnership to transfer an asset, it is still the partner's asset that is transferred (provided that e has such an asset, and that the transfer is otherwise POSSIBLE). CFJ 2137: Called by Murphy (15 Aug); Judged FALSE by G. (15 Aug) If a partner acts on behalf of a partnership to cast a vote, that vote is still cast by that partner, and is thus subject to that partner's voting limit. CFJ 2136: Called by comex (14 Aug); Judged TRUE by Murphy (08 Sep) CFJ 2050 was filed by ehird CFJ 2135: Called by Quazie (13 Aug); Judged FALSE by Murphy (22 Aug) Quazie's activity switch was flipped to inactive by the above message. CFJ 2134: Called by cmealerjr (13 Aug); Judged UNDETERMINED by root (08 Sep) Gender Neutral pronouns(e.g eir, e, and e's) are words granted meaning and usage under the set of rules excluding 754(4). CFJ 2133: Called by ehird (09 Aug); Judged FALSE by Wooble (15 Aug) "<Speech act>. The previous sentence is false." results in <speech act> being performed. CFJ 2132: Called by ehird (09 Aug); Judged TRUE by Sgeo (10 Aug); OVERTURNED on Appeal (02 Oct); Judged FALSE by comex (09 Oct) I am sitting. CFJ 2131: Called by ehird (09 Aug); Judged TRUE by comex (10 Aug) I am a player. CFJ 2130: Called by ehird (09 Aug); Judged TRUE by comex (10 Aug) tusho is a player. CFJ 2129: Called by ehird (08 Aug); Judged TRUE by Wooble (09 Aug) A player can be nominated to be Rulekeepor. CFJ 2128: Called by Sgeo (08 Aug); Judged UNDETERMINED by G. (09 Aug) I violated Rule 2149 by claiming that I lie when I did not, in fact lie. CFJ 2127: Called by Wooble (05 Aug); Judged FALSE by Murphy (09 Aug) The devolution of the AFO's obligations onto comex means that the AFO is in breach of the AAA agreement if comex calls CFJs for the clear purpose of allowing the CFJ to harvest their ID numbers. CFJ 2126: Called by comex (05 Aug); Judged IRRELEVANT by BobTHJ (10 Aug) I need more Water Rights Vouchers! CFJ 2125: Called by comex (05 Aug); Judged IRRELEVANT by BobTHJ (10 Aug) I need more Water Rights Vouchers! CFJ 2124: Called by comex (05 Aug); Judged IRRELEVANT by BobTHJ (10 Aug) I need more Water Rights Vouchers! CFJ 2123: Called by comex (05 Aug); Judged IRRELEVANT by BobTHJ (10 Aug) I need more Water Rights Vouchers! CFJ 2122: Called by comex (05 Aug); Judged IRRELEVANT by BobTHJ (10 Aug) I need more Water Rights Vouchers! CFJ 2121: Called by G. (04 Aug); Judged FALSE by woggle (14 Aug) The Speaker CAN assign prerogatives for September 2008. CFJ 2120: Called by G. (04 Aug); Judged TRUE by woggle (14 Aug) The Speaker CAN assign prerogatives for August 2008. CFJ 2119: Called by ehird (04 Aug); Judged by woggle (14 Oct) ihope has not ascended the game and is not performing the action of ascending the game at this moment. CFJ 2118: Called by Wooble (04 Aug); Judged FALSE by G. (15 Sep) A judicial finding has determined that X, for the purposes of R2125 and R2161, if and only if a CFJ directly inquiring into the veracity of either X or not X has a judgment of TRUE or FALSE respectively. CFJ 2117: Called by Warrigal (29 Jul); Judged TRUE by Sgeo (04 Aug) Posting the string [ed: moved to evidence due to length] to a Public Forum would be Monstrous Consent. CFJ 2116: Called by Wooble (28 Jul); Judged UNDETERMINED by comex (10 Aug) The contract quoted above currently has Ivan Hope CXXVII as a party. CFJ 2115: Called by Warrigal (28 Jul); Judged UNDECIDABLE by woggle (18 Aug) Immediately after a judge is assigned to this case, it will be legal for that judge to judge FALSE on its question on veracity. CFJ 2114: Called by Quazie (25 Jul); Judged TRUE by BobTHJ (04 Aug) If an entity is not elgible to own a particular type of asset, then they own zero of that asset CFJ 2113: Called by Wooble (25 Jul); Judged INNOCENT by ais523 (04 Aug) Sgeo violated Rule 1742 by leaving the contract "The Winning Team" when the contract forbid leaving the contract. CFJ 2112: Called by comex (23 Jul); Judged FALSE by woggle (01 Aug) Publishing the message "I object", in response to an attempt to perform a dependent action, causes an action to be taken by announcement. CFJ 2111: Called by ehird (23 Jul); Judged UNIMPUGNED by Murphy (02 Aug) tusho violated rule 2149 by stating that the initiation of this CFJ will fail. CFJ 2110: Called by Murphy (23 Jul); Judged FALSE by ais523 (15 Aug) At least two of the valid votes on Proposal 5648 were cast by the same player. CFJ 2109: Called by OscarMeyr (22 Jul); Judged TRUE by Murphy (25 Jul) A non-player can violate a rule of Agora. CFJ 2108: Called by BobTHJ (22 Jul); Judged by Wooble (09 Sep) Ivan Hope has failed to increase eir VP holdings above 50 within the allotted 60 day timeframe. CFJ 2107: Called by G. (22 Jul); Judged GUILTY/FINE by Wooble (28 Jul); REMANDED on Appeal (10 Aug); Judged GUILTY/FINE by woggle (07 Sep); AFFIRMED on Appeal (15 Sep) Ivan Hope violated R2149 by making the untruthful statement "UNDECIDABLE is never appropriate." CFJ 2106: Called by Warrigal (22 Jul); Judged ALREADY TRIED by Wooble (09 Aug) Goethe violated rule 2158 by judging UNDECIDABLE on CFJ 2087. CFJ 2105: Called by Warrigal (22 Jul); Judged GUILTY/DISCHARGE by Wooble (09 Aug) Goethe violated rule 2158 by judging UNDECIDABLE on CFJ 2086. CFJ 2104: Called by G. (21 Jul); Judged FALSE by BobTHJ (25 Jul) ihope changed eir Registrar-recorded nickname to avpx on or about Jul 19th. CFJ 2103: Called by Sgeo (21 Jul); Judged SLIPPERY by OscarMeyr (07 Aug); REMANDED on Appeal (15 Aug); Judged INNOCENT by OscarMeyr (18 Aug) I violated Rule 2149 by claiming that I lie when I did not, in fact lie. CFJ 2102: Called by comex (21 Jul); Judged SLIPPERY by ais523 (01 Aug) OscarMeyr violated Rule 2149 by claiming that tusho could not have violated any rules because e was not a player. CFJ 2101: Called by Sgeo (20 Jul); Judged TRUE by comex (09 Aug); OVERTURNED on Appeal (20 Sep); Judged FALSE by ais523 (20 Sep) Equity case judgements violate R101(iv). CFJ 2100: Called by Wooble (20 Jul); Judged by Murphy (09 Aug) upon Ivan Hope transferring to em all eir VPs, Sgeo did not, as soon as possible, transfer all eir VPs to Ivan Hope. CFJ 2099: Called by Pavitra (19 Jul); Judged FALSE by Wooble (28 Jul) I transfer all my crops to the PNP. CFJ 2098: Called by ais523 (18 Jul); Judged FALSE by Wooble (19 Jul) No matter what their contents, all public messages contain at least one game-relevant action CFJ 2097: Called by Quazie (18 Jul); Judged FALSE by woggle (26 Jul) The Executor of a message that contains a CFJ is also the Initiator of that CFJ, even if the Executor says E submits the CFJ on behalf of someone/something else CFJ 2096: Called by root (17 Jul); Judged TRUE by Murphy (25 Jul) There is an inquiry case with the ID number 2073. CFJ 2095: Called by G. (17 Jul); Judged UNDETERMINED by ais523 (29 Jul) The statement labeled by the CotC as the CFJ statement for CFJ 2080 was a CFJ statement called by Quazie. CFJ 2094: Called by G. (17 Jul); Judged UNDETERMINED by ais523 (29 Jul) The statement labeled by the CotC as the CFJ statement for CFJ 2079 was a CFJ statement called by root. CFJ 2093: Called by Murphy (19 Jul); Judged FALSE by G. (21 Jul) Human Point Two bears the patent title Minister Without Portfolio CFJ 2092: Called by ehird (16 Jul); Judged INNOCENT by comex (10 Aug) tusho violated rule 101 by abridging, reducing, limiting, or removing Blind, Deaf and Mute's rights. CFJ 2091: Called by ehird (16 Jul); Judged INNOCENT by comex (10 Aug) Quazie violated rule 101 by abridging, reducing, limiting, or removing Blind, Deaf and Mute's rights. CFJ 2090: Called by Quazie (16 Jul); Judged TRUE by ais523 (21 Jul); REMANDED on Appeal (08 Aug); Judged TRUE by ais523 (11 Aug) CFJ 2019 is a valid CFJ. CFJ 2089: Called by woggle (16 Jul); Judged TRUE by Quazie (19 Jul) The PerlNomic Partnership transferred 150 chits to woggle as a result of the quoted message. CFJ 2088: Called by Wooble (16 Jul); Judged INNOCENT by OscarMeyr (20 Jul) tusho violated Rule 2029 by changing eir posture to sitting. CFJ 2087: Called by ehird (15 Jul); Judged UNDECIDABLE by G. (22 Jul); OVERTURNED on Appeal (08 Sep); Judged FALSE by ais523 (16 Sep); REMANDED on Appeal (02 Oct); Judged TRUE by ais523 (03 Oct) I CFJ on the following statement. CFJ 2086: Called by ehird (15 Jul); Judged UNDECIDABLE by G. (22 Jul); OVERTURNED on Appeal (08 Sep); Judged FALSE by ais523 (16 Sep); REMANDED on Appeal (02 Oct); Judged FALSE by ais523 (03 Oct) I CFJ on the previous statement. CFJ 2085: Called by comex (15 Jul); Judged UNIMPUGNED by OscarMeyr (01 Aug) comex breached rule 2149 by thinking up statements that will be public although they are not true before e has sent them CFJ 2084: Called by comex (15 Jul); Judged SLIPPERY by OscarMeyr (27 Jul) comex breached rule 2149 by sending a message with message-id <6bf32280807151511sfca8f7dveb137ee7d95c576@mail.gmail.com> in which e did not tell the truth (because e did not say anything) CFJ 2083: Called by comex (15 Jul); Judged INNOCENT by OscarMeyr (27 Jul) root breached rule 2149 by claiming that the precedent from CFJ 1738 is that speech acts carry truth values CFJ 2082: Called by comex (15 Jul); Judged GUILTY/APOLOGY by OscarMeyr (27 Jul); AFFIRMED on Appeal (08 Sep) ehird breached rule 2149 by claiming to kill Goethe in eir message with message-id <784a579e0807151341l7123d535wdfcc5376130d2cb2@mail.gmail.com> CFJ 2081: Called by comex (15 Jul); Judged INNOCENT by OscarMeyr (27 Jul) Goethe breached rule 2149 by claiming to dance in eir message with message-id <Pine.LNX.4.43.0807151338310.13451@hymn11.u.washington.edu> CFJ 2080: Called by Quazie (15 Jul); Judged TRUE by Murphy (17 Jul) I CFJ on this statement. CFJ 2079: Called by root (15 Jul); Judged TRUE by woggle (19 Jul) I CFJ on this statement. CFJ 2078: Called by Wooble (14 Jul); Judged FALSE by Warrigal (08 Sep) Two contracts CAN have the same name. CFJ 2077: Called by Warrigal (14 Jul); Judged TRUE by BobTHJ (17 Jul); REMANDED on Appeal (21 Jul); Judged FALSE by G. (08 Sep) Ivan Hope is a player CFJ 2076: Called by ehird (14 Jul); Judged FALSE by Quazie (20 Jul) tusho has 24 VP. CFJ 2075: Called by ehird (14 Jul); Judged FALSE by Quazie (20 Jul) ehird is a player. CFJ 2074: Called by ehird (14 Jul); Judged FALSE by Quazie (20 Jul) tusho is a player. CFJ 2073: Called by Warrigal (14 Jul); Judged TRUE by Wooble (17 Jul) Either the sky is always red or, if I do not hereby initiate an inquiry case on this sentence, then the sky is always green. CFJ 2072: Called by BobTHJ (13 Jul); Judged UNAWARE by OscarMeyr (18 Jul) the CotC (Murphy) violated R2019 by not assigning the Default Justice (myself) to be member of this appeals panel. CFJ 2071: Called by comex (11 Jul); Judged TRUE by G. (17 Jul) If there had been no disclaimer in the message sent by comex with Message-ID <6bf32280807111120s54788104x1e5e3a3001cb1be5@mail.gmail.com>, and Rule 2208 did not exist, comex would have taken at least one action besides submitting a CFJ by sending it. CFJ 2070: Called by comex (11 Jul); Judged TRUE by G. (17 Jul) If there had been no disclaimer in the message sent by comex with Message-ID <6bf32280807111120s54788104x1e5e3a3001cb1be5@mail.gmail.com>, comex would have taken at least one action besides submitting a CFJ by sending it. CFJ 2069: Called by G. (11 Jul); Judged FALSE by ais523 (18 Jul); REMANDED on Appeal (13 Aug); Judged FALSE by ais523 (15 Aug) There are no game-relevant actions or intents of action in the message sent by comex with Message-ID: <6bf32280807111120s54788104x1e5e3a3001cb1be5@mail.gmail.com> CFJ 2068: Called by Sgeo (11 Jul); Judged TRUE by Murphy (25 Jul) Sgeo is obligated to give Ivan Hope CXXVII an amount of VP CFJ 2067: Called by Warrigal (11 Jul); Judged by Wooble (20 Jul) Sgeo could stash all the currency I didn't give him, then claim he only has to give back what he has after stashing. This is clearly a great injustice. CFJ 2066: Called by G. (08 Jul); Judged FALSE by woggle (17 Jul) Goethe won by extortion on or about July 7, 2008. CFJ 2065: Called by ehird (07 Jul); Judged FALSE by woggle (17 Jul) Sgeo has won today or yesterday (relative to the initiation of this CFJ). CFJ 2064: Called by ais523 (07 Jul); Judged FALSE by Quazie (17 Jul) The message quoted in the evidence section of this CFJ changed the text of a public contract CFJ 2062: Called by Warrigal (05 Jul); Judged TRUE by ais523 (07 Jul) The contract Ivan Hope just agreed to is a pledge because it states "Guvf vf n cyrqtr.", which is "This is a pledge." in rot13. CFJ 2061: Called by root (03 Jul); Judged TRUE by ais523 (21 Jul) The Reformed Bank of Agora is a partnership. CFJ 2060: Called by Sgeo (02 Jul); Judged FALSE by G. (04 Jul) The CotC MAY NOT refuse cases based on cases being excess as defined by Rule 2175 CFJ 2059: Called by G. (01 Jul); Judged FALSE by ais523 (04 Jul) BobTHJ holds the Patent Title Left in a Huff. CFJ 2058: Called by ais523 (01 Jul); Judged TRUE by Quazie (05 Jul); REMANDED on Appeal (03 Aug); Judged TRUE by cmealerjr (18 Aug) If an officer attempts to post a self-ratifying report to a public forum, but it does not arrive until over a week after it left the officer's technical domain of control, the report nonetheless self-ratifies even though none of the other players are aware of what its contents are. CFJ 2057: Called by Murphy (01 Jul); Judged TRUE by G. (02 Jul) ehrid is a player. CFJ 2056: Called by Taral (01 Jul); Judged TRUE by Wooble (09 Jul) A message containing one action sent to multiple fora is still only one action. CFJ 2055: Called by Wooble (30 Jun); Judged TRUE by woggle (05 Jul) ais523 was a person on Agora's birthday. CFJ 2054: Called by ais523 (30 Jun); Judged FALSE by Murphy (02 Jul) ais523 has a Magenta Ribbon CFJ 2053: Called by ehird (30 Jun); Judged INNOCENT by OscarMeyr (13 Jul); REMANDED on Appeal (21 Jul); Judged ALREADY TRIED by pikhq (11 Aug) ehird violated rule 2149 by lying. CFJ 2052: Called by BobTHJ (27 Jun); Judged by woggle (26 Jul) OscarMeyr has explicitly refused to join the Agoran Slavery pledge, and the other players have implicitly refused to do so by their inaction. CFJ 2051: Called by BobTHJ (27 Jun); Judged FALSE by woggle (05 Jul) ais523 can fill the Buy Ticket specified in the evidence more than once. CFJ 2050: Called by ais523 (27 Jun); Judged FALSE by Wooble (06 Jul) This CFJ was filed by ehird CFJ 2049: Called by ehird (27 Jun); Judged TRUE by Murphy (27 Jun) This CFJ exists. CFJ 2048: Called by comex (26 Jun); Judged UNIMPUGNED by Taral (06 Jul); OVERTURNED on Appeal (25 Jul); Judged GUILTY/DISCHARGE by OscarMeyr (01 Aug); AFFIRMED on Appeal (15 Aug) ehird violated Rule 2149 by saying that e joins. CFJ 2047: Called by ehird (25 Jun); Judged FALSE by BobTHJ (27 Jun) notehird is a registered player. CFJ 2046: Called by ehird (25 Jun); Judged TRUE by G. (27 Jun) ehrid devolves its obligations onto at least two people. CFJ 2045: Called by Quazie (25 Jun); Judged TRUE by Murphy (12 Jul) Comex objected to the termination of the pledge which allows anything to act on behalf of ehird. CFJ 2044: Called by ais523 (25 Jun); Judged UNIMPUGNED by OscarMeyr (04 Jul) comex violated rule 2185 by failing to assign a judgement to an open and applicable judicial question of CFJ 2006 as soon as possible. CFJ 2043: Called by ais523 (25 Jun); Judged UNIMPUGNED by OscarMeyr (04 Jul) comex violated rule 2185 by failing to assign a judgement to an open and applicable judicial question of CFJ 1996 as soon as possible. CFJ 2042: Called by G. (24 Jun); Judged TRUE by Quazie (02 Jul) If a partnership dissolves after having incurred obligations from another contract, the former members may be required by an equity settlement involving the second contract to be a parties to the settlement. CFJ 2041: Called by G. (24 Jun); Judged TRUE by Quazie (02 Jul) If a partnership incurs contract obligations from another contract while a particular member is a member, and that member departs the partnership, the member in question may be required by an equity settlement involving the second contract to be a party to the settlement, even if the partnership agreement does not explicitly allow this. CFJ 2040: Called by G. (24 Jun); Judged TRUE by Quazie (02 Jul) If a partnership is party to another contract, individual members of the contract may be required, by an equity settlement involving the second contract, to be parties to the settlement, even if the partnership agreement does not explicitly allow this. CFJ 2039: Called by Quazie (24 Jun); Judged by Sgeo (28 Jul) The Judgement of CFJ 2029 indicates that BobTHJ is in violation of point 12 of the AAA contract by not creating a mill in the possession of Quazie after revoking 3 points from em. CFJ 2038: Called by BobTHJ (24 Jun); Judged by Murphy (12 Jul) Due to eir deregistration ehird has not acted in the manner envisioned by section 11 of the contract. CFJ 2037: Called by BobTHJ (24 Jun); Judged INNOCENT by OscarMeyr (27 Jun) ehird violated R1742 by not acting in accordance with section 11 of the Protection Racket agreement when he posted a pledge allowing anyone to act on eir behalf. CFJ 2036: Called by comex (24 Jun); Judged by Wooble (06 Jul) Murphy took all of the AFO's assets. CFJ 2035: Called by G. (24 Jun); Judged FALSE by Wooble (12 Jul) If the previous CFJ is found TRUE, its judge CAN and SHOULD award comex the Patent Title Scamster by announcement. CFJ 2034: Called by G. (24 Jun); Judged TRUE by Wooble (12 Jul) comex has shown great enthusiasm, persistence, or skill in the perpetrating of scams. CFJ 2033: Called by Quazie (24 Jun); Judged TRUE by Murphy (24 Jun) The Agoran Agricultural Association is a contest CFJ 2032: Called by comex (23 Jun); Judged FALSE by woggle (01 Jul) The hypothetical contract in the evidence section, if made a contest, would be effective, because neither Rule 101 (vi.) nor Rule 478 would prevent its operation. CFJ 2031: Called by ais523 (23 Jun); Judged UNIMPUGNED by Taral (05 Jul) ehird violated rule 2149 by knowingly or recklessly making a false statement. CFJ 2030: Called by woggle (23 Jun); Judged FALSE by ais523 (24 Jun) It is possible for ehird to cause woggle to vote by announcing 'On behalf of woggle: woggle retracts eir votes on proposal 5568 and votes AGAINST x 6 on proposal 5568'. CFJ 2029: Called by Quazie (23 Jun); Judged TRUE by BobTHJ (24 Jun) As a result of removing 3 points from Quazie on Jun 17, 2008 at 12:00 PM BobTHJ must create a mill, other than land #98, in Quazie's possession or BobTHJ is in violation of the AAA contract CFJ 2028: Called by root (23 Jun); Judged GUILTY/APOLOGY by ais523 (03 Jul) the Reformed Bank of Agora violated R2144 by registering while having the same basis (BobTHJ and Ivan Hope CXXVII) as the Protection Racket, a registered player. CFJ 2027: Called by Warrigal (22 Jun); Judged FALSE by ais523 (15 Jul); OVERRULED to TRUE on Appeal (15 Aug) The Notary is the recordkeepor of public contracts. CFJ 2026: Called by root (22 Jun); Judged FALSE by Wooble (22 Jun); REMANDED on Appeal (24 Jun); Judged TRUE by Wooble (01 Jul) The Left Hand is a public contract. CFJ 2025: Called by ehird (20 Jun); Judged SLIPPERY by ais523 (23 Jun) comex violated rule 2149 by lying in the quoted message. CFJ 2024: Called by ehird (20 Jun); Judged FALSE by BobTHJ (22 Jun) comex deregistered sometime around or on Thursday, June 19th, 2008 at 8:06:36pm MDT. CFJ 2023: Called by ais523 (20 Jun); Judged INNOCENT by OscarMeyr (20 Jul) root broke rule 1742 by failing to act in accordance with the Brainfuck Golf contract. CFJ 2022: Called by Murphy (20 Jun); Judged GUILTY/CHOKEY by woggle (21 Jun) comex violated Rule 1504 by failing to publish an apology for CFJ 1942. CFJ 2021: Called by ais523 (20 Jun); Judged FALSE by Quazie (16 Jul) If an entity is both a public message and a forum, it is necessarily a public forum. CFJ 2020: Called by Warrigal (20 Jun); Judged GUILTY/APOLOGY by comex (22 Jun); AFFIRMED on Appeal (24 Jun) BobTHJ violated Rule 2158 by judging CFJ 2005 UNDECIDABLE. CFJ 2017: Called by ehird (17 Jun); Judged FALSE by Quazie (02 Jul) I am a first-class partnership. CFJ 2016: Called by Zefram (17 Jun); Judged UNIMPUGNED by Taral (01 Jul) Quazie violated rule 2149 by publicly claiming in message <aa8936fe0806161718q6d3862fbl2e343709396fca5f@mail.gmail.com> that Echidna and Typhon are coauthors (or a coauthor) of the proposal that e submitted in that message. CFJ 2015: Called by Quazie (17 Jun); Judged TRUE by Pavitra (18 Jun) BobTHJ successfully created land #98 in Quazie's possession On or about Tue, Jun 17, 2008 at 12:59 PM. CFJ 2014: Called by Quazie (17 Jun); Judged FALSE by cmealerjr (18 Jun) If ehrid was able to act on my behalf at the time CFJ 1999 and CFJ 2000 were called one or more of the set of {CFJ 1999, CFJ 2000} would've been TRUE. CFJ 2013: Called by Warrigal (17 Jun); Judged FALSE by Wooble (18 Jun) Rule 2141 implies that a rule can destroy the universe. CFJ 2012: Called by BobTHJ (16 Jun); Judged GUILTY/CHOKEY by OscarMeyr (25 Jun); REMANDED on Appeal (03 Jul); Judged GUILTY/CHOKEY by OscarMeyr (04 Jul) comex breached Rule 1742 by continued failure to comply with the terms of the binding Equation of CFJ 1915 CFJ 2011: Called by BobTHJ (16 Jun); Judged GUILTY/CHOKEY by OscarMeyr (25 Jun); REMANDED on Appeal (03 Jul); Judged GUILTY/CHOKEY by OscarMeyr (04 Jul) comex breached Rule 1742 by continued failure to comply with the terms of the binding Vote Market contract. CFJ 2010: Called by ais523 (15 Jun); Judged UNIMPUGNED by Taral (19 Jul) OscarMeyr violated rule 2149 by claiming there was "nothing to see here" when in fact there was. CFJ 2009: Called by Warrigal (13 Jun); Judged UNIMPUGNED by Murphy (21 Jun) Ivan Hope violated rule 1742 by initiating this CFJ. CFJ 2008: Called by Wooble (13 Jun); Judged FALSE by Murphy (21 Jun) Ehird deregistered on June 13, 2008, at or around 19:31 UTC CFJ 2007: Called by root (13 Jun); Judged FALSE by Murphy (17 Jun) Ivan Hope CXXVII is in the chokey. CFJ 2006: Called by avpx (13 Jun); Judged FALSE by G. (26 Jun) ehird's vote in the Assessor election is valid. CFJ 2005: Called by ehird (13 Jun); Judged UNDECIDABLE by BobTHJ (16 Jun); OVERRULED to TRUE on Appeal (21 Jun) Schrodinger's Cat is a player. CFJ 2004: Called by Murphy (10 Jun); Judged UNIMPUGNED by OscarMeyr (17 Jun) Ivan Hope breached Rule 2149 (Truthfulness) by saying "By the way, did I mention I didn't have 50 pens in the first place, so you just gave me free stuff?" while believing e did have at least 50 pens at the time (on or about Mon, 09 Jun 2008 13:11:46 -0400) e claimed to transfer 50 pens to comex. CFJ 2003: Called by comex (10 Jun); Judged SLIPPERY by Taral (21 Jun) Senator Hillary Rodham Clinton breached rule 101 by failing to treat Agora right good forever CFJ 2002: Called by Pavitra (10 Jun); Judged TRUE by Wooble (13 Jun) Rule 2193 is at least one of: (1) a Monster; (2) the Monster. CFJ 2001: Called by Warrigal (10 Jun); Judged INNOCENT by OscarMeyr (22 Jun) Murphy violated rule 1871 by rotating the bench while the Pineapple Partnership is qualified to judge. CFJ 2000: Called by Quazie (09 Jun); Judged FALSE by Murphy (17 Jun) ehird was deregistered when ehrid posted the following message: "I perform the following action on behalf of Quazie: {I deregister.}" CFJ 1999: Called by Quazie (09 Jun); Judged FALSE by Murphy (17 Jun) Quazie was deregistered when ehrid posted the following message: "I perform the following action on behalf of Quazie: {I deregister.}" CFJ 1998: Called by Quazie (09 Jun); Judged TRUE by Wooble (17 Jun) No change will occur to the OBJECTIONABLE contract based on comex's statement: 'Without 3 OBJECTIONS (I don't have any, for that matter), I hereby amend the OBJECTIONABLE contract to read: {{ 1. Any person can join this contract by announcement. 2. Any person other than Quazie can leave this contract by announcement. 3. Any person other than Quazie can perform any action on behalf of Quazie by announcement. }}' regardless of the number of objections that occur CFJ 1997: Called by Quazie (09 Jun); Judged TRUE by Wooble (17 Jun) The following two statements have different meanings, 1 - Without 3 OBJECTIONS, I hereby amend the OBJECTIONABLE contract to read: {{ 1. Any person can join this contract by announcement. 2. Any person other than Quazie can leave this contract by announcement. 3. Any person other than Quazie can perform any action on behalf of Quazie by announcement. }} 2 - Without 3 objections , I hereby amend the OBJECTIONABLE contract to read: {{ 1. Any person can join this contract by announcement. 2. Any person other than Quazie can leave this contract by announcement. 3. Any person other than Quazie can perform any action on behalf of Quazie by announcement. }} CFJ 1996: Called by Murphy (09 Jun); Judged TRUE by Warrigal (27 Jun) On or about Mon, 09 Jun 2008 15:03:27 -0400, comex gave Ivan Hope 50 pens CFJ 1995: Called by Murphy (09 Jun); Judged INNOCENT by OscarMeyr (17 Jun) Ivan Hope breached Rule 2149 (Truthfulness) by claiming (on or about Mon, 09 Jun 2008 13:11:46 -0400) to give comex 50 pens. CFJ 1994: Called by ais523 (09 Jun); Judged TRUE by root (21 Jun) The PerlNomic Partnership has voted FOR on the Agoran decision on whether to adopt proposal 5545. CFJ 1993: Called by ais523 (09 Jun); Judged GUILTY/APOLOGY by OscarMeyr (20 Jun) Murphy breached rule 2158 by failing to recuse the judicial panel of comex, Pavitra and pikhq with cause. CFJ 1992: Called by Quazie (09 Jun); Judged TRUE by Warrigal (13 Jun) It is an entity, where the aforementioned 'it' is any thing. CFJ 1991: Called by ais523 (07 Jun); Judged TRUE by BobTHJ (09 Jun) ehird has apologised as required by the judgement of the question on sentencing of CFJ 1943. CFJ 1990: Called by root (07 Jun); Judged TRUE by Warrigal (13 Jun) The CotC CAN assign a poorly qualified player to judge a case. CFJ 1989: Called by root (07 Jun); Judged FALSE by Warrigal (13 Jun) All actions are regulated. CFJ 1988: Called by Warrigal (07 Jun); Judged UNDETERMINED by Murphy (09 Jun) It's an entity. CFJ 1987: Called by Warrigal (06 Jun); Judged TRUE by comex (13 Jun) The Lost and Found Department owns the oddball {2/3,3/4} CFJ 1986: Called by Warrigal (06 Jun); Judged FALSE by comex (13 Jun) Ivan Hope CXXVII owns the oddball {2/3,3/4} CFJ 1985: Called by comex (05 Jun); Judged FALSE by Pavitra (13 Jun) The first paragraph of Rule 1586 has no effect. CFJ 1984: Called by comex (04 Jun); Judged IRRELEVANT by root (06 Jun); AFFIRMED on Appeal (22 Jun) At least one of the following statements is true: - War is Peace. - Freedom is Slavery. - Ignorance is Strength. CFJ 1983: Called by ais523 (31 May); Judged TRUE by Murphy (09 Jun) There is a CFJ with ID number 1934 CFJ 1982: Called by ehird (30 May); Judged UNDECIDABLE by Wooble (05 Jun) comex CAN initiate an equity case concerning the Gnarlier Contract CFJ 1981: Called by comex (30 May); Judged TRUE by BobTHJ (01 Jun) If I am judged GUILTY in CFJ 1935, a sentence other than DISCHARGE is appropriate CFJ 1980: Called by ais523 (29 May); Judged UNDECIDABLE by comex (03 Jun) comex CAN initiate an equity case concerning the Gnarlier Contract CFJ 1979: Called by woggle (29 May); Judged FALSE by root (30 May) When CFJ 1972 was called, it was possible for Pavitra to make Kiwi into a contest without 3 objections. CFJ 1978: Called by woggle (28 May); Judged FALSE by Warrigal (03 Jun) Wooble has a Cyan ribbon. CFJ 1977: Called by Pavitra (26 May); Judged FALSE by Murphy (29 May) If a player announces "I pledge {this is the Pear contract}; the following sentence has no effect. I pledge {this is the Papaya contract}; the preceding sentence has no effect.", and no attempt is made to dissolve the Pear contract, then another player CAN join the Pear contract by announcement. CFJ 1976: Called by ehird (26 May); Judged TRUE by Pavitra (27 May); OVERRULED to FALSE on Appeal (13 Jun) ais523 could, at the time this CFJ was called, leave The Gnarly Contract by announcement CFJ 1975: Called by ais523 (26 May); Judged TRUE by Pavitra (27 May); OVERRULED to FALSE on Appeal (13 Jun) ais523 could, at the time this CFJ was called, leave The Gnarly Contract by announcement CFJ 1974: Called by comex (23 May); Judged FALSE by Murphy (29 May) When CFJ 1972 was called, it was possible for Pavrita to leave Kiwi. CFJ 1973: Called by Pavitra (22 May); Judged UNDECIDABLE by Wooble (23 May); OVERRULED to FALSE on Appeal (02 Jul) Pavitra is a party to Kiwi. CFJ 1972: Called by Pavitra (22 May); Judged UNDECIDABLE by Wooble (23 May); OVERRULED to FALSE on Appeal (02 Jul) Pavitra is a party to Mango. CFJ 1971: Called by ais523 (22 May); Judged TRUE by BobTHJ (25 May) It is possible to take a game action even in a message which includes the disclaimer in the evidence section. CFJ 1970: Called by ehird (22 May); Judged IRRELEVANT by Murphy (23 May) "A few CFJs" accurately describes the amount of CFJs I have recently called. CFJ 1969: Called by ehird (22 May); Judged IRRELEVANT by Murphy (23 May) "A few CFJs" accurately describes the amount of CFJs I have recently called. CFJ 1968: Called by ehird (22 May); Judged IRRELEVANT by Murphy (23 May) "A few CFJs" accurately describes the amount of CFJs I have recently called. CFJ 1967: Called by ehird (22 May); Judged IRRELEVANT by Murphy (23 May) "A few CFJs" accurately describes the amount of CFJs I have recently called. CFJ 1966: Called by comex (22 May); Judged TRUE by Warrigal (26 May); REMANDED on Appeal (30 May); Judged TRUE by Warrigal (02 Jun); OVERTURNED on Appeal (13 Jun); Judged TRUE by Pavitra (14 Jun); OVERTURNED on Appeal (24 Jun); Judged FALSE by Wooble (26 Jun) R101 item i. reads: i. The map being obviously the most important rule, every person has the right to move it back up to the top of the ruleset if the Rulekeepor put it down near the bottom again. CFJ 1965: Called by ais523 (22 May); Judged FALSE by comex (29 May) ehird's Announcement of Chaos caused at least one contract to terminate. CFJ 1964: Called by Warrigal (21 May); Judged UNIMPUGNED by comex (08 Jun) Ivan Hope violated rule 2149 by making a public statement that two plus two is five. CFJ 1963: Called by ehird (20 May); Judged INNOCENT by OscarMeyr (30 May) Ivan Hope violated Rule 2173 by revealing the text of that private contract. CFJ 1962: Called by ais523 (20 May); Judged FALSE by Murphy (23 May) In the quoted message, ehird sent an infinite number of messages. CFJ 1961: Called by G. (20 May); Judged TRUE by Pavitra (26 May) Proposal A is distributed and is filibustered (and remains filibustered) during emergency session; given no rule changes, a week and a day later, a vote cast on it may be valid. CFJ 1960: Called by ais523 (20 May); Judged FALSE by Warrigal (22 May) If a player's voting limit on an Agoran decision reduces during that decision's voting period, then all votes that that player has already cast on that decision are no longer valid. CFJ 1959: Called by ais523 (20 May); Judged FALSE by Warrigal (22 May) If a player's voting limit on an Agoran decision reduces during that decision's voting period, then all votes that that player has already cast on that decision are still valid. CFJ 1958: Called by Murphy (20 May); Judged TRUE by Wooble (22 May) There exists at least one rule with Power = 1. CFJ 1957: Called by Warrigal (19 May); Judged FALSE by Wooble (09 Jun) There is a pen that owns at least 1 crumpet. CFJ 1956: Called by Warrigal (19 May); Judged FALSE by Wooble (09 Jun) There is a pen that owns at least 5 crumpets. CFJ 1955: Called by comex (15 May); Judged FALSE by G. (16 May) If Rule 101 gives me the right to perform an action in this game, but the Rules do not define a mechanism for performing that action, I can perform it by announcement. CFJ 1954: Called by ehird (14 May); Judged FALSE by Murphy (18 May) In the message archived at the URL <http://www.agoranomic.org/cgi-bin/mailman/private/agora-business/2008-May/010573.html>, ehird won the game. CFJ 1953: Called by G. (13 May); Judged FALSE by ais523 (16 May) A individual player may be found GUILTY in a criminal case for an action performed by a judicial panel of which e is a member, if the judicial panel performs the action as described in R2157. CFJ 1952: Called by G. (13 May); Judged UNIMPUGNED by Warrigal (16 May) comex violated Rule 101(vii) and Goethe's defined rights by initiating a criminal case against Goethe, when Goethe is already being punished for the same single action (by having to defend emself in a separate, previously-initiated criminal case). CFJ 1951: Called by comex (13 May); Judged UNIMPUGNED by root (13 Jun) Goethe violated Rule 217 by submitting a judgement (on behalf of an appeal panel) for the appeal case CFJ 1932a. CFJ 1950: Called by root (13 May); Judged INNOCENT by OscarMeyr (30 May) Wooble breached Rule 2157 by failing to ensure that the panel met all of its obligations in appeal case 1932a. Specifically, the panel failed to meet its obligation to assign an appropriate judgement in that case. CFJ 1949: Called by root (13 May); Judged INNOCENT by OscarMeyr (30 May) Murphy breached Rule 2157 by failing to ensure that the panel met all of its obligations in appeal case 1932a. Specifically, the panel failed to meet its obligation to assign an appropriate judgement in that case. CFJ 1948: Called by root (13 May); Judged INNOCENT by OscarMeyr (30 May) Goethe breached Rule 2157 by failing to ensure that the panel met all of its obligations in appeal case 1932a. Specifically, the panel failed to meet its obligation to assign an appropriate judgement in that case. CFJ 1947: Called by G. (13 May); Judged FALSE by Murphy (16 May) If an appealed equity case judgement is REMANDED or REASSIGNED, the original (prior) judgement remains a binding agreement. CFJ 1946: Called by ais523 (09 May); Judged FALSE by G. (12 May) In the message found at <http://www.agoranomic.org/cgi-bin/mailman/private/agora-business/2008-May/010509.html>, ihope agreed to something. CFJ 1945: Called by ehird (09 May); Judged INNOCENT by ais523 (14 May) Wooble violated Rule 101 by alienating new players by insulting eir religion. CFJ 1944: Called by Blaise Pascal (09 May); Judged FALSE by Pavitra (26 May) If I were to post to a public forum any of the following statements, I would be a player: 1. I am a player. 2. I declare myself to be a player. CFJ 1943: Called by Wooble (09 May); Judged GUILTY/APOLOGY by OscarMeyr (30 May) ehird breached Rule 1742 by not acting in accordance with eir obligations under the Ducks & Platypuses agreement, by being a party to that agreement. CFJ 1942: Called by Wooble (09 May); Judged GUILTY/APOLOGY by OscarMeyr (30 May) comex breached Rule 1742 by not acting in accordance with eir obligations under the Ducks & Platypuses agreement, by being a party to that agreement. CFJ 1941: Called by Warrigal (08 May); Judged TRUE by Murphy (16 May) A contract can allow arbitrary persons to act on behalf of its parties. CFJ 1940: Called by Warrigal (08 May); Judged GUILTY/CHOKEY by Wooble (13 May) Ivan Hope violated Rule 1742 by not transferring one pen to Murphy as soon as possible after making this pledge. CFJ 1939: Called by ais523 (08 May); Judged FALSE by G. (16 May) If a rule states that an action is regulated, that does not prevent that action from taking place, but only prevents that thing from taking place under rule 101(ii) (and therefore makes it impossible to take that action unless another rule makes it possible). CFJ 1938: Called by Wooble (07 May); Judged INNOCENT by comex (28 May) ais523 violated Rule 2158 by assigning an inappropriate judgement to CFJ 1932. CFJ 1937: Called by woggle (07 May); Judged FALSE by Wooble (08 May); REMANDED on Appeal (21 May); Judged FALSE by Wooble (05 Jun) root is the contestmaster of the equation of CFJ1932. CFJ 1936: Called by Wooble (07 May); Judged FALSE by Murphy (16 May); AFFIRMED on Appeal (13 Jun) The judge in an equity case CAN make the equation a contest by stating it is one. CFJ 1935: Called by Wooble (07 May); Judged OVERLOOKED by ais523 (20 May); AFFIRMED on Appeal (14 Jun) comex violated Rule 1742 by failing to act in accordance with eir obligations under the CFJ 1915 equation. CFJ 1934: Called by ais523 (04 May); Judged IRRELEVANT by Pavitra (31 May) Hello! CFJ 1933: Called by G. (02 May); Judged FALSE by Warrigal (02 Jun) Due to the LAND GRAB pledge, Goethe is the recordkeeper for the types of crops currencies referenced by the Agoran Agricultural Association contract. CFJ 1932: Called by root (29 Apr); Judged by ais523 (07 May); OVERTURNED on Appeal (13 May); Judged by ehird (16 May) I haven't left the contract at my first opportunity, as is expected of me. CFJ 1931: Called by comex (28 Apr); Judged FALSE by G. (08 May) IRCNomic is a public contract. CFJ 1930: Called by ais523 (28 Apr); Judged TRUE by root (08 May) It is impossible for a player to become Referee within the meaning of the public contract that is the backing document for XP without failing to do something that its paragraph 8 specifies that the Referee SHALL do in that situation, under the current set of rules. CFJ 1929: Called by comex (26 Apr); Judged INNOCENT by Murphy (08 May) comex breached Rule 1742 by claiming that contract R requires that we "*pretend*" that it's a rule, which is not treating it like a rule, but rather a pretend rule, thereby violating its terms CFJ 1927: Called by BobTHJ (18 Apr); Judged by Wooble (07 May) comex has failed to submit Sell Tickets as required by section 2 of this Equation. The other parties have failed to suggest suitable tickets as required in section 3 of the equation. CFJ 1926: Called by G. (11 Apr); Judged FALSE by Murphy (25 Apr) If a pledge contains no explicit exit clause, a party may leave it by announcement. CFJ 1925: Called by woggle (11 Apr); Judged TRUE by Iammars (20 Apr); REMANDED on Appeal (01 May); Judged FALSE by Murphy (18 May) In eir report, the Notary is required to list Agora's Child as a member of the set of parties to a public contract concerning Trouts and Jester's Caps. CFJ 1924: Called by comex (10 Apr); Judged FALSE by G. (25 Apr) The message in the evidence section (1) would be invalid because "30 days, or until e updates the player list..." is not a valid duration (ignoring any other problems with the message) CFJ 1923: Called by Murphy (04 Apr); Judged FALSE by root (22 Apr) pikhq has a bean. CFJ 1922: Called by Murphy (04 Apr); Judged FALSE by root (22 Apr) Murphy has at least one bean. CFJ 1921: Called by G. (02 Apr); Judged TRUE by Iammars (03 May) If I publish the following statement 'I'll give a quatloo to you, comex, if you give me a dingbat', and quatloos and dingbats are Agoran quantities, and comex publishes 'Okay' in reference to the statement, it forms a binding agreement (a contract). CFJ 1920: Called by comex (01 Apr); Judged FALSE by G. (07 Apr) If the offer in the evidence section (1) were published by me, then accepted, any person would be able to become a party to the resultant contract by announcement. CFJ 1919: Called by Iammars (27 Mar); Judged GUILTY/CHOKEY by OscarMeyr (09 Apr) pikhq breached Rule 2135 by neglecting his duty to update the Nomic Wiki page in the month of February. CFJ 1918: Called by Iammars (27 Mar); Judged GUILTY/CHOKEY by OscarMeyr (09 Apr) pikhq breached Rule 2135 by misrepresenting Agora on the Nomic Wiki by failing to include my name in the players list. CFJ 1917: Called by Warrigal (22 Mar); Judged GUILTY/APOLOGY by Iammars (03 Apr) Goethe violated rule 2143 by not publishing a Notary report last month. CFJ 1916: Called by comex (13 Mar); Judged FALSE by Zefram (13 Mar) In the quoted message, Iammars consented to something. CFJ 1915: Called by BobTHJ (11 Mar); Judged by woggle (27 Mar) comex has breached the Vote Market agreement by failing to restore his VP to a level at or above 50 within 60 days of when it first fell below that threshold. CFJ 1914: Called by comex (11 Mar); Judged TRUE by Warrigal (12 Apr) Rule 2166 exists. CFJ 1913: Called by comex (10 Mar); Judged FALSE by Murphy (30 Mar) Bob is a first-class person. CFJ 1912: Called by comex (10 Mar); Judged FALSE by Murphy (30 Mar) Bob is a player. CFJ 1911: Called by comex (10 Mar); Judged FALSE by Murphy (30 Mar) Bob is a person. CFJ 1910: Called by root (10 Mar); Judged TRUE by Murphy (15 Mar) One or more partnerships exist. CFJ 1909: Called by woggle (02 Mar); Judged FALSE by Iammars (12 Mar) CFJ 1903a has been judged. CFJ 1908: Called by woggle (02 Mar); Judged FALSE by Iammars (12 Mar) A concurring opinion has been published by the judicial panel in CFJ 1903a. CFJ 1907: Called by comex (18 Feb); Judged GUILTY/CHOKEY by Zefram (07 Mar) pikhq violated Rule 208 by failing to resolve eir intent to appeal CFJ 1856. CFJ 1906: Called by Zefram (08 Feb); Judged GUILTY/FINE by Wooble (18 Feb) comex violated rule 2149 by claiming in message <6bf32280802080851i14c79ea9oa8fc2768a80bc7af@mail.gmail.com> that proposal 5419 passed while not believing that to be true. CFJ 1905: Called by comex (07 Feb); Judged FALSE by Murphy (16 Feb) There is a Rule 9999. CFJ 1904: Called by pikhq (07 Feb); Judged INNOCENT by Iammars (22 Feb) comex violated Rule 2149/8, Truthfulness, by falsely claiming that there exists a rule 9999. CFJ 1903: Called by Pavitra (06 Feb); Judged FALSE by G. (07 Feb); AFFIRMED on Appeal (16 Mar) The above question initiated an inquiry case. CFJ 1902: Called by Levi (05 Feb); Judged TRUE by comex (20 Feb) Making the public statement 'This statement is not true' would cause the person making that statement to violate Rule 2149. CFJ 1901: Called by comex (04 Feb); Judged TRUE by Zefram (05 Feb) Y is a contract. CFJ 1900: Called by Murphy (03 Feb); Judged FALSE by G. (21 Feb) Zefram CAN register. CFJ 1899: Called by Murphy (03 Feb); Judged FALSE by G. (22 Feb) BobTHJ CAN register. CFJ 1898: Called by Murphy (03 Feb); Judged TRUE by G. (21 Feb) Zefram is a player. CFJ 1897: Called by comex (03 Feb); Judged FALSE by BobTHJ (26 Feb); OVERRULED to TRUE on Appeal (19 Mar) BobTHJ is a player CFJ 1896: Called by comex (03 Feb); Judged FALSE by Murphy (03 Feb); OVERRULED to TRUE on Appeal (04 Feb) There exists a R2160 'position' that is not an office CFJ 1895: Called by comex (03 Feb); Judged FALSE by G. (22 Feb) BobTHJ is an R2160 'position' CFJ 1894: Called by Zefram (03 Feb); Judged TRUE by pikhq (04 Feb) an inquiry case CAN be initiated with a question taking the role of the statement to be inquired into CFJ 1893: Called by root (03 Feb); Judged FALSE by Wooble (04 Feb) comex successfully caused at least one player other than emself to cast a vote on Proposal 5419. CFJ 1892: Called by pikhq (02 Feb); Judged FALSE by G. (04 Feb) comex's non-binding agreement 'X' is a contract. CFJ 1891: Called by G. (02 Feb); Judged TRUE by OscarMeyr (22 Feb); REMANDED on Appeal (19 Apr); Judged FALSE by Wooble (01 May) If the Speaker fails to assign prerogatives for the upcoming month in the seven days before the beginning of a month, e CAN assign prerogatives (for that month) after the month has begun. CFJ 1890: Called by G. (02 Feb); Judged TRUE by OscarMeyr (22 Feb); REMANDED on Appeal (19 Apr); Judged FALSE by Wooble (01 May) The Speaker CAN assign prerogatives for the upcoming month in the seven days before the beginning of a month. CFJ 1889: Called by Wooble (01 Feb); Judged UNIMPUGNED by woggle (11 Feb) Zefram violated Rule 2149 in the above message by making the statement "I intend to deputise for BobTHJ to deregister em." while not reasonably believing it to be true. CFJ 1888: Called by pikhq (31 Jan); Judged FALSE by OscarMeyr (01 Feb) The above message was a public message. CFJ 1887: Called by Levi (30 Jan); Judged TRUE by BobTHJ (01 Feb) Making the public statement 'This statement is a lie' would cause the person making that statement to violate Rule 2149. CFJ 1886: Called by Murphy (28 Jan); Judged by Zefram (11 Feb) BobTHJ has not deregistered. CFJ 1885: Called by Taral (26 Jan); Judged TRUE by Zefram (31 Jan) Eris' votes of ROOT on Proposal 5412 were valid. CFJ 1884: Called by BobTHJ (26 Jan); Judged UNDECIDABLE by Murphy (26 Jan) Where the above referenced decision on amending the Vote Market agreement able to be validly resolved as of the calling of this CFJ would pikhq's vote of OBJECT be valid? CFJ 1883: Called by BobTHJ (26 Jan); Judged UNDECIDABLE by Murphy (26 Jan) Where the above referenced decision on amending the Vote Market agreement able to be validly resolved as of the calling of this CFJ would Pavitra's vote of OBJECT be valid? CFJ 1882: Called by comex (25 Jan); Judged TRUE by woggle (29 Jan); REMANDED on Appeal (30 Jan); Judged TRUE by woggle (05 Feb) watcher is a Player CFJ 1881: Called by pikhq (25 Jan); Judged FALSE by comex (07 Feb) rule 2029 requires Agorans to always Dance a Powerful Dance. CFJ 1880: Called by comex (22 Jan); Judged TRUE by Iammars (30 Jan) The Agoran Agricultural Association is a contract. CFJ 1879: Called by pikhq (19 Jan); Judged FALSE by Taral (29 Jan); REMANDED on Appeal (07 Feb); Judged FALSE by Wooble (05 Mar) Canada is a nomic. CFJ 1878: Called by woggle (18 Jan); Judged FALSE by root (23 Jan) It is possible to, by announcement, cease to be a party to a contract which has exactly 1 party and which is both a location and a pledge when the contract explicitly permits this. CFJ 1877: Called by woggle (18 Jan); Judged FALSE by root (23 Jan) It is possible to cease to be a party to a location which has exactly 1 party by announcement when the text of the location explicitly permits this. CFJ 1876: Called by woggle (18 Jan); Judged FALSE by root (23 Jan) It is possible to cease to be a party to a pledge which has exactly 1 party by announcement when the text of pledge explicitly permits this. CFJ 1875: Called by Levi (15 Jan); Judged FALSE by OscarMeyr (25 Jan) Levi is The Speaker. CFJ 1874: Called by Levi (15 Jan); Judged TRUE by OscarMeyr (25 Jan) Murphy is The Speaker. CFJ 1873: Called by Levi (15 Jan); Judged FALSE by OscarMeyr (25 Jan) Human Point Two Bears the patent title Minister Without Portfolio. CFJ 1872: Called by pikhq (15 Jan); Judged TRUE by BobTHJ (15 Jan) The Vote Market is a contract. CFJ 1871: Called by G. (15 Jan); Judged FALSE by Zefram (18 Jan) If a judge makes the right judgement but for the wrong reasons, then e has made an inappropriate judgement. CFJ 1870: Called by Zefram (15 Jan); Judged FALSE by pikhq (15 Jan); REMANDED on Appeal (15 Jan); Judged TRUE by pikhq (16 Jan) where a prerogative has been assigned to a person for a particular month, and no assignment of prerogatives has yet been made for the following month, that person loses that prerogative at the end of that month CFJ 1869: Called by pikhq (15 Jan); Judged FALSE by Murphy (15 Jan) it is possible to join the Vote Market while already a member of the Vote Market. CFJ 1868: Called by BobTHJ (14 Jan); Judged INNOCENT by pikhq (16 Jan) woggle breached Rule 911 by assigning an inappropriate judgment to CFJ 1860a. CFJ 1867: Called by BobTHJ (14 Jan); Judged INNOCENT by pikhq (16 Jan) root breached Rule 911 by assigning an inappropriate judgment to CFJ 1860a. CFJ 1866: Called by BobTHJ (14 Jan); Judged INNOCENT by pikhq (16 Jan) Murphy breached Rule 911 by assigning an inappropriate judgment to CFJ 1860a. CFJ 1865: Called by Zefram (14 Jan); Judged FALSE by root (14 Jan) the Patent Title of Champion CAN be awarded by announcement of the Herald to a person who has not won the game CFJ 1864: Called by root (12 Jan); Judged TRUE by Taral (21 Jan) The Left Hand is a partnership. CFJ 1863: Called by Zefram (10 Jan); Judged EXCUSED by G. (14 Jan); REMANDED on Appeal (21 Jan); Judged EXCUSED by G. (29 Jan) BobTHJ violated rule 2158 by failing to assign an appropriate judgement to the question on veracity in CFJ 1860 when obliged to, by means of assigning an inappropriate judgement instead. CFJ 1862: Called by Murphy (10 Jan); Judged FALSE by Iammars (17 Jan) Human Point Two bears the Patent Title of Minister Without Portfolio. CFJ 1861: Called by Iammars (08 Jan); Judged FALSE by OscarMeyr (16 Jan) Players may always be referred to by eir legal name along with eir nickname. CFJ 1860: Called by pikhq (08 Jan); Judged IRRELEVANT by BobTHJ (10 Jan); OVERTURNED on Appeal (14 Jan); Judged FALSE by Iammars (21 Jan) It is a violation of rule 2159 to falsely claim that something is a protective decree to Steve Wallace (the biological person, not necessarily the player). CFJ 1859: Called by comex (01 Jan); Judged FALSE by Murphy (08 Jan) At least one of the votes in root's message with message-id <3fc761710712310956p646fddd3h9ca3b5ceb0c16fe4@mail.gmail.com> is valid. CFJ 1858: Called by woggle (31 Dec); Judged UNAWARE by pikhq (07 Jan); OVERRULED to GUILTY on Appeal (14 Jan) root violated rule 1769 by assigning, during a Holiday, judgement to the judicial question on culpability in CFJ 1838 in the above-quoted message. CFJ 1857: Called by woggle (31 Dec); Judged UNAWARE by pikhq (07 Jan); OVERRULED to GUILTY on Appeal (14 Jan) root violated rule 1769 by assigning, during a Holiday, judgement to the judicial question on culpability in CFJ 1837 in the above-quoted message. CFJ 1856: Called by Zefram (29 Dec); Judged FALSE by G. (08 Jan) Steve Wallace is a player CFJ 1855: Called by pikhq (29 Dec); Judged FALSE by woggle (15 Jan) The AFO is not part of the basis of Agora's Child, but is a partner of Agora's Child. CFJ 1854: Called by avpx (24 Dec); Judged FALSE by root (14 Jan) It is possible to spend VCs that one does not own. CFJ 1853: Called by G. (23 Dec); Judged UNIMPUGNED by Taral (14 Jan) comex has violated Rule 2149 in his communication of voting on proposal 5380. CFJ 1852: Called by G. (23 Dec); Judged UNIMPUGNED by Taral (14 Jan) comex has violated Rule 2149 in his communication of voting on proposal 5375. CFJ 1851: Called by Murphy (22 Dec); Judged TRUE by OscarMeyr (10 Jan) Proposal 5373 was adopted in Message-ID: <476D30DB.6040804@socal.rr.com> CFJ 1850: Called by Murphy (22 Dec); Judged FALSE by root (07 Jan) pikhq won in Message-Id: <200712202153.34050.josiahw@gmail.com> CFJ 1849: Called by Zefram (21 Dec); Judged GUILTY/APOLOGY by Taral (09 Jan); AFFIRMED on Appeal (14 Jan) BobTHJ violated rule 2149 by publishing in message <56732cfd0712210825i54c896f7n9f4795405528894e@mail.gmail.com> a statement that e did not believe was true. CFJ 1848: Called by Murphy (21 Dec); Judged FALSE by Zefram (21 Dec) Futuremyartug is a player. CFJ 1847: Called by Zefram (20 Dec); Judged FALSE by comex (20 Dec) when a person calls for judgement, and has already done so at least five times in the same week, e is awarded one blue mark by section (+b) of rule 2176 CFJ 1846: Called by BobTHJ (20 Dec); Judged FALSE by pikhq (21 Dec); OVERRULED to TRUE on Appeal (07 Jan) The sentence issued by BobTHJ (prior to appeal) in CFJ 1812 included a valid set of prescribed words. CFJ 1845: Called by Murphy (20 Dec); Judged FALSE by OscarMeyr (09 Jan) comex initiated two criminal cases in Message-Id: <200712181706.58039.comexk@gmail.com> CFJ 1844: Called by pikhq (20 Dec); Judged TRUE by Iammars (07 Jan) submitting a protective decree to Steve Wallace is a violation of rule 2159. CFJ 1843: Called by WALRUS (20 Dec); Judged FALSE by G. (20 Dec) It is possible for joining a contract to take effect retroactively. CFJ 1842: Called by WALRUS (20 Dec); Judged UNDETERMINED by G. (20 Dec) It is possible for a contract change to take effect retroactively. CFJ 1841: Called by WALRUS (20 Dec); Judged TRUE by G. (20 Dec) It is possible for a game action to take effect retroactively. CFJ 1840: Called by pikhq (20 Dec); Judged TRUE by Murphy (20 Dec); OVERTURNED on Appeal (31 Dec); Judged FALSE by Zefram (14 Jan) WALRUS is a player. CFJ 1839: Called by pikhq (20 Dec); Judged INNOCENT by Iammars (07 Jan) Zefram violated Rule 2149/8. ("A person SHALL NOT make a public statement unless e believes in doing so e is telling the truth.") In message <20071219230243.GL17928@fysh.org>, Zefram claimed that the attempt to register WALRUS was ineffective, since 'WALRUS does not adequately identify any particular entity'. CFJ 1838: Called by comex (19 Dec); Judged SLIPPERY by root (20 Dec); REMANDED on Appeal (21 Dec); Judged INNOCENT by root (31 Dec) BobTHJ breached Rule 2149 by, as a knight, publishing a statement that e believed to be false in eir message with Message-ID <56732cfd0711041449h23dcc500id9e643c76643d597@mail.gmail.com> CFJ 1837: Called by comex (19 Dec); Judged SLIPPERY by root (20 Dec); REMANDED on Appeal (21 Dec); Judged INNOCENT by root (31 Dec) BobTHJ breached Rule 2149 by, as a knight, publishing a statement that e believed to be false in eir message with Message-ID <56732cfd0710291242h67fc331and43dd1076934828@mail.gmail.com> CFJ 1836: Called by comex (18 Dec); Judged FALSE by pikhq (20 Dec); REMANDED on Appeal (20 Dec); Judged FALSE by pikhq (22 Dec); AFFIRMED on Appeal (07 Jan) Fookiemyartug is a player. CFJ 1835: Called by comex (18 Dec); Judged FALSE by Zefram (20 Dec) In this message, comex submitted a CFJ on the statement "Who am I?" CFJ 1834: Called by comex (18 Dec); Judged TRUE by Zefram (20 Dec) In this message, comex submitted a proposal with the text "No, I'm Spartacus!" CFJ 1833: Called by comex (18 Dec); Judged TRUE by Zefram (20 Dec) In this message, comex submitted a CFJ on the statement "I'm Spartacus!" CFJ 1832: Called by comex (15 Dec); Judged by BobTHJ (20 Dec) The AFO violated a contract not to vote on Proposal 5365. CFJ 1831: Called by pikhq (10 Dec); Judged TRUE by G. (10 Dec); REMANDED on Appeal (11 Dec); Judged FALSE by Taral (20 Dec); REMANDED on Appeal (20 Jan); Judged FALSE by Iammars (05 Feb) The above was a valid vote on the stability of Rulekeepor. CFJ 1830: Called by comex (09 Dec); Judged TRUE by OscarMeyr (10 Dec); REMANDED on Appeal (12 Dec); Judged IRRELEVANT by OscarMeyr (13 Dec) There are elephants over there. CFJ 1829: Called by pikhq (08 Dec); Judged FALSE by Wooble (10 Dec) The Accountor is an office. CFJ 1828: Called by Agora's Child (08 Dec); Judged SLIPPERY by comex (20 Dec); REMANDED on Appeal (14 Jan); Judged UNIMPUGNED by comex (21 Jan) pikhq, as Ambassador, is in violation of rule 2159 by claiming the following to be a protective decree to Steve "cheesworshiper" Wallace: "There is now such a thing as a suffusion of yellow." CFJ 1827: Called by Murphy (06 Dec); Judged FALSE by root (20 Dec) The AFO's VVLOP changed 104 times as a result of comex's message with Message-ID <6bf32280711281839g6adde4a4wdf21f00d231c776b@mail.gmail.com> CFJ 1826: Called by Murphy (06 Dec); Judged FALSE by root (20 Dec) The AFO's VVLOP changed as a result of comex's message with Message-ID <6bf32280711281839g6adde4a4wdf21f00d231c776b@mail.gmail.com> CFJ 1825: Called by Levi (05 Dec); Judged by pikhq (10 Dec) Murphy violated a contract to transfer one Green Mark to Levi. CFJ 1824: Called by comex (04 Dec); Judged INNOCENT by Taral (17 Dec) Goethe violated Rule 2149 by recklessly (and falsely) claiming that I violated Rule 2149. CFJ 1823: Called by G. (04 Dec); Judged INNOCENT by Taral (17 Dec) comex violated Rule 2149 by recklessly (and falsely) claiming that I recklessly claimed a false thing. CFJ 1822: Called by BobTHJ (04 Dec); Judged TRUE by Zefram (04 Dec) The inclusion or exclusion of invalid votes can invalidate the resolution of an Agoran Decision. CFJ 1821: Called by BobTHJ (04 Dec); Judged FALSE by Zefram (10 Dec) Message-Id <56732cfd0712022332k5826ec06o3b92fd665a1e2751@mail.gmail.com> was a valid resolution of an Agoran Decision. CFJ 1820: Called by comex (04 Dec); Judged INNOCENT by Taral (10 Dec) Goethe violated Rule 2149 by publishing the quoted message (with message-id <Pine.LNX.4.43.0712032043080.4740@hymn33.u.washington.edu>). CFJ 1819: Called by pikhq (03 Dec); Judged FALSE by Wooble (04 Dec) On Dec. 3, 2007, Fookiemyartug, comex, and BobTHJ won the game. CFJ 1818: Called by pikhq (02 Dec); Judged FALSE by OscarMeyr (05 Dec) pikhq won the game. CFJ 1817: Called by pikhq (02 Dec); Judged FALSE by root (05 Dec) Win 1-10 were contests. CFJ 1816: Called by pikhq (02 Dec); Judged FALSE by root (05 Dec) pikhq was able to define dependent contracts via a contract. CFJ 1815: Called by Association of Federated Organizations (02 Dec); Judged TRUE by comex (03 Dec) The AFO is a player and a partnership. CFJ 1814: Called by root (29 Nov); Judged FALSE by G. (06 Dec) The AFO won the game as a result of pikhq's message with Message-ID <200711281949.16555.josiahw@gmail.com>. CFJ 1813: Called by root (29 Nov); Judged FALSE by G. (06 Dec) The AFO won the game as a result of comex's message with Message-ID <6bf32280711281839g6adde4a4wdf21f00d231c776b@mail.gmail.com>. CFJ 1812: Called by Levi (29 Nov); Judged GUILTY/APOLOGY by BobTHJ (04 Dec); OVERRULED to EXCUSED on Appeal (05 Dec) pikhq breached rule 2172 by attempting to register Agora as a B Nomic faction without Agoran Consent. CFJ 1811: Called by pikhq (29 Nov); Judged by comex (16 Dec) Murphy is in breach of our contract concerning marks by not sending me 1 blue mark and 1 black mark. CFJ 1810: Called by Murphy (28 Nov); Judged TRUE by Taral (01 Dec) The AFO resolved the Agoran decisions for Proposals 5293 and 5294 in Message-ID: <4745305E.8090405@socal.rr.com> CFJ 1809: Called by pikhq (28 Nov); Judged TRUE by root (29 Nov) sentencing someone to APOLOGY without giving a set of prescribed words means that the apology has a null set of prescribed words. CFJ 1808: Called by pikhq (28 Nov); Judged TRUE by root (29 Nov) sentencing someone to APOLOGY without giving a set of prescribed words means that the apology has a null set of prescribed words. CFJ 1807: Called by root (25 Nov); Judged TRUE by BobTHJ (28 Nov); REMANDED on Appeal (03 Dec); Judged TRUE by BobTHJ (07 Dec) root won the game at or around Sat, 24 Nov 2007 23:29:13 UTC. CFJ 1806: Called by pikhq (24 Nov); Judged UNDECIDABLE by Zefram (29 Nov); REMANDED on Appeal (01 Dec); Judged UNDETERMINED by Zefram (01 Dec) In rule 2126, spending N+1 or N+2 VCs of different colors means that more than one color must be involved. CFJ 1805: Called by BobTHJ (23 Nov); Judged TRUE by pikhq (28 Nov); OVERRULED to FALSE on Appeal (05 Dec) CFJ 1799 is an inquiry case on the permissibility of an action. CFJ 1804: Called by comex (19 Nov); Judged EXCUSED by G. (29 Nov) pikhq breached Rule 2158 by assigning an inappropriate judgement to the question on veracity in CFJ 1711 CFJ 1803: Called by Wooble (19 Nov); Judged FALSE by Murphy (23 Nov) B Nomic is a Player. CFJ 1802: Called by Levi (19 Nov); Judged FALSE by G. (19 Nov) pikhq obtained Agoran Consent to have Agora join B Nomic as a B Nomic faction CFJ 1801: Called by Levi (19 Nov); Judged TRUE by comex (28 Nov) Agoran Consent is required to have Agora join B Nomic as a B Nomic faction CFJ 1800: Called by Murphy (18 Nov); Judged TRUE by root (27 Nov) Goethe initiated an Agoran decision in Message-id: <Pine.LNX.4.43.0711171811460.2595@hymn12.u.washington.edu> CFJ 1799: Called by comex (18 Nov); Judged UNDECIDABLE by BobTHJ (23 Nov); AFFIRMED on Appeal (05 Dec) It is permissible to nkeplwgplxgioyzjvtxjnncsqscvntlbdqromyeyvlhkjgteaqnneqgujjpwcbyfrpueoydjjk CFJ 1798: Called by G. (16 Nov); Judged TRUE by Zefram (19 Nov) Goethe is a coauthor on the Proposal Contests Fix Mk II CFJ 1797: Called by Murphy (14 Nov); Judged FALSE by pikhq (16 Nov) The Bake The Traitor agreement is fair to all contestants while there are no contestants other than comex. CFJ 1796: Called by Murphy (14 Nov); Judged TRUE by Taral (17 Nov) comex can join the Bake The Traitor agreement. CFJ 1795: Called by comex (13 Nov); Judged TRUE by Murphy (17 Nov) CFJ 1794 is an inquiry case on the possibility of a rule-defined action CFJ 1794: Called by comex (13 Nov); Judged TRUE by Murphy (17 Nov) It is possible for Beverly to deregister. CFJ 1793: Called by comex (13 Nov); Judged FALSE by G. (19 Nov) If the announcement of Partnership 1's Contest had been received by the listserver sixty minutes before the announcement dissolving it, all other factors being equal, Partnership 1's Contest would have allowed any first-class player to become a party CFJ 1792: Called by comex (13 Nov); Judged FALSE by G. (19 Nov) If the announcement of Partnership 1's Contest had been received by the listserver sixty seconds before the announcement dissolving it, all other factors being equal, Partnership 1's Contest would have allowed any first-class player to become a party CFJ 1791: Called by Murphy (11 Nov); Judged FALSE by root (12 Nov) Eris's VC holdings as reported in the Assessor's report on or about November 3, 2007 have been ratified. CFJ 1790: Called by Murphy (11 Nov); Judged FALSE by root (12 Nov) Zefram's VC holdings as reported in the Assessor's report on or about November 3, 2007 have been ratified. CFJ 1789: Called by Murphy (11 Nov); Judged FALSE by Taral (11 Nov) The Voting Credit holdings reported in the Assessor's report on or about November 3, 2007 have been ratified. CFJ 1788: Called by Murphy (11 Nov); Judged FALSE by root (11 Nov) The Assessor's report published on or about November 3, 2007 has been ratified. CFJ 1787: Called by root (10 Nov); Judged UNDECIDABLE by Murphy (10 Nov); REMANDED on Appeal (13 Nov); Judged UNDECIDABLE by Murphy (17 Nov) It is permissible to judge the question on veracity in this case FALSE. CFJ 1786: Called by G. (06 Nov); Judged EXCUSED by Taral (07 Nov); OVERTURNED on Appeal (27 Nov); Judged INNOCENT by Murphy (29 Nov) Goethe, while holding the office of Notary, did breach the terms of eir office contained in Rule 2173 by identifying the membership of the private contract known as the AFO without the consent of its members or as allowed by the contract. CFJ 1785: Called by BobTHJ (05 Nov); Judged GUILTY/APOLOGY by Zefram (07 Nov) BobTHJ breached R1504, Criminal Cases, by failing to issue an Apology within 72 hours. CFJ 1784: Called by comex (05 Nov); Judged TRUE by Zefram (19 Nov) The message with subject "BUS: I say I pseudo-judge (fwd)", message-id <Pine.LNX.4.43.0711050913160.1343@hymn31.u.washington.edu> that purported to judge CFJs 1774 and 1775) had the effect of assigning a judgement. CFJ 1783: Called by Zefram (05 Nov); Judged GUILTY/APOLOGY by pikhq (16 Nov) comex breached rule 2149 by knowingly or recklessly claiming, while e was a knight, in message <6bf32280711041554v63a82c17vc2925d02ad455298@mail.gmail.com>, that Fookiemyartug's personness was part of the CotC's weekly report. CFJ 1782: Called by Murphy (04 Nov); Judged TRUE by G. (06 Nov) pikhq initiated a criminal case in Message-id: <200711041446.04509.josiahw@gmail.com> CFJ 1781: Called by pikhq (04 Nov); Judged UNIMPUGNED by comex (17 Nov) proposal 5269 was never submitted, and therefore should not have been distributed. Since the Promoter did this without a submission to the proposal pool, he made a proposal outside of rule 106, and is therefore in violation. CFJ 1780: Called by pikhq (04 Nov); Judged FALSE by Zefram (07 Nov) proposal 5269 was not submitted by pikhq, and it was instead authored by the Promoter. CFJ 1779: Called by Zefram (04 Nov); Judged TRUE by comex (07 Nov) Fookiemyartug is a person CFJ 1778: Called by root (04 Nov); Judged FALSE by Murphy (10 Nov) Judging UNDECIDABLE is permissible. CFJ 1777: Called by Zefram (04 Nov); Judged FALSE by Taral (11 Nov); AFFIRMED on Appeal (18 Nov) Partnership 1's Contest allowed any first-class player to become a party CFJ 1776: Called by comex (01 Nov); Judged TRUE by root (06 Nov) It is possible to deputise for the purpose of changing all sitting players to standing CFJ 1775: Called by Murphy (01 Nov); Judged FALSE by G. (05 Nov) comex initiated exactly one inquiry case in Message-id: <200710281809.40881.comexk@gmail.com> CFJ 1774: Called by Murphy (01 Nov); Judged TRUE by G. (05 Nov) comex did not initiate any inquiry cases in Message-id: <200710281809.40881.comexk@gmail.com> CFJ 1773: Called by Murphy (28 Oct); Judged FALSE by pikhq (04 Nov) comex initiated a criminal case in the message with Message-id: <200710221616.45845.comexk@gmail.com> CFJ 1772: Called by comex (28 Oct); Judged FALSE by Zefram (28 Oct) comex initiated an equity case in eir message dated Mon, 22 Oct 2007 16:16:40 -0400 CFJ 1771: Called by G. (28 Oct); Judged TRUE by root (04 Nov) If an inquiry case revolves around the interpretation of a specific action, and the caller does not provide, in arguments, evidence, or the statement, one of (a) a direct quote of the action; (b) a link or email reference to the action; or (c) an approximate time and date the action was performed in a specified forum, then the judge is acting reasonably if e judges UNDETERMINED. CFJ 1770: Called by root (23 Oct); Judged FALSE by Zefram (24 Oct) Primo Corporation is a person and a player. CFJ 1769: Called by comex (22 Oct); Judged UNDETERMINED by G. (28 Oct) comex has initiated an equity case CFJ 1768: Called by comex (22 Oct); Judged FALSE by Zefram (22 Oct) Rule 2149's obligation on a knights to not publish statements that e believes are false is in conflict with the knight's right of participation in the fora. CFJ 1767: Called by pikhq (21 Oct); Judged FALSE by Taral (21 Oct) When comex gave his consent in agora-discussion (not a public forum) on a panel ruling, this was *not* sufficient to actually be an agreement to the ruling on CFJ 1748a. CFJ 1766: Called by Zefram (16 Oct); Judged TRUE by root (20 Oct) when the CotC has recused with cause a judge who is a non-supine player, and at least a week has passed since the recusal, and the recused player's posture has not changed during that time, the CotC CAN flip that player's posture to supine by announcement CFJ 1765: Called by Zefram (16 Oct); Judged TRUE by root (20 Oct) within the week after the CotC has recused with cause a judge who is a non-supine player, e CAN flip that player's posture to supine by announcement CFJ 1764: Called by comex (07 Oct); Judged TRUE by root (24 Oct) pikhq voted FOR a proposal on or about Sun, 7 Oct 2007 16:19:46 -0600. CFJ 1763: Called by Taral (03 Oct); Judged TRUE by comex (08 Oct) Eris can resolve the Agoran decision e started on 9/17 without violating a rule. CFJ 1762: Called by comex (03 Oct); Judged TRUE by pikhq (07 Oct) The Variety Show does not meet the definition of a contest because it is not fair to all contestants. CFJ 1761: Called by Murphy (30 Sep); Judged FALSE by Zefram (08 Oct) The AFO published the message with Message-id: <46FFFFB9.4070306@socal.rr.com> CFJ 1760: Called by Murphy (30 Sep); Judged TRUE by Zefram (08 Oct) Murphy published the message with Message-id: <46FFFFB9.4070306@socal.rr.com> CFJ 1759: Called by Murphy (30 Sep); Judged TRUE by Zefram (03 Oct) The AFO was the vote collector for the Agoran decision on whether to adopt Proposal 5222 as of the publication of Message-id: <46FFFFB9.4070306@socal.rr.com> CFJ 1758: Called by Murphy (30 Sep); Judged FALSE by Zefram (03 Oct) Murphy was the vote collector for the Agoran decision on whether to adopt Proposal 5222 as of the publication of Message-id: <46FFFFB9.4070306@socal.rr.com> CFJ 1757: Called by root (28 Sep); Judged FALSE by Taral (31 Oct) At or within one minute of Thu, 27 Sep 2007 16:49:15 GMT, root initiated a criminal case. CFJ 1756: Called by root (28 Sep); Judged FALSE by Taral (31 Oct) At or within one minute of Thu, 27 Sep 2007 16:49:15 GMT, root initiated an inquiry case. CFJ 1755: Called by Zefram (28 Sep); Judged TRUE by Wooble (29 Sep) message <46F75B65.3070304@socal.rr.com> had the effect of resolving the Agoran decision on proposals 5224 CFJ 1754: Called by Zefram (28 Sep); Judged FALSE by Taral (29 Sep) message <46EE1408.50406@socal.rr.com> had the effect of resolving the Agoran decisions on proposals 5222 and 5223 CFJ 1753: Called by Murphy (28 Sep); Judged FALSE by root (20 Oct) Murphy left The Variety Show in the message in which this CFJ was called. CFJ 1752: Called by Murphy (28 Sep); Judged FALSE by root (20 Oct) Murphy left The Variety Show when e deregistered. CFJ 1751: Called by Murphy (24 Sep); Judged TRUE by Taral (08 Oct) Murphy caused the AFO to act in Message-ID: <46F73781.6020303@socal.rr.com> CFJ 1750: Called by Murphy (24 Sep); Judged TRUE by Taral (08 Oct) Murphy is a member of the AFO's basis. CFJ 1749: Called by pikhq (24 Sep); Judged TRUE by Zefram (03 Oct) Upon joining Agora as a first-class player, Pikhq obtained one white VC, and is of the white party. CFJ 1748: Called by root (22 Sep); Judged FALSE by Zefram (29 Sep); REMANDED on Appeal (21 Oct); Judged FALSE by Zefram (25 Oct) The ratification of an announcement of the resolution of an Agoran decision can change the decision's outcome. CFJ 1747: Called by comex (21 Sep); Judged FALSE by Murphy (24 Sep) The judicial panel of Murphy, root, and Wooble would be a person if the hypothetical Rule in the evidence section were enacted. CFJ 1746: Called by comex (21 Sep); Judged FALSE by Murphy (24 Sep) The judicial panel of Murphy, root, and Wooble is a person. CFJ 1745: Called by Murphy (18 Sep); Judged FALSE by Wooble (19 Sep); OVERRULED to IRRELEVANT on Appeal (22 Oct) It is possible for a judicial case to have more than one subclass. CFJ 1744: Called by Wooble (18 Sep); Judged UNDETERMINED by Taral (25 Sep) Big Brother is a Player. CFJ 1743: Called by Murphy (18 Sep); Judged TRUE by Zefram (24 Sep) Eris initiated an Agoran decision to determine a new holder for the office of Scorekeepor in the message with Message-id: <fa0147d90709171857m67881bc1ib52ff01709db517c@mail.gmail.com> CFJ 1742: Called by Pavitra (13 Sep); Judged TRUE by Murphy (17 Sep) It is possible for a judicial case to exist that has no subclass. CFJ 1741: Called by Peekee (11 Sep); Judged TRUE by root (18 Sep) Peekee is a player. CFJ 1740: Called by Zefram (06 Sep); Judged GUILTY/CHOKEY by Taral (21 Sep); OVERRULED to APOLOGY on Appeal (21 Sep) BobTHJ violated rule 1504 by failing to notify the defendant in CFJ 1735 as soon as possible while assigned as judge of that case during the pre-trial period. CFJ 1739: Called by comex (29 Aug); Judged UNDETERMINED by Taral (05 Sep) A part of a message sent to a Public Forum that is quoting another message (even if the quote is intended to perform an action) is never a violation of Rule 2149 to publish. CFJ 1738: Called by Zefram (29 Aug); Judged TRUE by root (29 Aug) rule 2149's obligation on a knave to not publish statements that e believes are true is in conflict with the knave's right of participation in the fora. CFJ 1737: Called by Murphy (29 Aug); Judged TRUE by root (21 Sep) The pre-trial phase of a criminal case does not end until one week after the judge informs the defendant of the case and invites em to rebut the argument for eir guilt. CFJ 1736: Called by comex (23 Aug); Judged UNIMPUGNED by Murphy (29 Aug) The Pineapple Partnership failed to hail Eris CFJ 1735: Called by comex (23 Aug); Judged UNIMPUGNED by Zefram (21 Oct) Eris published a statement that e thinks is true CFJ 1734: Called by comex (23 Aug); Judged IRRELEVANT by Taral (24 Aug) comex sucks CFJ 1733: Called by comex (23 Aug); Judged SLIPPERY by root (04 Sep) Eris violated a rule CFJ 1732: Called by comex (23 Aug); Judged TRUE by Zefram (23 Aug) if an inquiry case with the statement "the holder of the office of Clerk of the Courts is Zefram" was judged FALSE, the holder of the office of Clerk of the Courts would be Zefram CFJ 1731: Called by Zefram (23 Aug); Judged TRUE by Murphy (29 Aug) it is possible for a person to bear more than one instance of a patent title simultaneously. CFJ 1730: Called by Pavitra (22 Aug); Judged TRUE by Zefram (30 Aug) The player Goddess Eris assigned judgements to the CFJs 1716, 1710, 1711, 1724, and 1725. CFJ 1729: Called by Zefram (21 Aug); Judged TRUE by root (28 Aug) The Host has awarded Levi a total of 100 points so far. CFJ 1728: Called by BobTHJ (20 Aug); Judged FALSE by Murphy (20 Aug) A player who is an eligible voter may submit an infinite number of votes on a proposal. CFJ 1727: Called by Murphy (17 Aug); Judged FALSE by Wooble (18 Aug) BobTHJ lost one VC for recusing emself from CFJ 1712. CFJ 1726: Called by Murphy (17 Aug); Judged FALSE by comex (17 Aug) BobTHJ lost one Blue VC for recusing emself from CFJ 1712. CFJ 1725: Called by Peekee (16 Aug); Judged UNDETERMINED by Taral (22 Aug) hedgehogcull is a Player. CFJ 1724: Called by Peekee (16 Aug); Judged UNDETERMINED by Taral (22 Aug) eekeeP is a Player. CFJ 1723: Called by root (15 Aug); Judged FALSE by Murphy (21 Aug) On or around August 15, 2007, root initiated an Agoran decision to approve the action of making bd_ inactive. CFJ 1722: Called by root (15 Aug); Judged FALSE by Zefram (20 Aug) On or around August 15, 2007, root initiated an Agoran decision to make bd_ inactive. CFJ 1721: Called by Wooble (13 Aug); Judged TRUE by Zefram (21 Aug) The Person known to Agora as Peekee recently sent a message to the Public Forum containing the text "I did not send the message." CFJ 1720: Called by Zefram (12 Aug); Judged FALSE by root (14 Aug) in CFJ 1715, the alleged act is illegal but impossible. CFJ 1719: Called by root (12 Aug); Judged FALSE by Zefram (15 Aug) Peekee is a player. CFJ 1718: Called by Peekee (08 Aug); Judged IRRELEVANT by root (13 Aug) Peekee submitted an email to the agora-discussion forum containing "Fnord!" CFJ 1717: Called by Peekee (08 Aug); Judged TRUE by Murphy (13 Aug) Murphy submitted a proposal in eir recent post with subject "What is the title of this proposal?" CFJ 1716: Called by comex (03 Aug); Judged UNIMPUGNED by Taral (22 Aug) Peekee has violated Rule 2149 by deliberately or recklessly making the false statement "maybe" CFJ 1715: Called by comex (03 Aug); Judged UNIMPUGNED by Wooble (14 Aug) Peekee has violated Rule 754 by sending communication with little regularity. CFJ 1714: Called by Wooble (03 Aug); Judged UNDECIDABLE by Zefram (03 Aug); AFFIRMED on Appeal (07 Aug) A Player of Agora who is not the Ambassador CAN unilaterally take Game Actions in a foreign nomic on Agora's behalf if it is legal for Agora to take those Actions in the foreign nomic. CFJ 1713: Called by Zefram (02 Aug); Judged TRUE by Wooble (02 Aug) CFJ 1712 is a criminal case. CFJ 1712: Called by Murphy (01 Aug); Judged UNIMPUGNED by Wooble (15 Aug) CotC Zefram violated Rule 1871 (The Standing Court) by changing all sitting players to standing on or about Mon, 30 Jul 2007 22:11:48 +0100. CFJ 1711: Called by Murphy (01 Aug); Judged FALSE by Taral (22 Aug); REMANDED on Appeal (07 Oct); Judged TRUE by pikhq (21 Oct); OVERRULED to FALSE on Appeal (22 Oct) Proposal 5085 was adopted on or about Mon, 23 Jul 2007 06:25:41 -0700. CFJ 1710: Called by Murphy (01 Aug); Judged FALSE by Taral (22 Aug) Proposal 5085 was adopted on or about Sun, 22 Jul 2007 20:31:06 -0700. CFJ 1709: Called by Zefram (26 Jul); Judged IRRELEVANT by comex (05 Aug) rule 1742's obligation to act in accordance with contracts is binding on non-player parties to R1742 contracts. CFJ 1708: Called by Zefram (23 Jul); Judged UNIMPUGNED by Murphy (29 Aug) comex violated rule 2149 by falsely claiming in message <6bf32280707091136l373a0b37m7e5516a9279d2335@mail.gmail.com> that eir nickname is "Murphy". CFJ 1707: Called by Zefram (20 Jul); Judged TRUE by Human Point Two (23 Jul) B Nomic met rule 2147's requirements at the time of BobTHJ's message on 2007-06-14 in which e claimed to make B Nomic a protectorate. CFJ 1706: Called by BobTHJ (20 Jul); Judged TRUE by Pineapple Partnership (23 Jul) Gunner Nomic 2.0 is not a non-natural person by the rules of Agora. CFJ 1705: Called by Murphy (18 Jul); Judged TRUE by BobTHJ (24 Jul) It is possible for the Speaker to hold the office of Clerk of the Courts. CFJ 1704: Called by Zefram (17 Jul); Judged TRUE by Murphy (19 Jul) Primo Corporation is a protectorate. CFJ 1703: Called by OscarMeyr (13 Jul); Judged FALSE by root (19 Jul) Comex successfully changed eir nickname to Murphy on 9 July 2007. CFJ 1702: Called by Murphy (12 Jul); Judged TRUE by Zefram (01 Aug) A requirement to submit something to an officer is satisfied by publishing it, even if that office is vacant at the time. CFJ 1701: Called by Zefram (11 Jul); Judged FALSE by Human Point Two (21 Jul) to qualify as a member of a partnership one must be responsible for all of the partnership's obligations. CFJ 1700: Called by Zefram (10 Jul); Judged TRUE by Wooble (19 Jul) Peekee's colleague Jon is a person. CFJ 1699: Called by Zefram (09 Jul); Judged FALSE by BobTHJ (25 Jul) comex has violated rule 2149 by falsely claiming in message <6bf32280707091136l373a0b37m7e5516a9279d2335@mail.gmail.com> that eir nickname is "Murphy". CFJ 1698: Called by comex (09 Jul); Judged FALSE by Zefram (24 Jul) The player with the email address emurphy42@socal.rr.com has violated Rule 1586 by having the same nickname as me (the caller of this CFJ). CFJ 1697: Called by BobTHJ (02 Jul); Judged TRUE by Pineapple Partnership (20 Jul) Since the repeal of Gunner Nomic 2.0 rule 357.3 Gunner Nomic no longer satisfies the conditions of a Player of Agora. CFJ 1696: Called by BobTHJ (02 Jul); Judged TRUE by Pineapple Partnership (20 Jul) Since the repeal of Gunner Nomic 2.0 rule 357.3, Gunner Nomic no longer satisfies the conditions of a Partnership. CFJ 1695: Called by Levi (23 Jun); Judged TRUE by root (13 Jul) BobTHJ can vote on behalf of Primo Corporation CFJ 1694: Called by BobTHJ (22 Jun); Judged TRUE by Primo Corporation (16 Jul) Gunner Nomic 2.0 has allowed Agora unrestricted access to change its ruleset. CFJ 1693: Called by root (20 Jun); Judged TRUE by Murphy (28 Jun) CFJ 1684 has been judged. CFJ 1692: Called by root (20 Jun); Judged TRUE by Murphy (28 Jun) A CFJ that was called on or around May 25, 2007 is identified by the index 1684. CFJ 1691: Called by comex (20 Jun); Judged TRUE by Murphy (29 Jun) The Pineapple Partnership is a person. CFJ 1690: Called by G. (19 Jun); Judged TRUE by Zefram (28 Jun) Prior to this CFJ, the results of Proposal 4977 were not challenged. CFJ 1689: Called by comex (15 Jun); Judged FALSE by root (28 Jun) root changed his Primo Corporation share holdings to 1 million on or about Wed, 6 Jun 2007 21:35:18 -0600. CFJ 1688: Called by Murphy (15 Jun); Judged TRUE by root (06 Aug) Murphy is the author of Proposal 4939. CFJ 1687: Called by Zefram (08 Jun); Judged FALSE by Human Point Two (29 Jun); SUSTAINED on Appeal (19 Jul) a binding agreement created under the laws of the state of Colorado can form a partnership that constitutes a person in Agoran law CFJ 1686: Called by BobTHJ (07 Jun); Judged FALSE by Murphy (13 Jun) root has violated the agreement titled "Primo Corporation Charter" CFJ 1685: Called by G. (31 May); Judged FALSE by Zefram (08 Jun) root's keyboard is a player. CFJ 1684: Called by root (26 May); Judged FALSE by Taral (19 Jun); OVERRULED to TRUE on Appeal (02 Aug) The Pineapple Partnership is a person. CFJ 1683: Called by Zefram (23 May); Judged FALSE by Human Point Two (26 May) a binding agreement under rule 1742 can be made among a set of exactly zero players (the empty set) CFJ 1682: Called by Zefram (23 May); Judged FALSE by Human Point Two (26 May) a binding agreement under rule 1742 can be made among a set of exactly one player CFJ 1681: Called by comex (22 May); Judged FALSE by Human Point Two (26 May) Within three minutes before Mon, 21 May 2007 20:19:27 -0500, Yin Corp was a person distinct from Quazie CFJ 1680: Called by comex (22 May); Judged FALSE by Human Point Two (26 May) Yin Corp and Yang Corp are the same person CFJ 1679: Called by comex (22 May); Judged FALSE by Human Point Two (26 May) Yang Corp is a person CFJ 1678: Called by comex (22 May); Judged FALSE by Human Point Two (26 May) Yin Corp is a person CFJ 1677: Called by comex (22 May); Judged FALSE by Pineapple Partnership (29 Jun) this is not a CFJ CFJ 1676: Called by comex (22 May); Judged TRUE by BobTHJ (07 Jun) this is a CFJ CFJ 1675: Called by Murphy (20 May); Judged FALSE by The Hanging Judge (23 May) Quorum for a proposal is based on the maximum number of eligible voters at any time during the voting period. CFJ 1674: Called by Murphy (20 May); Judged FALSE by The Hanging Judge (23 May) Quorum for a proposal is based on the number of eligible voters at the end of the voting period. CFJ 1673: Called by Murphy (20 May); Judged FALSE by The Hanging Judge (23 May) Quorum for a proposal is based on the number of eligible voters at the start of the voting period. CFJ 1672: Called by Quazie (18 May); Judged TRUE by The Hanging Judge (07 Jun) The International Associate Director of Personnel is the Director of Personnel. CFJ 1671: Called by comex (17 May); Judged TRUE by BobTHJ (07 Jun) Second-System Effect registered on or about Sun, 13 May 2007 16:09:28 -0700 CFJ 1670: Called by Zefram (16 May); Judged TRUE by Murphy (08 Jun) where a proposal's distribution has a different text from the proposal's submission, and the proposal is adopted, the version of the proposal that takes effect is the distributed version CFJ 1669: Called by Zefram (16 May); Judged FALSE by Murphy (08 Jun) where a purported distribution of a proposal has a text that is slightly and non-obviously different from the text of the proposal as submitted, and otherwise conforms to the rules' requirements on proposal distribution, this constitutes a distribution of the submitted proposal CFJ 1668: Called by Zefram (14 May); Judged FALSE by The Hanging Judge (23 May) if a partnership agreement allows for the set of partners to change, and such a change occurs from one set of natural persons to a different set of natural persons, then the partnership defined before the change is a different legal person from the partnership defined after the change. CFJ 1667: Called by Zefram (14 May); Judged FALSE by The Hanging Judge (23 May) if there is a partnership agreement A, defining a partnership PA, for which the partners are a partnership PB and one of PB's members M, then PA is the same legal person as PB. CFJ 1666: Called by Zefram (14 May); Judged FALSE by The Hanging Judge (23 May) if two binding agreements each purport to construct a partnership, and the set of partners is the same for both, then the two agreements construct and govern a single partnership. CFJ 1665: Called by Murphy (14 May); Judged TRUE by BobTHJ (28 Jun) Immediately after Goethe's message with Message-ID <Pine.LNX.4.43.0705140907210.23516@hymn08.u.washington.edu>, one or more of (BobTHJ, Eris, Levi, Maud, Peter, Sherlock) were Partners as described by the Pineapple Partnership agreement. CFJ 1664: Called by Murphy (14 May); Judged TRUE by BobTHJ (28 Jun) Immediately after Goethe's message with Message-ID <Pine.LNX.4.43.0705140907210.23516@hymn08.u.washington.edu>, one or more of (comex, Eris, Manu, Maud, Quazie, Sherlock) were Partners as described by the Pineapple Partnership agreement. CFJ 1663: Called by Murphy (14 May); Judged FALSE by BobTHJ (28 Jun) Immediately after Goethe's message with Message-ID <Pine.LNX.4.43.0705140907210.23516@hymn08.u.washington.edu>, one or more of (GreyKnight, Levi, Manu, Maud, sproingie) were Partners as described by the Pineapple Partnership agreement. CFJ 1662: Called by Murphy (14 May); Judged FALSE by BobTHJ (28 Jun) Immediately after Goethe's message with Message-ID <Pine.LNX.4.43.0705140907210.23516@hymn08.u.washington.edu>, one or more of (OscarMeyr, Peter, Quazie, Sherlock, sproingie) were Partners as described by the Pineapple Partnership agreement. CFJ 1661: Called by Murphy (14 May); Judged TRUE by BobTHJ (28 Jun) Immediately after Goethe's message with Message-ID <Pine.LNX.4.43.0705140907210.23516@hymn08.u.washington.edu>, there were exactly two Partners, including Zefram, as described by the Pineapple Partnership agreement. CFJ 1660: Called by Murphy (13 May); Judged TRUE by root (13 Jun) The words "Office" and "Officer" used by the charter of Primo Corporation, when qualified by the additional phrase "of Primo Corporation", are not bound by the Rule definition of the words "Office" and "Officer". CFJ 1659: Called by Murphy (13 May); Judged FALSE by root (13 Jun) The phrase "by announcement" and similar phrases used by the charter of Primo Corporation, when qualified by the additional phrase "to the Corporate Forum", are not bound by the standard Rule definition of the phrase "by announcement". CFJ 1658: Called by comex (11 May); Judged TRUE by Zefram (28 Jun) The term 'contract' as used in R2136 should be interpreted as synonymous with 'binding agreement'. CFJ 1657: Called by comex (11 May); Judged FALSE by Zefram (28 Jun) The term 'contract' as used in R2136 should be interpreted as synonymous with 'Agoran Contract'. CFJ 1656: Called by Zefram (09 May); Judged TRUE by root (13 Jun) the Promotor has distributed a proposal under the description "proposal 4963" which includes the text "Change the Power of rule 2126 to 2." CFJ 1655: Called by Zefram (09 May); Judged FALSE by root (13 Jun) the Promotor has distributed the proposal titled "mostly-random judicial assignments" submitted by Zefram CFJ 1654: Called by Zefram (06 May); Judged TRUE by comex (14 May) item (a) in rule 683 requires that for a ballot to be valid its submitter must be an eligible voter at the time that that the ballot's validity is determined CFJ 1653: Called by Zefram (06 May); Judged FALSE by comex (14 May) item (a) in rule 683 requires that for a ballot to be valid its submitter must be an eligible voter at the time that the ballot is submitted CFJ 1652: Called by Zefram (06 May); Judged TRUE by comex (14 May) the set of eligible voters on an Agoran decision can change during its voting period CFJ 1651: Called by Zefram (06 May); Judged TRUE by Quazie (18 May); OVERTURNED on Appeal (12 Jul); Judged TRUE by Murphy (07 Aug) if a R107 notice initiating an Agoran decision does not contain an explicit list of the eligible voters, and there is later a dispute (evidenced by submission of a CFJ) over which voters were eligible at that time, then the notice's description of the class of eligible voters was necessarily insufficient to enable public agreement on which persons are eligible CFJ 1650: Called by Zefram (06 May); Judged TRUE by Murphy (11 May) a message labelled as a "distribution of proposals" and detailing the text and other attributes of proposals, as has been periodically published during the first quarter of 2007, in the absence of public disagreement over voter eligibility, qualifies as a set of R107 notices initiating the Agoran decisions on the adoption of those proposals CFJ 1649: Called by BobTHJ (04 May); Judged TRUE by Zefram (13 Jun) BobTHJ is an eligible voter on proposals 4947-4957 CFJ 1648: Called by Murphy (01 May); Judged TRUE by Maud (14 May) BobTHJ registered on or about Mon, 30 Apr 2007 12:06:41 -0600. CFJ 1647: Called by Taral (30 Apr); Judged FALSE by Murphy (29 Jun) Murphy's message with datestamp Sun, 29 Apr 2007 16:59:19 -0700 had the effect of submitting a proposal. CFJ 1646: Called by Zefram (30 Apr); Judged TRUE by Taral (18 May) Quazie's VC spending in the message identified by message ID <4635317D.8030401@gmail.com> took effect in the Agoran week beginning at 00:00 UTC on 30 April 2007. CFJ 1645: Called by Zefram (29 Apr); Dismissed by G. (29 Apr) where a proposal attempts two separate rule changes affecting the same rule, if one of the attempted rule changes is not possible and the other is then the possible rule change does in fact occur, even if both attempted rule changes were specified in a single sentence, unless the proposal explicitly requires a different resolution CFJ 1644: Called by Zefram (29 Apr); Judged TRUE by G. (29 Apr) where a proposal contains the form of words "Change the power of rule NNNN to P and amend it by XXX.", where XXX specifies a text change, this constitutes two attempted rule changes CFJ 1643: Called by Zefram (29 Apr); Judged FALSE by G. (29 Apr) where a proposal specifies a single rule amendment in two parts, and one of the parts is not possible, the whole attempted amendment fails, even if the other part could have been applied if it stood alone CFJ 1642: Called by Zefram (29 Apr); Judged FALSE by G. (29 Apr) where a proposal contains the form of words "Amend rule NNNN by XXX. Further amend rule NNNN by YYY.", where both XXX and YYY specify text changes, this constitutes a single attempt at a rule change, even though it is specified in two parts in separate sentences CFJ 1641: Called by Zefram (29 Apr); Judged TRUE by G. (29 Apr) where a proposal contains the form of words "Amend rule NNNN by XXX and by YYY.", where both XXX and YYY specify text changes, this constitutes a single attempt at a rule change, even though it is specified in two parts CFJ 1640: Called by Zefram (29 Apr); Judged TRUE by G. (29 Apr) where a proposal contains the form of words "Amend rule NNNN by XXX and YYY.", where both XXX and YYY specify text changes, this constitutes a single attempt at a rule change, even though it is specified in two parts CFJ 1639: Called by Zefram (29 Apr); Judged TRUE by G. (29 Apr) where a proposal attempts two separate amendments of the text of the same rule, if one of the attempted amendments is not possible and the other is then the possible amendment does in fact occur, unless the proposal explicitly requires a different resolution CFJ 1638: Called by Zefram (29 Apr); Judged TRUE by G. (29 Apr) where a proposal contains the form of words "Amend rule NNNN by XXX. Amend rule NNNN by YYY.", this constitutes two separate attempts at rule changes, even though both attempt to amend the same rule CFJ 1637: Called by G. (29 Apr); Dismissed by Zefram (29 Apr) If no punishment is proscribed for a given action, that action is not illegal. CFJ 1636: Called by G. (29 Apr); Judged FALSE by Zefram (29 Apr) If an action can not be punished, than no punishment is proscribed. CFJ 1635: Called by G. (29 Apr); Judged TRUE by Zefram (29 Apr) If an action is not performed, it can not be punished. CFJ 1634: Called by G. (29 Apr); Judged FALSE by Zefram (29 Apr) If an action is ineffective, it is not performed. CFJ 1633: Called by G. (29 Apr); Dismissed by Zefram (29 Apr) If an action is illegal, it is considered ineffective. CFJ 1632: Called by G. (29 Apr); Judged FALSE by Zefram (29 Apr) If the rules proscribe a punishment for a given action, that action is illegal. CFJ 1631: Called by Murphy (29 Apr); Judged FALSE by OscarMeyr (06 May) comex registered on or about Sat, 28 Apr 2007 22:00:01 -0400. CFJ 1630: Called by G. (29 Apr); Dismissed by Levi (29 Apr) We're all mad, here. CFJ 1629: Called by G. (29 Apr); Dismissed by Pineapple Partnership (11 May) There are elephants to the left. CFJ 1628: Called by G. (29 Apr); Dismissed by Zefram (29 Apr) Zefram is wearing a hat. CFJ 1627: Called by Zefram (29 Apr); Judged FALSE by Maud (05 May) the text in exhibit A, if enacted into a Rule, would conflict with Rule 101 CFJ 1626: Called by Murphy (08 Apr); Judged TRUE by Zefram (11 Apr) A rule cannot directly enact, modify, or repeal a rule (including itself), unless it takes precedence over the last paragraph of Rule 105. CFJ 1625: Called by Zefram (01 Apr); Judged FALSE by Pineapple Partnership (29 Apr) proposal 4805 succeeded in amending rule 2101 (prior to repealing it) CFJ 1624: Called by Zefram (01 Apr); Judged TRUE by Levi (11 Apr) neither rule 2009 nor rule 2037 has been repealed CFJ 1623: Called by Murphy (27 Feb); Judged TRUE by Pineapple Partnership (27 Mar) The Pineapple Partnership is a person. CFJ 1622: Called by Pineapple Partnership (26 Feb); Judged TRUE by G. (13 Mar) the Pineapple Partnership is a person CFJ 1621: Called by Murphy (08 Feb); Judged FALSE by OscarMeyr (12 Apr); REMANDED on Appeal (26 Jun); Judged TRUE by OscarMeyr (23 Jul) GreyKnight is a player. CFJ 1620: Called by Quazie (06 Feb); Judged FALSE by Zefram (22 Feb) The following statement from the judgment of CFJ 1589 is true 'All players that were inactive when 4866 was adopted are considered inactive for any such rule until they next participate in Agora, from which point they should be considered active.' CFJ 1619: Called by Quazie (06 Feb); Judged FALSE by Zefram (22 Feb) Any actions Quazie has preformed since september 18th 2006 that are limited to active players never happened CFJ 1618: Called by Quazie (06 Feb); Judged FALSE by Zefram (22 Feb) Quazie is inactive CFJ 1617: Called by Murphy (06 Feb); Judged TRUE by G. (11 Apr) Rule 2024 should be interpreted such that "same Agoran Week" means "same Agoran Week as the possibly-Excess CFJ". CFJ 1616: Called by G. (02 Feb); Judged TRUE by Sherlock (28 Feb) Zefram is a person. CFJ 1615: Called by G. (02 Feb); Judged TRUE by Sherlock (28 Feb) Zefram successfully called for judgement on or about Fri, 2 Feb 2007 10:06:14 +0000. CFJ 1614: Called by Zefram (02 Feb); Dismissed by OscarMeyr (25 Feb) Zefram is an avocado. CFJ 1613: Called by G. (02 Feb); Dismissed by Peter (27 Feb) Zefram is a pineapple. CFJ 1612: Called by Zefram (31 Jan); Dismissed by GreyKnight (31 Jan); Judged TRUE by Murphy (11 Apr) Rule 1871 should be interpreted such that it is possible to publish a Notice of Rotation, and that such a Notice has the effect of making all turned players unturned, even if there is no open CFJ with no Trial Judge assigned to it CFJ 1611: Called by Zefram (31 Jan); Dismissed by GreyKnight (31 Jan); Judged TRUE by comex (26 Jun) GreyKnight has violated Rule 1868 by failing to assign a Trial Judge to CFJs 1600 to 1604 CFJ 1610: Called by Zefram (31 Jan); Dismissed by GreyKnight (31 Jan); Judged FALSE by G. (06 Apr) this is an Excess CFJ CFJ 1609: Called by Maud (13 Jan); Judged FALSE by Cecilius (28 Feb) Michael's message, on or about 11 January 2007, reading in part "I hereby vote AGAINST all proposals currently up for vote", did not have the effect of submitting any ballots. CFJ 1608: Called by G. (12 Jan); Judged TRUE by Maud (29 Mar) Unanimous (Voting index = Unanimity) Proposals may be adopted. CFJ 1607: Called by G. (12 Jan); Judged FALSE by Cecilius (02 Feb) Non-Unanimous (Voting index not Unanimity) Agoran Decisions may not be adopted. CFJ 1606: Called by G. (11 Jan); Dismissed by Murphy (30 Mar) Goethe was deregistered in a Writ of FAGE in December 2006. CFJ 1605: Called by Zefram (11 Jan); Judged FALSE by Murphy (06 Feb) Rule 955 should be interpreted such a voting index of "Unanimity" cannot meet or exceed any numerical adoption index. CFJ 1604: Called by Zefram (10 Jan); Judged FALSE by Murphy (26 Feb) it is impossible to assign to Judge this CFJ any player who was registered at the time it was called. CFJ 1603: Called by Zefram (10 Jan); Judged TRUE by Murphy (26 Feb) being Barred from judging a CFJ does not constitute being Barred from judging a set of Linked CFJs containing that CFJ, even though it has the effect of making the Barred person ineligible to Judge such a set of Linked CFJs under some circumstances. CFJ 1602: Called by Zefram (10 Jan); Judged TRUE by Murphy (26 Feb) a set of Linked CFJs is an entity distinct from the individual CFJs from which it is composed. CFJ 1601: Called by Zefram (10 Jan); Judged FALSE by Murphy (26 Feb) when a Judge is to be assigned to a set of Linked CFJs as required by Rule 2024, references in Rule 698 to "that CFJ" or "that increasingly annoying CFJ" must be interpreted as references to the set of Linked CFJs. CFJ 1600: Called by Zefram (10 Jan); Judged TRUE by Murphy (26 Feb) in Rule 698 the phrase "all barred players" means all Players that are Barred from Judging the increasingly annoying CFJ. CFJ 1599: Called by Murphy (04 Jan); Judged TRUE by OscarMeyr (02 Feb) Rule 402 (Church and State) may cause the Clerk of the Courts to become Speaker. CFJ 1598: Called by Sherlock (30 Dec); Judged FALSE by GreyKnight (31 Jan) Murphy received more than one Patent Title of Champion on December 30th, 2006 CFJ 1597: Called by G. (22 Dec); Judged FALSE by Michael (31 Jan) An appeal of the Trial Judgement for CFJ 1594 may not be initiated. CFJ 1596: Called by Quazie (21 Dec); Judged FALSE by OscarMeyr (29 Mar) CFJ 1594 has been judged. CFJ 1595: Called by Murphy (18 Dec); Dismissed by Quazie (24 Jan) Agora is dead. CFJ 1594: Called by Murphy (16 Dec); Judged TRUE by Sherlock (21 Dec); REVERSED on Appeal (30 Mar) Players cannot be deregistered due to Rule 1789. CFJ 1593: Called by G. (01 Dec); Judged FALSE by Murphy (30 Mar) Evantine is a Fugitive from Justice. CFJ 1592: Called by G. (01 Dec); Judged TRUE by Murphy (30 Mar) Evantine holds the patent title Fugitive. CFJ 1591: Called by G. (01 Dec); Judged TRUE by Murphy (30 Mar) Evantine is a Fugitive. CFJ 1590: Called by Murphy (18 Sep); Judged FALSE by GreyKnight (09 Nov) Quazie is eligible to be a Judge. CFJ 1589: Called by Murphy (18 Sep); Judged FALSE by GreyKnight (09 Nov); REVERSED on Appeal (02 Feb) Quazie is inactive. CFJ 1588: Called by G. (07 May); Judged FALSE by Murphy (24 Jul) An Appeal may not be initiated twice for the same trial judgement. CFJ 1587: Called by G. (05 Apr); Dismissed by Taral (02 Aug) If, as part of eir duties with respect to the Speaker's Veto, the Assessor publishes a copy of a vetoed proposal with clear indication that it become a proposal, then the Assessor is the Proposer of that new Proposal. CFJ 1586: Called by G. (05 Apr); Judged TRUE by Taral (02 Aug) The text in the most recent Proposal Pool Report, purporting to be Proposal 06-017 ("Fixing Your Turn"), is a Proposal. CFJ 1585: Called by G. (21 Mar); Judged FALSE by OscarMeyr (18 Jun) The Deckmastor may legally deal a card to Goethe, thus satisfying a pending draw, but e may not legally deal a card to Quazie. CFJ 1584: Called by G. (24 Feb); Judged FALSE by Michael (20 Mar) Sherlock has made an infinite number of notes that The Library held a winning hand. CFJ 1583: Called by Sherlock (24 Feb); Judged FALSE by Taral (06 Mar) Sherlock played Corporate Bankruptcy on February 10th, 2006. CFJ 1582: Called by G. (21 Feb); Judged FALSE by Manu (01 Mar) Conclaves have a quorum of 5. CFJ 1581: Called by root (20 Feb); Judged FALSE by G. (01 Mar) Proposal 06-006, titled "Quick Conclave Fix" and submitted by root on February 20, 2006, is democratic. CFJ 1580: Called by G. (12 Jan); Judged FALSE by Murphy (13 Feb) Maud performed a regulated action in this message: http://www.agoranomic.org/cgi-bin/mailman/private/agora-business/2006-January/005510.html CFJ 1579: Called by Taral (21 Dec); Judged FALSE by Michael (16 Jan) Eris gained an albatross of the Thief from eir play of Thieves in the Night naming Riail. CFJ 1578: Called by Taral (21 Dec); Judged FALSE by Michael (16 Jan) Eris's play of Thieves in the Night naming Riail was successful. CFJ 1577: Called by Sherlock (17 Dec); Judged FALSE by OscarMeyr (13 Feb) The Registrar has not legally resolved the Rebellion that occurred on December 15th, 2005. CFJ 1576: Called by G. (31 Oct); Judged TRUE by Maud (17 Nov) Goethe successfully played Corporate Bankruptcy on or about Oct. 31, 2005. CFJ 1575: Called by G. (26 Aug); Judged TRUE by Taral (26 Sep) root is required to deliver a legal judgement for CFJ 1278. CFJ 1574: Called by Manu (28 Jul); Judged FALSE by OscarMeyr (14 Aug) All Cards curently defined in the Onepower Cardbook that change Kudos (other than fees) are invalid and have no effect. CFJ 1573: Called by Maud (04 Jul); Judged FALSE by G. (11 Jul) OscarMeyr became Speaker on or about 22:58:35 on 30 June 2005. CFJ 1572: Called by Maud (06 Jun); Judged TRUE by Murphy (26 Jun) The phrase "no Votes were cast AGAINST it" in rule 2095 should be interpreted as "any vote cast AGAINST it either was cancelled or at the end of the voting period had a vote value besides AGAINST". CFJ 1571: Called by root (04 Jun); Judged TRUE by Sherlock (17 Jun) The orders executed by Goethe in the second message submitted as evidence are improper. CFJ 1570: Called by root (04 Jun); Judged TRUE by Sherlock (17 Jun) The legality of at least one of the transfers referenced by Goethe in the first message submitted as evidence cannot be determined with finality, as required by the rule "Win by Paradox". CFJ 1569: Called by Manu (25 May); Judged FALSE by Maud (08 Jun) Manu successfully transfered a Kudo from a Contract to emself at least once. CFJ 1568: Called by OscarMeyr (22 May); Judged TRUE by Michael (25 May) root is Noisy. CFJ 1567: Called by G. (20 May); Judged TRUE by Manu (27 May) If Sherlock has a One Share card, then Goethe errored in good faith in determining the cards to deal, and the errors did not greatly change the probability of the cards that were selected. CFJ 1566: Called by Quazie (13 May); Judged FALSE by root (22 May) Eris is guilty of Delay of Game after Quazie played Your Turn indicating Eris. CFJ 1565: Called by Maud (12 May); Judged FALSE by G. (13 Jun) The holder of power of attorney for a player who is not the speaker may deregister that player. CFJ 1564: Called by Sherlock (05 May); Dismissed by Murphy (15 May) Goethe possesses a Not Your Turn card. CFJ 1563: Called by Sherlock (05 May); Dismissed by OscarMeyr (14 May) Goethe possesses a Discard Picking card. CFJ 1562: Called by G. (03 May); Judged TRUE by Michael (05 May) A cancelled vote on a Proposal does not count towards quorum. CFJ 1561: Called by Manu (29 Apr); Judged TRUE by G. (05 May) The Library can not receive Boons and/or Patent Titles CFJ 1560: Called by Sherlock (27 Apr); Judged TRUE by OscarMeyr (05 May) The Justiciar's report was not ratified in 2003. CFJ 1559: Called by Quazie (23 Apr); Judged FALSE by Manu (27 Apr) Quazie successfully played Library Renewal on April 21st CFJ 1558: Called by Quazie (18 Apr); Judged TRUE by Maud (24 Apr) When gazebo_dude deregistered, Thieves in the Night was returned to the deck CFJ 1557: Called by G. (18 Apr); Judged FALSE by Manu (20 Apr) Quazie's private Orders to Goethe on or about Mon, 11 Apr 2005 22:41:06 were improperly executed. CFJ 1556: Called by G. (18 Apr); Judged FALSE by Manu (20 Apr) Goethe's private Orders to Quazie on or about Mon, 11 Apr 2005 19:27:50 were improperly executed. CFJ 1555: Called by G. (18 Apr); Judged TRUE by Manu (19 Apr) Quazie's private Orders to Goethe on or about Sat, 9 Apr 2005 04:28:32 were improperly executed. CFJ 1554: Called by Quazie (18 Apr); Judged TRUE by root (25 Apr) At least one proposal containing a rule change, that was submitted after Rule 1561 was created, has taken effect. CFJ 1553: Called by root (18 Apr); Judged FALSE by OscarMeyr (21 Apr) The Assessor may refuse to assign a voting index to an aborted proposal. CFJ 1552: Called by root (18 Apr); Judged FALSE by OscarMeyr (21 Apr) The Assessor may refuse to publish the votes cast on an aborted proposal. CFJ 1551: Called by root (18 Apr); Judged FALSE by OscarMeyr (21 Apr) An aborted proposal necessarily fails. CFJ 1550: Called by root (18 Apr); Judged FALSE by OscarMeyr (21 Apr); SUSTAINED on Appeal (03 Jun); REVERSED on Appeal (19 Jun) When a proposal is aborted, all votes cast on it are canceled. CFJ 1549: Called by root (18 Apr); Judged TRUE by OscarMeyr (21 Apr) When a proposal is aborted, its voting period immediately ends, if it has not ended already. CFJ 1548: Called by Quazie (17 Apr); Judged TRUE by root (05 May) root successfully played 'drop your weapon' on saturday april 16th CFJ 1547: Called by Murphy (15 Apr); Judged TRUE by Michael (20 Apr) Multiple CFJs are not linked unless they are clearly labelled as Linked CFJs within the message in which they are submitted. CFJ 1546: Called by root (14 Apr); Judged TRUE by Kolja (20 Apr) In reports and distributions, the Promotor is permitted to add or delete whitespace or other formatting text to or from a proposal, provided that the substance of the proposal is not altered. CFJ 1545: Called by Quazie (14 Apr); Dismissed by Murphy (26 Apr) Goethe's order to Quazie, ordering Quazie to withdraw eir orders because they were invalid, was a valid order CFJ 1544: Called by Quazie (14 Apr); Judged TRUE by Kolja (21 Apr) Quazie's order to Goethe, ordering Goethe to publicly announce that e is a Ninny, was a valid order CFJ 1543: Called by Quazie (14 Apr); Judged TRUE by Maud (24 Apr) Quazie's order to Goethe, ordering Goethe to dance, was a valid order CFJ 1542: Called by Kolja (12 Apr); Judged FALSE by Sherlock (19 Apr) The rules currently define no card with the caption "Your Turn". CFJ 1541: Called by Murphy (12 Apr); Judged FALSE by G. (18 Apr) On or about Sun, 10 Apr 2005 23:46:45 -0400, root submitted a Call for Judgement with the statement "Quazie attempted to declare Presence on several Ordinary proposals". CFJ 1540: Called by Murphy (12 Apr); Judged FALSE by G. (18 Apr) On or about Sun, 10 Apr 2005 23:46:45 -0400, root submitted a Call for Judgement with the statement "e attempted to declare Presence on several Ordinary proposals". CFJ 1539: Called by Murphy (12 Apr); Judged FALSE by G. (18 Apr) On or about Sun, 10 Apr 2005 23:46:45 -0400, root submitted a Call for Judgement. CFJ 1538: Called by G. (07 Apr); Judged TRUE by Riail (17 Apr) A successful play of the Corporate Bankruptcy card causes any shares cards not in the Deck to be discarded. CFJ 1537: Called by root (07 Apr); Judged TRUE by Quazie (11 Apr) Goethe has a Two Shares card. CFJ 1536: Called by Murphy (13 Mar); Judged FALSE by Michael (17 Mar) Murphy is not a Contestant in Pakaran's Contest. CFJ 1535: Called by Sherlock (10 Mar); Judged FALSE by root (18 Mar) Sherlock did not gain 15 Blots on June 15th, 2004. CFJ 1534: Called by Quazie (08 Mar); Judged FALSE by Kolja (24 Mar) Michael Norrish is the Speaker. CFJ 1533: Called by G. (07 Mar); Judged FALSE by Murphy (27 Mar); REMANDED on Appeal (06 Apr); Judged TRUE by Murphy (15 Apr); REMANDED on Appeal (17 Apr); Judged FALSE by Murphy (18 Apr) Rule 1561 cannot prevent an adopted Rule Change from taking effect. CFJ 1532: Called by Quazie (04 Mar); Judged FALSE by Sherlock (11 Mar) Proposals containing rule changes that were submitted after Rule 1561 was created have taken effect. CFJ 1531: Called by root (27 Feb); Judged FALSE by Maud (12 Mar) Proposal 4639 was Aborted. CFJ 1530: Called by G. (16 Feb); Judged TRUE by Manu (22 Feb) Quazie's Hand is Free. CFJ 1529: Called by G. (14 Feb); Judged FALSE by OscarMeyr (26 Feb) Goethe was a Corporate Raider when Proposal 4639's voting period ended. CFJ 1528: Called by G. (14 Feb); Judged FALSE by OscarMeyr (26 Feb) Proposal 4639 was a Takeover Proposal when its voting period ended. CFJ 1527: Called by root (14 Dec); Judged FALSE by OscarMeyr (23 Jan) Goethe has nine Pennies. CFJ 1526: Called by Murphy (20 Nov); Judged TRUE by Riail (13 Dec) No player's Voting Potential has increased due to Proposal 4618 (Battery packs). CFJ 1525: Called by OscarMeyr (15 Nov); Judged FALSE by RedKnight (27 Nov) The Patent Title of Champion defined in R2075 is different from the previous Patent Title of Champion. CFJ 1524: Called by G. (04 Nov); Judged FALSE by Maud (12 Nov) A Corporate Bankruptcy card has been legally dealt to root. CFJ 1523: Called by G. (26 Oct); Judged TRUE by root (10 Nov) If It's A Surprise is played when the hand size is above the maximum, the play wholly fails. CFJ 1522: Called by G. (26 Oct); Judged TRUE by root (10 Nov) A Player may NOT draw two cards without fee by playing It's A Surprise, if eir hand size is above the maximum. CFJ 1521: Called by Murphy (15 Aug); Judged TRUE by Taral (19 Aug) Eris has a beard. CFJ 1520: Called by root (29 Jul); Judged FALSE by G. (20 Aug) Reasonable Doubt achieved a Team Win on Thursday, July 29, 2004. CFJ 1519: Called by root (29 Jul); Judged TRUE by G. (20 Aug) There is a Contest named Claustronomic, and its Contestmaster is root. CFJ 1518: Called by G. (29 Jul); Judged FALSE by Michael (08 Oct) Elysion was awarded 5 points on or about 29-Jul-04. CFJ 1517: Called by G. (29 Jul); Judged TRUE by Michael (08 Oct) Claustronomic is not currently an Agoran Contest. CFJ 1516: Called by G. (06 Jul); Judged FALSE by Elysion (23 Jul) Murphy's honor, immediately before e attempted to increase eir Voting Potential by 41, can not be determined by reasonable effort. CFJ 1515: Called by Murphy (04 Jul); Judged FALSE by Elysion (23 Jul) Murphy's Voting Potential is 1. CFJ 1514: Called by Murphy (04 Jul); Judged FALSE by Elysion (23 Jul) Murphy's Voting Potential is 42. CFJ 1513: Called by G. (25 Jun); Judged TRUE by OscarMeyr (01 Aug) Riall holds a Debate-o-matic card. CFJ 1512: Called by G. (25 Jun); Judged TRUE by OscarMeyr (01 Aug) Proposal 4588 is in its voting period. CFJ 1511: Called by G. (25 Jun); Judged FALSE by OscarMeyr (01 Aug) Proposal 4588 is Democratic. CFJ 1510: Called by root (21 Jun); Judged TRUE by Taral (04 Jul) Riail currently possesses one or more Debate-O-Matic cards. CFJ 1509: Called by root (18 May); Judged FALSE by Murphy (20 Jun) Goethe is the Prime Executor of the Deck with respect to the the requirement to post "Hot Potato" to a public forum as a result of root's play of the Hot Potato card on Sunday, May 16 2004. CFJ 1508: Called by root (18 May); Judged TRUE by Murphy (20 Jun) The Deck is guilty of the class 1 Infraction of Dropping the Potato. CFJ 1507: Called by root (18 May); Judged FALSE by Murphy (20 Jun) Goethe's delegation of the Deckmastor Office to Wes on Tuesday, May 18 2004 extended the deadline of the Deck's requirement to post the phrase "Hot Potato" to "as soon as possible" after the delegation. CFJ 1506: Called by root (18 May); Judged TRUE by Murphy (20 Jun) The Deckmastor is not empowered to post messages on behalf of the Deck. CFJ 1505: Called by root (18 May); Judged TRUE by Murphy (20 Jun) root successfully played the Hot Potato card on Sunday, May 16 2004. CFJ 1504: Called by Murphy (16 May); Dismissed by Maud (28 May) At least one of (Cainech, Oerjan, Pakaran, Steve, t) is a Politician. CFJ 1503: Called by Murphy (16 May); Dismissed by Maud (28 May) At least one of (Kolja, Maud, Sherlock, Sir Toby, Wes) is a Politician. CFJ 1502: Called by Murphy (16 May); Judged FALSE by Maud (28 May) All Players are Politicians. CFJ 1501: Called by Murphy (16 May); Dismissed by Maud (28 May) All Players who are Electee to one or more Offices are Politicians. CFJ 1500: Called by G. (03 May); Judged TRUE by Michael (13 May) Goethe is a Politician. CFJ 1499: Called by G. (20 Apr); Judged FALSE by Kolja (04 Jun); SUSTAINED on Appeal (04 Jul) Rule 2050 has been repealed. CFJ 1498: Called by Wes (12 Apr); Judged FALSE by Sir Toby (21 Apr); SUSTAINED on Appeal (30 Apr) No two Rules may legally have the same Title. CFJ 1497: Called by Maud (08 Apr); Judged TRUE by Murphy (08 Apr); REMANDED on Appeal (05 May); Judged FALSE by Murphy (16 May) If a person who is a player of both Agora and Claustronomic ceases to be a player of Agora, then e also ceases to be a player of Claustronomic. CFJ 1496: Called by Elysion (04 Apr); Judged FALSE by OscarMeyr (11 Apr) CFJ 1495 constitutes a challenge under rule 1941 to Eris's attempt to increase eir Lobbying Strength in eir message dated Thu, 1 Apr 2004 17:23:35 -0600. CFJ 1495: Called by Taral (02 Apr); Judged TRUE by Elysion (04 Apr) Eris successfully increased eir Lobbying Strength by 3 in eir message dated Thu, 1 Apr 2004 17:23:35 -0600. CFJ 1494: Called by Taral (01 Apr); Judged TRUE by root (02 Apr) Eris is Immaculate. CFJ 1493: Called by Kolja (23 Mar); Judged TRUE by RedKnight (06 Apr) The position of Speaker defined in the regulations of the Contest 'Claustronomic' is currently filled by Goethe. CFJ 1492: Called by root (17 Feb); Judged FALSE by Michael (29 Feb); REMANDED on Appeal (14 Mar); Judged TRUE by Michael (19 Mar) Cainech, not root, is the Trial Judge of CFJ 1490. CFJ 1491: Called by Cainech (15 Feb); Judged FALSE by G. (19 Mar) CFJ's 1482 to 1487 are not valid CFJ's, as the text was never submitted to the CotC. CFJ 1490: Called by OscarMeyr (11 Feb); Judged FALSE by Cainech (17 Feb) Cainech's statement of 11 Feb 2004 14:10:04, reading "I lay a COE on OscarMeyer for accepting a COE that was not made in a public forum, thereby contravening R1431. ("A Claim of Error is a public message.....")" is NOT a valid COE. CFJ 1489: Called by Cainech (11 Feb); Judged TRUE by Maud (28 Mar) Watchers are not a rule-defined elemeent of the game. CFJ 1488: Called by Cainech (11 Feb); Judged FALSE by Sherlock (20 Feb) Bringing about a situation other than one explicitily allowed in the rules in which other Players are unable to follow rule n is, in and of itself, breaking rule n. CFJ 1487: Called by Cainech (10 Feb); Dismissed by OscarMeyr (20 Feb) A Watcher is still an active Player. CFJ 1486: Called by Cainech (10 Feb); Dismissed by OscarMeyr (20 Feb) All references in public forum to "Kolja" should refer to the original bearer of that name, Kolja A. This should be applicable retroactively. CFJ 1485: Called by Cainech (10 Feb); Judged FALSE by OscarMeyr (20 Feb) "Kolja" is not entitled to the benefits assosciated with being a completely new player, as the player has been registered under a different name in the past 365 days. CFJ 1484: Called by Cainech (10 Feb); Judged TRUE by OscarMeyr (20 Feb) OscarMeyer issued an invalid order by requesting that "Klaus" be globally changed to "Kolja". CFJ 1483: Called by Cainech (10 Feb); Judged FALSE by OscarMeyr (20 Feb) when referring to Kolja in public forum, it is ambiguous as to whether Klaus or Kolja A is referred to, thereby entailing an infraction of R754. CFJ 1482: Called by Cainech (10 Feb); Dismissed by G. (19 Feb) Kolja and Kolja A are not eligible for any responsibilities as described under R1755 until the following linked CFJ is resoloved. CFJ 1481: Called by G. (30 Jan); Judged TRUE by root (28 Mar) A Player's score is deemed to change at the time a Scorekeepor is notified of a scoring event, not at the time of the scoring event itself. CFJ 1480: Called by G. (05 Jan); Judged FALSE by Murphy (06 Jan) A Speaker Transition did *not* commence on January 1. CFJ 1479: Called by Murphy (17 Oct); Judged TRUE by Taral (17 Oct) A is not B. CFJ 1478: Called by Murphy (17 Oct); Dismissed by root (17 Oct) A is A. CFJ 1477: Called by Murphy (15 Oct); Judged FALSE by Pakaran (26 Oct) Team Dovesdar has achieved a Team Win within the past 24 hours. CFJ 1476: Called by Murphy (15 Oct); Judged TRUE by G. (15 Oct) Oerjan is silent. CFJ 1475: Called by G. (15 Oct); Judged TRUE by Murphy (15 Oct) The above message contains a valid Notice of Award. CFJ 1474: Called by root (07 Oct); Judged TRUE by RedKnight (17 Oct); REMANDED on Appeal (07 Nov); Judged FALSE by RedKnight (15 Nov) A Points Contest named Eris' Contest has awarded a positive number of points to some player during the month of October. CFJ 1473: Called by root (07 Oct); Judged FALSE by RedKnight (17 Oct) There was a Points Contest named Eris' Contest at the beginning of the month of October. CFJ 1472: Called by root (07 Oct); Judged TRUE by RedKnight (17 Oct) There is a Points Contest named Eris' Contest. CFJ 1471: Called by OscarMeyr (05 Oct); Judged TRUE by Steve (06 Oct) The GWotO is allowed to remove from the Oligarchy an Oligarch whose term of service has expired. CFJ 1470: Called by Murphy (05 Oct); Judged TRUE by Taral (15 Oct) If a player attempts to perform multiple fee-based actions by paying a single amount of kudos, but one of the actions fails, then they all fail. CFJ 1469: Called by Murphy (05 Oct); Judged FALSE by Taral (15 Oct) A player may perform multiple fee-based actions by paying a single amount of kudos equal to the total fees for those actions. CFJ 1468: Called by Murphy (05 Oct); Judged FALSE by Taral (15 Oct) A player may perform multiple fee-based actions (e.g. extending eir Oligarchic Term of Service by the Oligarchic Term twice) by announcing the net effect of those actions. CFJ 1467: Called by Murphy (05 Oct); Judged FALSE by Taral (15 Oct) If a player attempts to spend N kudos to pay a fee, but the fee is smaller than N, then N kudos are still paid. CFJ 1466: Called by Murphy (05 Oct); Judged TRUE by Taral (15 Oct) If a player attempts to spend N kudos to pay a fee, but the fee is smaller than N, then the fee-based action succeeds (assuming it is not otherwise prohibited). CFJ 1465: Called by Murphy (05 Oct); Dismissed by Taral (15 Oct) If a player attempts to spend N kudos to pay a fee, but the fee-based action fails (e.g. the fee is larger than N), then the kudos are still spent. CFJ 1464: Called by RedKnight (30 Sep); Judged TRUE by Taral (15 Oct) RedKnight sucessfuly entered the Oligarchy through at least one of the above statements. CFJ 1463: Called by Pakaran (30 Sep); Dismissed by OscarMeyr (10 Oct) Pakaran is presently eligible to judge one or more CFJs. CFJ 1462: Called by root (29 Sep); Judged TRUE by Sir Toby (17 Oct) The Oligarchy Charge Requirement, as defined by the Grand Warden of the Oligarchy's Budget, is 6. CFJ 1461: Called by root (27 May); Judged FALSE by Taral (19 Jul) One or more tax debts of one or more bouncy balls were created as a result of a message sent by root on May 27, 2003. CFJ 1460: Called by G. (04 Apr); Judged FALSE by Maud (01 May) The public message sent by Goethe on April 1st created a requirement for at least one Officer to act as soon as possible [after the message]. CFJ 1459: Called by Peekee (17 Mar); Judged TRUE by OscarMeyr (28 Mar) If a Contest has no Entry Fee or does not specify an Entry Fee, then players are considered to have paid the Entry Fee without having to make a statement specifically to pay the Entry Fee. CFJ 1458: Called by Peekee (17 Mar); Judged TRUE by OscarMeyr (28 Mar) If a Contest has no Entry Fee or does not specify an Entry Fee, then players may join that Contest without paying an Entry Fee. CFJ 1457: Called by Peekee (17 Mar); Judged TRUE by OscarMeyr (28 Mar) Murphy is a member of Scribes' Collegium. CFJ 1456: Called by Peekee (17 Mar); Judged TRUE by OscarMeyr (28 Mar) If a Contest does not specify a quantity of some particular Currency as an Entry Fee, then a player is not required to pay a Fee (as in Rule 1941) to join that Contest. CFJ 1455: Called by Sir Toby (14 Mar); Judged TRUE by Steve (27 Mar) Sir Toby did not join The Evil Scam Contest in a message sent to agora-business on Fri, 14 Mar 2003 08:53:40 -0800, with the following subject: This message brought to you by the letter "a". CFJ 1454: Called by Peekee (10 Mar); Dismissed by Michael (23 Mar) New York is the capital of England CFJ 1453: Called by root (05 Mar); Judged TRUE by Sir Toby (25 Mar); SUSTAINED on Appeal (11 Aug) As a result of the formation of root's Pay Out Scam Contest (rPOSC), the Bank incurred a debt to root consisting of one or more properties. CFJ 1452: Called by Peekee (06 Mar); Judged TRUE by root (18 Mar) Peekee has published a message containing the text "This is a single message", in emails with titles A and B. CFJ 1451: Called by Peekee (06 Mar); Judged TRUE by root (18 Mar) Peekee has published a message containing the text "MessageXX", in emails with titles 1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9. CFJ 1450: Called by Maud (05 Mar); Judged TRUE by Sherlock (12 Mar) A fee may be paid by announcement. CFJ 1449: Called by Cecilius (03 Mar); Judged TRUE by G. (17 Mar); REVERSED on Appeal (28 Mar) The Proposal entitled "Full Discretion Fix" would have been Rubberstamped by the message sent by Cecilius today under the subject line "Rubberstamping, Take Two," if that Proposal had not already been Rubberstamped. CFJ 1448: Called by Cecilius (03 Mar); Judged TRUE by G. (17 Mar); REVERSED on Appeal (28 Mar) The Proposal entitled "Full Discretion Fix" was Rubberstamped by a message sent by Cecilius today under the subject line "Rubberstamping, Take Two". CFJ 1447: Called by Murphy (03 Mar); Judged FALSE by Peekee (29 Apr) The Proposal "Try Again, Part 2 of 3" is distributable. CFJ 1446: Called by Murphy (03 Mar); Judged FALSE by Peekee (29 Apr) The Proposal "Try Again, Part 1 of 3" is distributable. CFJ 1445: Called by Maud (02 Mar); Judged FALSE by Peekee (10 Mar) Cecilius's first attempt on 1 March, 2003 to rubberstamp a proposal failed. CFJ 1444: Called by Maud (02 Mar); Judged FALSE by Peekee (10 Mar) A player cannot perform an action with 0 support. CFJ 1443: Called by Maud (02 Mar); Judged TRUE by Peekee (10 Mar) The rules regulate rubberstamping proposals. CFJ 1442: Called by Maud (02 Mar); Judged TRUE by Peekee (10 Mar) Rubberstamping with 0 support is not a dependent action. CFJ 1441: Called by Peekee (26 Feb); Dismissed by RedKnight (08 Mar) London is the capital of England CFJ 1440: Called by Sherlock (24 Feb); Judged TRUE by Michael (09 Mar) Proposal 4453 had an Adoption Index of 1. CFJ 1439: Called by G. (20 Feb); Judged TRUE by root (11 Mar) Goethe has successfully absolved 1 Blot from emself this Agoran week. CFJ 1438: Called by G. (18 Feb); Judged TRUE by Murphy (15 Apr) The Order issued by Steve, 'I order the Bank to forgive RedKnight's Oligarchy upkeep debt.' (http://www.escribe.com/games/agora-business/m9000.html) is not a properly-issued Order. CFJ 1437: Called by Steve (17 Feb); Judged TRUE by Sherlock (20 Feb) Where the Bank has been properly ordered to forgive a debt denominated in a Bank Currency, only the Treasuror is both permitted and required to act on the Bank's behalf to forgive the debt. CFJ 1436: Called by Steve (11 Feb); Judged TRUE by G. (20 Feb) The Grand Warden of the Oligarchy is not empowered to remove from the Oligarchy a player who is not ineligible to be an Oligarch. CFJ 1435: Called by Murphy (04 Feb); Judged FALSE by Steve (10 Feb) The method used by Goethe in the message with Message-ID <Pine.LNX.4.43.0302031253250.32726@hymn01.u.washington.edu> is reasonably close to the probability distribution required for the action e attempted to perform in that message (i.e. determine the Weather for February 2003). CFJ 1434: Called by Cecilius (24 Jan); Judged TRUE by Pakaran (02 Feb) The registration of a Player and the expiration of eir Grace Period are both "events" for the purposes of Rule 1769 (Holidays). CFJ 1433: Called by Sir Toby (21 Jan); Judged TRUE by OscarMeyr (30 Jan) In a message sent at Fri, 17 Jan 2003 10:05:51 -0800, with message id <Pine.LNX.4.43.0301171005510.14735@hymn05.u.washington.edu>, Goethe tried to resign as Contestmaster of the Support Your Secret Leader Contest, but was prohibited from doing so. CFJ 1432: Called by Sir Toby (21 Jan); Judged TRUE by Murphy (28 Jan) In a message sent at Fri, 17 Jan 2003 10:05:51 -0800, with message id <Pine.LNX.4.43.0301171005510.14735@hymn05.u.washington.edu>, Goethe tried to transfer 2 Stems from Support Your Scret Leader to both Sir Toby and Steve, but the transfers were invalid and did not occur. CFJ 1431: Called by Sir Toby (21 Jan); Judged FALSE by Taral (31 Jan) In a message sent at Fri, 17 Jan 2003 10:05:51 -0800, with message id <Pine.LNX.4.43.0301171005510.14735@hymn05.u.washington.edu>, Goethe tried to transfer 0.05 VEs, 0.1 Indulgences, 0.15 Papyri, and 2 Fish from Support Your Secret Leader to both Sir Toby and Steve, but the transfers were invalid and did not occur. CFJ 1430: Called by G. (14 Jan); Judged FALSE by Steve (16 Jan) Goddess Eris is not Immaculate. CFJ 1429: Called by G. (13 Jan); Judged FALSE by Steve (16 Jan) Goddess Eris has less than zero Blots. CFJ 1428: Called by G. (14 Jan); Judged TRUE by Steve (16 Jan) Goethe succeeded in removing exactly and only 0.68 Blots from Goddess Eris in the same message as this CFJ. CFJ 1427: Called by G. (14 Jan); Judged FALSE by Steve (16 Jan) Goethe succeeded in removing exactly and only 1.00 Blots from Goddess Eris in the same message as this CFJ. CFJ 1426: Called by G. (14 Jan); Judged FALSE by Steve (16 Jan) Absolving (removing) a Blot as per Rule 1986 is not the same as Expunging Blots as per Rule 2017. CFJ 1425: Called by Murphy (09 Jan); Judged TRUE by Sir Toby (16 Jan) Pakaran transferred 10 Stems from the Bank to Murphy in the message with Message-ID <407606326.1041695839@[192.168.1.100]>. CFJ 1424: Called by RedKnight (08 Jan); Judged TRUE by G. (17 Jan) The Goddess Eris has commited the class 2 crime of Disobedience. CFJ 1423: Called by Murphy (04 Jan); Judged FALSE by Taral (06 Jan) Parakan transferred 10 of eir own Stems to Murphy in the message with Message-ID <407606326.1041695839@[192.168.1.100]>. CFJ 1422: Called by Sir Toby (27 Dec); Judged TRUE by Murphy (31 Dec) In a private message (submitted as evidence) sent to Sir Toby on Fri, 20 Dec 2002 11:23:32 +1100 (EST), Steve made a valid bid of 0.25 Indulgences for (+4, 0) in the December Land Auctions initiated in a public message (also submitted as evidence) sent by Sir Toby on Tue, 17 Dec 2002 10:03:39 -0800 (PST). CFJ 1421: Called by Sir Toby (27 Dec); Judged FALSE by Murphy (31 Dec) In a private message (submitted as evidence) sent to Sir Toby on Fri, 20 Dec 2002 11:23:32 +1100 (EST), Steve made a valid bid of 0.25 Indulgences for (+8, +6) in the December Land Auctions initiated in a public message (also submitted as evidence) sent by Sir Toby on Tue, 17 Dec 2002 10:03:39 -0800 (PST). CFJ 1420: Called by Cecilius (17 Dec); Judged FALSE by OscarMeyr (22 Dec) A Claim of Error arising from an error in the list of Watchers contained in the Registrar's Census Report would be invalid. CFJ 1419: Called by Murphy (07 Dec); Judged FALSE by RedKnight (23 Dec); REMANDED on Appeal (31 Dec); Judged TRUE by RedKnight (08 Jan) Steve did not lose, on or about December 6, 2002, eir right to purchase an Indulgence by paying the debt arising from eir bid in the Indulgence Auction initiated on or about November 3, 2002. CFJ 1418: Called by Murphy (26 Oct); Judged TRUE by t (13 Nov) If, after the end of an Election's Nominating Period, the Vote Collector fails to publish a list of Candidates as soon as possible, then the Election has no Winner - even if there was exactly one Candidate at the end of the Nominating Period. CFJ 1417: Called by G. (10 Oct); Judged TRUE by Michael (25 Oct) A Frozen Player who is a Member of a Contest may perform Actions explicitly allowed to Contestants by that Contest's Regulations. CFJ 1416: Called by G. (10 Oct); Judged FALSE by Michael (25 Oct) A Frozen Player may transfer Property. CFJ 1415: Called by G. (10 Oct); Judged FALSE by Michael (25 Oct) A Frozen Player cannot be eir own Prime Executor. CFJ 1414: Called by G. (20 Sep); Judged TRUE by RedKnight (22 Sep); OVERTURNED on Appeal (27 Sep); Judged TRUE by OscarMeyr (04 Oct) Frozen Players may Call CFJs. CFJ 1413: Called by Steve (20 Sep); Judged TRUE by Taral (27 Sep) Rule 1016 prohibits a frozen Player from becoming a Contestant in a Contest. CFJ 1412: Called by Peekee (07 Sep); Judged FALSE by Steve (19 Sep) If a player is deregistered and then registers again without there being a Win since e was deregistered e returns with the same number of points as e had when e was deregistered. CFJ 1411: Called by Steve (23 Aug); Judged TRUE by Murphy (28 Aug) OscarMeyr is Michael's Opposite on RedKnight's Thesis Committee. CFJ 1410: Called by root (12 Aug); Judged FALSE by Steve (19 Aug) The Order executed by RedKnight in the message archived at http://www.escribe.com/games/agora-business/m7451.html was improperly or invalidly executed. CFJ 1409: Called by OscarMeyr (12 Aug); Judged FALSE by Michael (20 Sep) Sir Toby's COE in http://www.escribe.com/games/agora-business/m7478.html was not a valid Claim of Error. CFJ 1408: Called by RedKnight (05 Aug); Judged TRUE by Sir Toby (15 Aug); SUSTAINED on Appeal (05 Sep) Rulekeepor Michael has committed the Class 2 Crime of Unlawful Nondisclosure, as defined by Rule 1064/9. CFJ 1407: Called by RedKnight (15 Jul); Judged TRUE by teucer (17 Jul) The Registrar has not fulfilled eir duty under Rule 478/12 in eir last report. CFJ 1406: Called by teucer (14 Jul); Judged FALSE by Murphy (10 Aug) Pseudorandom numbers do not qualify as Random under the rules of Agora. CFJ 1405: Called by Blaise (09 Jul); Dismissed by Murphy (12 Jul) Four frivolous CFJs has been made by a non-Player. CFJ 1404: Called by Blaise (09 Jul); Dismissed by Sir Toby (11 Jul) Three frivolous CFJs has been made by a non-Player. CFJ 1403: Called by Blaise (09 Jul); Dismissed by Steve (11 Jul) Two frivolous CFJs has been made by a non-Player. CFJ 1402: Called by Blaise (09 Jul); Dismissed by Murphy (12 Jul) One frivolous CFJ has been made by a non-Player. CFJ 1401: Called by Blaise (09 Jul); Dismissed by Steve (11 Jul) No frivolous CFJs have been made by a non-Player. CFJ 1400: Called by Steve (09 Jul); Judged FALSE by root (12 Jul) Only the Treasuror is empowered to forgive debts to the Bank denominated in Bank Currencies. CFJ 1399: Called by G. (01 Jul); Judged TRUE by OscarMeyr (15 Jul) A Provision of an adopted Proposal that does not change the Ruleset may destroy a Stem in any Player's possession by its adoption. CFJ 1398: Called by G. (01 Jul); Judged TRUE by OscarMeyr (15 Jul) A Provision of an adopted Proposal that does not change the Ruleset may create a Stem in any Player's possession by its adoption. CFJ 1397: Called by G. (01 Jul); Judged TRUE by OscarMeyr (15 Jul) A Provision of an adopted Proposal that does not change the Ruleset may change a Player's Vote on a previous Proposal. CFJ 1396: Called by teucer (05 Jul); Judged TRUE by Taral (05 Jul) Craig submitted 5 CFJs on Friday, July 5. CFJ 1395: Called by teucer (05 Jul); Judged FALSE by Sir Toby (08 Jul) This is not a CFJ. CFJ 1394: Called by teucer (05 Jul); Judged FALSE by root (05 Jul); SUSTAINED on Appeal (10 Jul) This CFJ's judge is the Goddess Eris. CFJ 1393: Called by teucer (05 Jul); Judged TRUE by Taral (05 Jul) This CFJ was submitted by Craig. CFJ 1392: Called by teucer (05 Jul); Dismissed by Murphy (08 Jul) This CFJ is TRUE. CFJ 1391: Called by G. (19 Jun); Judged TRUE by Sir Toby (26 Jun); SUSTAINED on Appeal (04 Jul) Only one valid Notice of Infraction may be announced for a single given commission of an Infraction. CFJ 1390: Called by teucer (19 Jun); Judged FALSE by OscarMeyr (20 Jun) If Goethe becomes Lawless and is thus deregistered before Eris actually blesses the proposal, the proposal will not have the needed support to Bless it. CFJ 1389: Called by root (19 Jun); Judged FALSE by Steve (24 Jun) The Bank incurred a debt of 0.1 Papyri to Steve as a result of Opposite Proposal 4332. CFJ 1388: Called by teucer (17 Jun); Judged TRUE by Murphy (21 Jun) Goethe has failed to award three bonuses of one papyrus each to Craig ASAP after the passage of eir proposals "EPIMENIDES", "INSANE STEM DISTRIBUTION", and "SpLittable Boni"; this violates rule 1479. CFJ 1387: Called by teucer (17 Jun); Judged FALSE by Murphy (21 Jun) Goethe has failed to pay three bonuses of 1 papyrus each to Craig for eir passed proposals: "EPIMENIDES", "INSANE STEM DISTRIBUTION", and "SpLittable Boni". This is a violation of rule 1678. CFJ 1386: Called by Taral (12 Jun); Judged TRUE by Sir Toby (19 Jun) The following provision of Proposal 4329 is without effect: "all outstanding potential debts arising from past transfers are deemed, for the purposes of future debts, to have not occurred" CFJ 1385: Called by G. (31 May); Judged TRUE by OscarMeyr (09 Jun) Proposal 4323 contains an Invalid Legislative Order. CFJ 1384: Called by teucer (30 May); Dismissed by G. (16 Jun) Craig's transfer of an instance of a nameless currency to the name 'Beverly' was valid. CFJ 1383: Called by teucer (30 May); Judged FALSE by root (09 Jun) root's transfer of an instance of a nameless currency to nothing was valid. CFJ 1382: Called by teucer (30 May); Judged FALSE by Sir Toby (09 Jun) Steve has committed Misrepresentation. CFJ 1381: Called by G. (28 May); Judged FALSE by root (04 Jun) A Stem Tax Assessed or to be Assessed by the Payroll Clerk within the next 24 hours, was/will be legal. CFJ 1380: Called by teucer (30 May); Judged FALSE by Steve (10 Jun) The player Goethe has committed four counts of the Class Four Crime of Misrepresentation. CFJ 1379: Called by t (28 May); Judged FALSE by OscarMeyr (11 Jun) root committed the Crime of Misrepresentation when e sent a message with the subject 'Transfers' to Crito and t on Mon, 27 May 2002 22:36:41 -0400. CFJ 1378: Called by root (17 May); Judged TRUE by Steve (31 May) The player root won the game on or around May 10, 2002. CFJ 1377: Called by G. (28 May); Judged TRUE by root (04 Jun) The passage of Proposal 4318 created at least one legal VE debt. CFJ 1376: Called by Steve (14 May); Judged FALSE by OscarMeyr (29 May) The Rules do not explicitly permit Players to transfer their own Property. CFJ 1375: Called by teucer (13 May); Judged TRUE by root (31 May) root's transfer of an instance of a nameless currency to France was valid. CFJ 1374: Called by teucer (13 May); Judged TRUE by Crito (22 May) root's creation of a nameless currency was valid. CFJ 1373: Called by teucer (13 May); Judged FALSE by Sir Toby (24 May) Michael's Pot-Plants' transfer of one HereYouGoKezom to the Short Logical Ruleset was valid. CFJ 1372: Called by teucer (13 May); Judged TRUE by Sir Toby (16 May) Craig's transfer of three HereYouGoKezomi to a bond was valid. CFJ 1371: Called by teucer (13 May); Dismissed by t (15 May) Craig's transfer of one HereYouGoKezom to Michael's Pot-Plant was valid. CFJ 1370: Called by Murphy (10 May); Judged FALSE by Taral (22 May) The message <3CD83F68.3070804@syllepsis.org> contains two valid, successful Notices of Transfer. CFJ 1369: Called by teucer (08 May); Judged TRUE by OscarMeyr (15 May) Craig's transfer of two HereYouGoKezomi to the Coca-Cola corporation was valid. CFJ 1368: Called by teucer (08 May); Judged TRUE by G. (14 May) OscarMeyr's transfer of one Vote "Sir Toby" for Speaker-Elect Pamphlet to a piece of land was valid. CFJ 1367: Called by teucer (08 May); Judged TRUE by root (14 May) Craig's transfer of one Vote "Sir Toby" for Speaker-Elect Pamphlet to eir own insane proposal was valid. CFJ 1366: Called by teucer (08 May); Judged TRUE by Steve (14 May) Syllepsis' transfer of one Vote "Sir Toby" for Speaker-Elect Pamphlet to a Vote "Sir Toby" for Speaker-Elect Pamphlet was valid. CFJ 1365: Called by teucer (08 May); Judged TRUE by Crito (14 May) root's transfer of one Vote "Sir Toby" for Speaker-Elect Pamphlet to Rule 1467 was valid. CFJ 1364: Called by Syllepsis (08 May); Judged FALSE by Murphy (10 May); OVERTURNED on Appeal (28 May); Judged FALSE by G. (31 May) Once any Bond of a given species becomes redeemed, all Bonds of that species become redeemed. CFJ 1363: Called by Sir Toby (08 May); Judged FALSE by OscarMeyr (16 May) Rule 1969 does not prohibit redeeming Bonds that have already been redeemed. CFJ 1362: Called by Syllepsis (08 May); Judged FALSE by G. (14 May) In the context of the rules, fungible means indistinguishable by any value other than ownership. CFJ 1361: Called by G. (07 May); Judged FALSE by Steve (13 May) ALL of the following are True: (1) On or about May 7 2002, Goethe transferred 0.010 VEs to root. (2) On or about May 7 2002, Goethe transferred 0.010 VEs to Beverly. (3) The Registrar is required to track the nickname Beverly for the Player also known as root. CFJ 1360: Called by teucer (05 May); Judged TRUE by t (15 May) Murphy should not be penalized for eir recent failure to judge CFJ 1348. CFJ 1359: Called by Sir Toby (04 May); Judged TRUE by root (12 May) The proposal submitted in the message with Message ID: <200205010219.g412Jw062775@ke.earlham.edu> is insane. CFJ 1358: Called by root (29 Apr); Judged FALSE by G. (09 May) Proposal 4253 was not adopted. CFJ 1357: Called by Maud (29 Apr); Judged TRUE by Sir Toby (06 May); SUSTAINED on Appeal (16 May) If rule 1467 were repealed, currencies would still be properties. CFJ 1356: Called by root (28 Apr); Judged TRUE by Crito (09 May) The proposal titled "A MODEST PROPOSAL" has no obvious and direct attempt to coerce a Player into voting against eir conscience. CFJ 1355: Called by Maud (28 Apr); Judged TRUE by Crito (13 May) Calls for Judgement (CFJs) can have titles. CFJ 1354: Called by teucer (26 Apr); Judged FALSE by root (06 May) Insane proposals, if adopted, have no effect. CFJ 1353: Called by Murphy (26 Apr); Judged FALSE by t (04 May) Craig has more than 200 Stems. CFJ 1352: Called by Sir Toby (21 Apr); Judged TRUE by Steve (02 May) The last paragraph of rule 1969 does not prohibit transferring Bonds that have already been redeemed. CFJ 1351: Called by Sir Toby (19 Apr); Judged FALSE by Syllepsis (02 May) Proposal 4285 is insane. CFJ 1350: Called by Maud (18 Apr); Judged TRUE by Sir Toby (26 Apr) Sir Toby's first insane proposal submitted on 18 April 2002 is a null proposal. CFJ 1349: Called by Syllepsis (18 Apr); Dismissed by Taral (02 May) The Judgement of CFJ 21 was incorrect. CFJ 1348: Called by root (17 Apr); Judged TRUE by Sir Toby (14 May) No Justices have been appointed in Appeal 1346a. CFJ 1347: Called by root (17 Apr); Judged TRUE by t (26 Apr) Murphy is not a Justice in Appeal 1346a. CFJ 1346: Called by G. (10 Apr); Judged TRUE by root (12 Apr); REVERSED on Appeal (28 May) The Bank is deemed to have incurred a debt of 3.0 Voting Entitlements to: (a) any and every judge who returns a judgment of TRUE on this CFJ, and; (b) any and every member of a Board of Appeals who Overturns a judgment of FALSE on this CFJ or sustains a judgment of TRUE on this CFJ. CFJ 1345: Called by Murphy (15 Mar); Judged FALSE by G. (22 Mar) The ratification of the Payroll Clerk's Report of Tue 29 Jan 2002 caused at least one debt of a Judicial Salary to change from outstanding to not outstanding. CFJ 1344: Called by root (11 Feb); Judged FALSE by Steve (14 Feb) Proposal 4243 was adopted. CFJ 1343: Called by G. (01 Feb); Judged TRUE by Crito (13 Feb) The Payroll Clerk may pay out 50 Stems to Neil for Neil's holding of the Promoter Office in January 2002. CFJ 1342: Called by Murphy (22 Jan); Judged TRUE by Steve (24 Jan) If an Election ends in the middle of its Voting Period because there remains only a single Candidate, then the winner may be Awarded Points for winning a contested Election. CFJ 1341: Called by Murphy (11 Jan); Judged FALSE by G. (06 Feb) neil committed the Crime of Misrepresentation in the message with Message-ID <15422.32050.200019.402505@tarski.2y.net>. CFJ 1340: Called by neil (10 Jan); Judged TRUE by Crito (01 Feb) At the time of the Speaker Transition occurring at 01:27:48 on 10 January 2002, neil was Electee to the Office of Speaker-Elect. CFJ 1339: Called by neil (10 Jan); Judged FALSE by root (06 Feb) At the time of the Speaker Transition occurring at 01:27:48 on 10 January 2002, neil held the Office of Speaker-Elect. CFJ 1338: Called by G. (04 Jan); Judged TRUE by Murphy (13 Jan) Two Speaker Transitions have commenced since 18-Nov-01, and neither have concluded. CFJ 1337: Called by root (23 Dec); Judged TRUE by Steve (08 Jan) hooloovoo transferred 1.81 Indulgences and 3.15 Papyri to AgorEx Offshore just before eir most recent Deregistration. CFJ 1336: Called by Murphy (13 Dec); Judged TRUE by Crito (03 Jan) Murphy declined the Office of Speaker-Elect in the message http://www.escribe.com/games/agora-business/m5768.html CFJ 1335: Called by Crito (12 Dec); Judged TRUE by G. (04 Jan) The Notice of Speaker Transition issued Sat, 8 Dec 2001 was incorrect in its particulars. CFJ 1334: Called by root (11 Dec); Judged FALSE by Steve (21 Dec) Ten Land Auctions began on December 11, 2001 using VEs as the Auction Currencies. CFJ 1333: Called by root (11 Dec); Judged FALSE by Murphy (23 Dec) hooloovoo transferred 0.7 VEs, 1.81 Indulgences, and 3.15 Papyri to AgorEx Offshore just before eir most recent Deregistration. CFJ 1332: Called by neil (08 Dec); Judged FALSE by Crito (12 Dec); REVERSED on Appeal (15 Jan) Immediately after neil became Electee to the Office of Speaker-Elect (at approximately 00:23:21 on 21 Nov 2001 GMT), Steve held the Office of Speaker-Elect. CFJ 1331: Called by neil (04 Dec); Judged TRUE by root (04 Jan) Steve is the Holder of the Office of Speaker-Elect. CFJ 1330: Called by neil (21 Nov); Judged TRUE by root (01 Dec) neil is Electee to the Office of Speaker-Elect. CFJ 1329: Called by neil (21 Nov); Dismissed by G. (28 Nov) neil is Speaker-Elect. CFJ 1328: Called by G. (16 Nov); Dismissed by Syllepsis (20 Nov); OVERTURNED on Appeal (23 Nov); Judged TRUE by Steve (03 Dec) The AgoraEx exists in the eyes of the Rules. CFJ 1327: Called by G. (15 Nov); Judged FALSE by Crito (21 Nov) A looting auction for Peekee began on or about Sun 14 Oct 2001. CFJ 1326: Called by neil (12 Nov); Judged TRUE by Murphy (15 Nov) On or around 19:40:00 12 Nov 2001, neil successfully Nominated for the Office of Speaker-Elect. CFJ 1325: Called by Taral (12 Nov); Judged TRUE by G. (13 Nov) The listed Trading Accounts on the AgorEx web page are sufficient evidence of an Agreement between each listed Player and Lindrum in which the Player may demand that Lindrum pay em the specified amounts at any time. CFJ 1324: Called by Crito (06 Nov); Judged FALSE by root (17 Nov) Steve is NOT the Limited Executor for either Peekee or Ian. CFJ 1323: Called by Maud (30 Sep); Judged FALSE by G. (16 Oct) If each of two entities owes the other some amount of the same fungible property, then by agreement of the Prime Executors for the two entities and without either entity forgiving the other's debt: (a) if the debts are of equal amounts, both may be satisfied; and (b) if the amount of one debt is less than that of the other, then the amount of the latter debt may be reduced by that of the former, and the former debt may be satisfied. CFJ 1322: Called by G. (19 Sep); Judged FALSE by Oerjan (20 Sep) The Player, former Player, or Dissolute Blob has at least one Blot. CFJ 1321: Called by neil (12 Sep); Judged TRUE by Peekee (15 Sep); SUSTAINED on Appeal (26 Sep) There do not exist any Bonds issued by David. CFJ 1320: Called by neil (12 Sep); Judged FALSE by Crito (17 Sep) There do not exist any Bonds issued by Steve's Bond Scam Contest. CFJ 1319: Called by neil (12 Sep); Judged TRUE by Lindrum (19 Sep) There exist no entity known as Steve's Bond Scam Contest. CFJ 1318: Called by Murphy (12 Sep); Judged TRUE by solublefish (18 Sep) Rule 1470 explicitly permits all transfers of Property from the Bank, and therefore no transfer of Property from the Bank is unauthorized for the purpose of Rule 1981. CFJ 1317: Called by root (16 Aug); Judged FALSE by Syllepsis (24 Aug) A Zombie cannot own another Zombie. CFJ 1316: Called by neil (16 Aug); Judged TRUE by root (22 Aug); REVERSED on Appeal (11 Sep) Zombies may not be Players. CFJ 1315: Called by neil (16 Aug); Judged TRUE by Elysion (19 Aug) In publishing with the Voting Report for Proposals 4184-4194 incorrect text for Proposal 4190, Blob committed the Class 4 Crime of Misrepresentation. CFJ 1314: Called by Peekee (15 Aug); Judged TRUE by pTang (20 Aug) Peekee is an Active Player CFJ 1313: Called by G. (14 Aug); Judged TRUE by Murphy (18 Aug) If a Zombie Master emself becomes a Zombie, e loses Power of Attorney over eir own Zombie. CFJ 1312: Called by G. (06 Aug); Judged FALSE by root (12 Aug) The final auction price in the most recent Indulgence Auction was 50 Stems. CFJ 1311: Called by G. (18 Jul); Judged FALSE by Steve (19 Jul) No Proposals have passed during the current Nomic Week. CFJ 1310: Called by Syllepsis (10 Jul); Judged TRUE by solublefish (25 Jul) Proposal 4168 caused Ian, root, and solublefish to owe the Bank 120 Stems CFJ 1309: Called by Maud (15 Jul); Judged TRUE by Syllepsis (21 Jul) If the Vizier of a Group casts on behalf of the Group one or more votes on an Insane Proposal in a Public Forum, e has not thereby bended or violated Rule 1729. CFJ 1308: Called by Murphy (11 Jul); Judged FALSE by Lindrum (08 Aug) If a non-Player entity may Vote on an Insane Proposal, then it may do so in public. CFJ 1307: Called by Kelly (10 Jul); Judged TRUE by Elysion (08 Aug) Annabel's message, on or about 31 May 2001, reading in part "So I transfer all of my currencies to the Bank, and then deregister" did not have the effect of transferring any Currencies. CFJ 1306: Called by Murphy (05 Jul); Judged TRUE by Oerjan (09 Jul) The Basic Officer Salary is 50 Stems CFJ 1305: Called by G. (03 Jul); Judged TRUE by pTang (05 Jul) A Player, while on Hold, may not be made silent by Rule 1042 until two months after going on Hold. CFJ 1304: Called by Murphy (26 Jun); Judged FALSE by Taral (08 Jul) If the Executor of an entity posts to the Public Forum - clearly stating that e posts to the Public Forum on behalf of the entity, as if e were the entity - then the entity is considered to have posted to the Public Forum. CFJ 1303: Called by G. (25 Jun); Judged FALSE by Blob (01 Jul) Razl is Noisy. CFJ 1302: Called by Kelly (18 Jun); Judged TRUE by Hooloovoo (26 Jun) In eir message on or about 11 Jun 2001 14:57:38 -0400, player solublefish did not transfer 120 Stems to the Bank. CFJ 1301: Called by root (07 Jun); Judged TRUE by Syllepsis (13 Jun) Rule 1479 should be interpreted such that an Order, which requires a Player to pay out one or more Properties to some entity, and which is valid and proper under the Rules, causes the Bank to incur one or more debts to the named entity. CFJ 1300: Called by G. (04 Jun); Judged TRUE by Hooloovoo (10 Jun) A Limited Executor of the Bank may be issued a valid and proper Private Order to satisfy the Bank's debt for a property e has the authority to transfer from the Bank. CFJ 1299: Called by G. (31 May); Judged FALSE by root (05 Jun) The Bank has incurred an infinite number of debts to Goethe for each Bank Currency, and each of these debts is a debt for a minimum of 1 MUQ of one of the Bank Currencies. CFJ 1298: Called by G. (31 May); Judged FALSE by Razl (12 Jun) 'Distributor' is a Patent Title which may be changed at the opinion of the Registrar. CFJ 1297: Called by lee (23 May); Judged TRUE by Crito (29 May); REVERSED on Appeal (09 Jun) lee cast 5 votes against proposal 4158. CFJ 1296: Called by Blob (15 May); Dismissed by Wes (25 May) In eir judgement of CFJ 1293, Peekee violated Rule 217. CFJ 1295: Called by Razl (09 May); Judged TRUE by Evantine (17 May); OVERTURNED on Appeal (23 May); Judged FALSE by Lindrum (30 May); OVERTURNED on Appeal (12 Jun); Judged TRUE by solublefish (18 Jun) The Orders issued by Blob in <20010508144200.E5865@cse.unsw.edu.au> http://www.escribe.com/games/agora-business/m3682.html are improperly or invalidly executed. CFJ 1294: Called by Razl (08 May); Dismissed by Taral (18 May) The Administrative Orders issued by the Executor of the Bank in <20010508144200.E5865@cse.unsw.edu.au> http://www.escribe.com/games/agora-business/m3682.html are improperly or invalidly executed. CFJ 1293: Called by Razl (08 May); Judged TRUE by Peekee (14 May) Kelly's Order to Razl <15095.12486.922540.638717@ozma.pyrzqxgl.org> was improperly or invalidly executed. CFJ 1292: Called by Kelly (04 May); Judged FALSE by Oerjan (10 May) Kelly cast a nonzero number of Votes on Proposal 4139. CFJ 1291: Called by G. (04 May); Judged FALSE by lee (11 May) The Clerk of the Courts, Wes, has broken Rule 991, "Invoking Judgement". CFJ 1290: Called by G. (27 Apr); Judged TRUE by solublefish (10 May) Goethe is a Contestant in the Agora the Beautiful Contest. CFJ 1289: Called by Razl (18 Apr); Judged FALSE by G. (28 Apr) The ACO submitted by Tim to create the contest "Agora the Beautiful" is invalid. CFJ 1288: Called by Hooloovoo (04 Apr); Judged FALSE by Steve (13 Apr) The Bank transfered 100 stems to me on April 3, 2001. CFJ 1287: Called by Peekee (30 Mar); Judged TRUE by Tim (06 Apr) The message (as quoted above) Goethe sent titled "Contest announcement: Bardic Gatherings" failed to create a Contest. CFJ 1286: Called by Syllepsis (27 Mar); Judged FALSE by Elysion (03 Apr) The Herald is required to bill Syllepsis the Zombie Transfer Tax of 0.1 Indulgences for transfering 1 Zombie to the Bank CFJ 1285: Called by G. (20 Mar); Judged FALSE by Kelly (22 Mar) Between the time of the creation of the "Enrich the Contestmaster" Contest and this CFJ, Syllepsis, Ziggy, and Steve each successfully lowered the number of Stems they possess by 50, thus paying the Entry Fee for the Contest and successfully increasing the number of Stems possessed by the "Enrich the Contestmaster" Contest (in the Contest Fund) by 150 (total). CFJ 1284: Called by Hooloovoo (07 Mar); Judged FALSE by Evantine (10 Mar) On or about Tue, Tue, 6 Mar 2001 13:18:41 -0600,Kelly violated Rule 1729. CFJ 1283: Called by Kelly (07 Mar); Judged FALSE by Murphy (18 Mar) On or about Tue, 06 Mar 2001 16:04:06 -0800, Hoovooloo violated Rule 1729. CFJ 1282: Called by Syllepsis (06 Mar); Judged FALSE by Stuart (15 Mar) Maximum Voting Power, as referenced in Rule 1953, is a different quantity from an Entity's maximum Voting Power, as referenced in Rule 1950. CFJ 1281: Called by Kelly (06 Mar); Judged TRUE by Hooloovoo (15 Mar) The Voting Power of Player Kelly on Proposal 4120 is two. CFJ 1280: Called by Taral (28 Feb); Dismissed by Oerjan (08 Mar) The Private, Binding Agreement knows as the Articles of Confederation of the United Nomic Dead Groups affects the Votes of the Anemocrats. CFJ 1279: Called by Murphy (21 Feb); Judged FALSE by pTang (03 Mar); OVERTURNED on Appeal (05 May); Judged TRUE by Ziggy (11 May) Proposal 4112 is Democratic. CFJ 1278: Called by Murphy (21 Feb); Judged TRUE by Syllepsis (28 Feb); Judged TRUE by root (17 Oct) The Assessor has announced the results of the voting on Proposal 4111. CFJ 1277: Called by Ziggy (25 Feb); Judged TRUE by pTang (18 Mar) Lindrum's message <http://www.escribe.com/games/agora-business/m2571.html> was sent after the end of the Oligarch Auction announced in Murphy's message <http://www.escribe.com/games/agora-business/m2530.html>. CFJ 1276: Called by G. (19 Feb); Judged FALSE by Lindrum (04 Mar) An entity is a Player if, and only if, the Rules cannot distinguish that entity from a Player. CFJ 1275: Called by G. (19 Feb); Judged TRUE by Murphy (28 Feb) An entity is a Player if the Rules cannot distinguish that entity from a Player. CFJ 1274: Called by Oerjan (15 Feb); Judged TRUE by Evantine (22 Feb) t's Order of Wed, 14 Feb 2001, "I order everyone to make fewer bids in the next auction." was improperly or invalidly executed. CFJ 1273: Called by Wes (13 Feb); Judged TRUE by G. (14 Feb) An Appeal has been initiated with regards to CFJ 1266. CFJ 1272: Called by Evantine (12 Feb); Judged TRUE by Chuck (19 Feb) All Players always have at least one inherent right, regardless of any rule (for purposes of this statement, inherent right means a right that players have even when or if the rules do not explicitly grant them that right). CFJ 1271: Called by Syllepsis (09 Feb); Judged FALSE by Wes (12 Feb) There is no ordering to the statements 'I become a scribe.' and 'I become a politician.' in first message in which Syllepsis so stated them. CFJ 1270: Called by Syllepsis (08 Feb); Judged FALSE by Ziggy (10 Feb); CASE OPEN There is no ordering to the statements 'I become a scribe.' and 'I become a politician.' in first message in which Syllepsis so stated them. CFJ 1269: Called by Syllepsis (06 Feb); Judged FALSE by Elysion (11 Feb) There is no ordering to the statements 'I become a scribe.' and 'I become a politician.' in first message in which Syllepsis so stated them. CFJ 1268: Called by Wes (07 Feb); Judged TRUE by lee (07 Feb); OVERTURNED on Appeal (17 Feb); Judged TRUE by Razl (09 Mar); SUSTAINED on Appeal (10 Apr) Peekee has committed the Crime of Application Fraud as described in Rule 1626 by claiming that eir Application (included in Evidence below) was signed by Players who did not actually sign that Application. CFJ 1267: Called by Grech (06 Feb); Judged TRUE by Blob (09 Feb); SUSTAINED on Appeal (04 Mar) Syllepsis is a Scribe. CFJ 1266: Called by G. (06 Feb); Dismissed by Crito (07 Feb); SUSTAINED on Appeal (17 Feb) 1. That of the following two messages, http://www.escribe.com/games/agora-business/m2253.html and http://www.escribe.com/games/agora-business/m2255.html exactly ONE legally registered Goethe as a player in the game of Agora. The other one is either incorrect or superfluous. 2. That at a time 1 minute immediately BEFORE the SEND date listed in Goethe's e-mail header for m2253, normalized to GMT as Feb 5 0:22:49 (anecdotal evidence available on request), Goethe unambiguously was NOT a player. 3. That at a time 1 minute immediately AFTER the latest distribution date of m2255 listed in e-scribe, normalized to GMT as Feb 5 as 1:19:24, Goethe unambiguously WAS a player. 4. That, from these time indications, rounding to the minute, Goethe's Window of Ambiguity of Status as Player (GWASP) extends ABSOLUTELY NO LONGER than between GMT 0:21:00 and GMT 1:21:00 on Feb 5, 2001. 5. That Goethe's instant of becoming a player lies unambiguously within es GWASP. 5. While judgements on timestamps or the legality of the first message (c.f. http://www.escribe.com/games/agora-official/m967.html) may narrow the extent of this GWASP, no judgement may extend it. 6. Therefore, irrespective of the EXACT moment of Goethe's registration, and independent of any decisions further refining the exact moment, any game events, payments or adjustments, mandated by the rules to occur to Goethe's status, which must happen WITHIN a time period following registration, must use a registration date for Goethe NO LATER THAN 1:21:00 Feb. 5, 2001 in determining time of occurrence. 7. Likewise, any game events, payments, or adjustments mandated by the rules to occur a certain time AFTER Goethe's registration must use a registration date for Goethe NO EARLIER THAN 0:21:00 Feb. 5, 2001 in determining its time of occurrence. CFJ 1265: Called by Wes (05 Feb); Dismissed by Kelly (11 Feb) The Justiciar is required by the Rules to act in some way in response to the Call for Judgement earlier in this email. CFJ 1264: Called by Wes (05 Feb); Judged FALSE by loh (05 Feb) Clerk of the Courts Wes has failed to perform eir duty to distribute CFJ 1263 in a timely manner. CFJ 1263: Called by Blob (05 Feb); Judged FALSE by Steve (09 Feb) Goethe is not a Player. CFJ 1262: Called by Wes (29 Jan); Judged TRUE by Peekee (06 Feb) Chuck was a Justice for CFJ 1254 on Jan 24 at the time that e posted eir decision to OVERTURN and Dismiss. CFJ 1261: Called by Elysion (23 Jan); Judged FALSE by Maud (30 Jan) Proposal 4104 passed. CFJ 1260: Called by Elysion (22 Jan); Judged TRUE by Steve (29 Jan) Elysion committed the Crime of Misrepresentation in eir message dated Mon, 08 Jan 2001 14:54:47 -0500. CFJ 1259: Called by Peekee (18 Jan); Dismissed by Murphy (28 Jan) If this statement is true, Peekee is owed 100 Stems CFJ 1258: Called by Murphy (18 Dec); Judged TRUE by lee (14 Jan); OVERTURNED on Appeal (22 Jan); Judged TRUE by loh (01 Feb) Peekee is the Notary. CFJ 1257: Called by Murphy (18 Dec); Judged TRUE by Kelly (13 Jan) Peekee is an Oligarch. CFJ 1256: Called by Murphy (18 Dec); Judged TRUE by Wes (20 Dec) Peekee submitted at least one CFJ to the Clerk of the Courts during November 2000; the Clerk of the Courts has not assigned a Judge to any such CFJ; and Kelly is not the Clerk of the Courts. CFJ 1255: Called by Oerjan (08 Dec); Judged FALSE by Elysion (13 Jan) Rule 1586 should be interpreted such that the Rule created by Proposal 4090 (Debt Conversion) has no effect, since any outstanding debts and liabilities in Basic Currencies were canceled when Basic Currencies were abolished from the Rules. CFJ 1254: Called by Murphy (20 Nov); Judged TRUE by pTang (15 Jan); OVERTURNED on Appeal (24 Jan); Judged FALSE by Ziggy (01 Feb) Peekee possesses at least one Voting Token. CFJ 1253: Called by Andre (16 Nov); Judged FALSE by Crito (12 Jan) Novalis and Harlequin are not Zombies. CFJ 1252: Called by Peekee (07 Nov); Judged FALSE by Chuck (13 Jan) Peekee has a Will. CFJ 1251: Called by Elysion (15 Dec); Dismissed by Blob (18 Dec) Kelly has failed to select a Judge for the CFJ called by Peekee on November 11, and Kelly is not the CotC. CFJ 1250: Called by Chuck (02 Oct); Judged TRUE by Crito (10 Oct) Rule 1664 should be interpreted that the effects which are applied specifically to Abiding Players or specifically to Rebellious Players upon the success or failure of a Call for Revolt, are applied based on a Player's status as Abiding or Rebellious at the time the Registrar determines whether the Call for Revolt was successful or not, and not at the time the Call for Revolt is made. CFJ 1249: Called by Chuck (02 Oct); Judged TRUE by Peekee (09 Oct) The paragraph of Rule 1664 which reads 'The Registar shall select a random integer from 1 to the number of Players (plus 1 if Miscreant is held) at the time of the Call for Revolt. If this number is less than or equal to the number of Rebellious Players (plus 1 if Miscreant is held by a Rebellious Player), then the Revolt succeeds; otherwise it fails.' should be interpreted such that, while the total number of Players is determined as of the time of the Call for Revolt, the number of Rebellious Players is determined as of the time the Registrar selects a random integer as described. CFJ 1248: Called by pTang (28 Sep); Judged TRUE by Murphy (15 Oct) Rule 1941 shall be interpreted as outlined in pTang's judgement on CFJ 1246. CFJ 1247: Called by Taral (20 Sep); Judged TRUE by Crito (10 Oct) t's Order dated Wed, 20 Sep 2000 22:50:26 +0300 was improperly executed. CFJ 1246: Called by Peekee (19 Sep); Judged FALSE by pTang (28 Sep) Peekee has paid a Fee of 10 Stems since the 15th of September this year. CFJ 1245: Called by Taral (24 Aug); Judged FALSE by Chuck (02 Sep) The Speaker has failed to initiate an Election for the Office of Grand Warden of the Oligarchy as required by the Rules. CFJ 1244: Called by Peekee (23 Aug); Judged FALSE by Blob (27 Aug) A given Rule's title is a substantive property of that Rule, and so may be changed as a Rule Change. CFJ 1243: Called by Steve (22 Aug); Judged TRUE by Wes (25 Aug); REVERSED on Appeal (08 Oct) Chuck is ineligible to serve as a Justice in the Appeal of CFJ 1237. CFJ 1242: Called by Palnatoke (22 Aug); Judged FALSE by Andre (23 Aug) Palnatoke is Off Hold. CFJ 1241: Called by Taral (07 Aug); Judged FALSE by Peekee (11 Aug) Chuck has committed the Class 4 Crime of Contempt by Inaction by failing to abide by the Order issued by the Judge of CFJ 1237. CFJ 1240: Called by Kelly (08 Aug); Judged FALSE by t (14 Aug); OVERTURNED on Appeal (31 Aug); Judged TRUE by Andre (07 Sep) Kelly is not the Judge of CFJ 1234. CFJ 1239: Called by Peekee (01 Aug); Judged TRUE by Steve (02 Aug) Taral objected to both the making of the Proposal "Secret, Unknown and Hidden Proposals 2.1" disinterested and objected to the making of the Proposal "Respect for the dead" disinterested in eir message dated "Mon, 31 Jul 2000 11:33:18 -0500 (CDT)", subject "Re: BUS: disinterested". CFJ 1238: Called by Murphy (31 Jul); Dismissed by Blob (02 Aug) Rule 1930 "Scoring" is the only Rule allowing a Point Award or Penalty for any particular type of event, and has been the only such Rule since it and Rule 1929 "Points" were enacted. Therefore, any notification of the occurrence of such an event implicitly specifies Rule 1930 as the Rule allowing the Award or Penalty. CFJ 1237: Called by Taral (26 Jul); Judged FALSE by Oerjan (27 Jul); OVERTURNED on Appeal (02 Sep); Judged TRUE by Elysion (09 Sep) The Order issued by Chuck on Sun, 23 Jul 2000 17:17:02 -0500 was valid. CFJ 1236: Called by Peekee (21 Jul); Judged FALSE by Murphy (31 Jul) Zombies are not rewarded Indulgences for being Immaculate all Quarter. CFJ 1235: Called by Oerjan (20 Jul); Judged TRUE by lee (25 Jul) Peekee has not been awarded the Patent Title of Quack. CFJ 1234: Called by Murphy (20 Jul); Judged TRUE by Kelly (27 Jul); SUSTAINED on Appeal (03 Aug); CASE OPEN Kudos are Property. CFJ 1233: Called by Steve (03 Jul); Judged FALSE by Elysion (11 Jul) Rule 1927 should be interpreted as requiring the Executor of the Bank to announce eir intent to mint Bank Currencies between seven and fourteen days prior to actually minting them. CFJ 1232: Called by Taral (22 Jun); Judged FALSE by lee (23 Jun) Taral currently has at least 3 Blots. CFJ 1231: Called by Steve (20 Jun); Judged TRUE by Peekee (21 Jun) t, acting as Executor of the Zombie Novalis, caused Novalis to cast four votes AGAINST Proposal 4018. CFJ 1230: Called by Taral (18 Jun); Judged TRUE by Maud (22 Jun) Taral has not committed any acts of Promotor Misrepresentation. CFJ 1229: Called by Taral (14 Jun); Judged FALSE by Elysion (17 Jun); OVERTURNED on Appeal (29 Jun); Judged FALSE by Chuck (07 Jul) Taral distributed at least one Proposal during the Nomic Week beginning May 29, 2000. CFJ 1228: Called by Murphy (03 Jun); Judged TRUE by t (10 Jun) The Treasuror's Salary is 0.2 times the Basic Officer's Salary. CFJ 1227: Called by Kelly (29 May); Judged TRUE by Murphy (03 Jun) A Low Oligarch who is entitled to cast any vote at all upon a given Ordinary Proposal may cast a vote of ABSTAIN upon that Proposal. CFJ 1226: Called by Peekee (29 May); Judged FALSE by Kelly (05 Jun) The Transfer Orders which Peekee issued in the email identified by Message-ID: <20000524113533.52162.qmail@hotmail.com> satisfied the Stem Payment Orders as mentioned in the same email. CFJ 1225: Called by Wes (28 May); Judged TRUE by Palnatoke (30 May) The Transfer Orders which Peekee issued in the email identified by Message-ID: <20000524113533.52162.qmail@hotmail.com> were improperly or invalidly executed. CFJ 1125: Called by Blob (25 Apr); Judged TRUE by Crito (01 May) Rule 1883 has not been repealed. CFJ 866: Called by Morendil (08 Apr); Judged TRUE by Oerjan (09 Apr) Player Jtael has cast legal Votes on Proposals 2555 through 2564. CFJ 858: Called by Zefram (15 Feb); Judged TRUE by Coren (05 Mar); REVERSED on Appeal (08 Mar) Rule 1482 should be interpreted such that the meaning of a word used in a Rule is a part of the Rule's meaning, and therefore cannot be changed significantly by Rules of lower precedence. CFJ 818: Called by Swann (31 Oct); Judged TRUE by KoJen (02 Nov); SUSTAINED on Appeal (10 Nov) The Rules in general should be interpreted that, if the alleged Compact of the Mousetrap Organization exists, it cannot contain the Player Swann within its Jurisdiction. CFJ 707: Called by Steve (13 Oct); Judged FALSE by Vanyel (14 Oct) Steve legally voted FOR (and did not legally vote AGAINST) Proposal 1177. Hence, the votes on that Proposal were not 11 FOR, 13 AGAINST as reported by the Speaker, but in fact were tied 12 FOR, 12 AGAINST. CFJ 1224: Called by Kelly (26 May 2000); Sherlock defaulted (8 Jun); reassigned to Chuck (9 Jun); Judged TRUE by Chuck (15 Jun); OVERTURNED to FALSE on Appeal (23 Jun) Elysions's message of 11 April 2000, reading in part, 'The Bank pays all its outstanding IAT POs (50 to Michael and 75 to Chuck)', did not have the effect of executing a Transfer Order which would satisfy the Payment Order executed by lee in eir message dated 11 March 2000, reading in part, 'I order the Bank to pay Murphy 130 IATs.' CFJ 1223: Called by lee (25 May 2000); Judged TRUE by Peekee (2 Jun) lee started eir current occupation of the Office of Notary prior to midnight GMT on May 23, 2000. CFJ 1222: Called by Kelly (24 May 2000); Judged FALSE by Crito (31 May) The message sent to the Business List by Elysion containing the text 'The Bank pays all its outstanding IAT POs' did not cause any Transfer Orders to be exectuted. CFJ 1221: Called by Peekee (24 May 2000); Judged FALSE by Wes (28 May) There are no Payments Orders in Stems naming Peekee as the Payor[.] CFJ 1220: Called by Palnatoke (22 May 2000); Judged FALSE by Maud (22 May) Blob is currently eligible to Judge CFJs concerning conditional statements. CFJ 1219: Called by Wes (22 May 2000); Judged FALSE by Steve (23 May); SUSTAINED on Appeal (11 Jun) CFJ 1217 was not Dismissed. CFJ 1218: Called by Palnatoke (18 May 2000); Judged FALSE by t (25 May) The insertion of a blank line in a Rule is a Rule change[.] CFJ 1217: Called by t (18 May 2000); DISMISSED by Kelly (22 May) TYHJA: is not an obvious synonym of one of FOR, AGAINST or ABSTAIN, as specified in Rule 683, and therefore is not a vote upon a Proposal. CFJ 1216: Called by Eris (16 May 2000); Judged FALSE by Murphy (18 May) A Player who holds a wage-earning Office at the time Salaries are paid out is paid the Salary for that Office, regardless of the amount of time e has held that Office. CFJ 1215: Called by Wes (14 May 2000); assigned to lee (15 May); Judged FALSE by Chuck (27 May) If we post to a Public Forum a message in the form "If and only if t is standing up at the time we wrote this message, we transfer 10 VTs to t.", and t is indeed standing up at the time we wrote the message, and if there are no general conditions preventing any transfer of 10 VTs (such as a lack of funds), then 10 VTs are transferred from us to t. CFJ 1214: Called by Wes (14 May 2000); Judged TRUE by Eris (19 May) If we post to a Public Forum a message in the form "If and only if we have not transferred VTs to t in the last 2 days, we transfer 10 VTs to t.", and we have indeed made no transfers to t in the 2 days previous to sending this message, and if there are no general conditions preventing any transfer of 10 VTs (such as a lack of funds), then 10 VTs are transferred from us to t. If, however, we had transferred VTs to t 4 hours before this message reached the Public Forum, then no VTs would be transferred as a direct result of this posting. CFJ 1213: Called by Murphy (6 May 2000); DISMISSED by Palnatoke (9 May) Rule 1927 prevents the Executor of (the Mintor of) a Bank Currency from Minting a number of units of that Currency, unless e makes an announcement as described in clause a) and specifying that e intends to Mint that number of units of that Currency. CFJ 1212: Called by t (4 May 2000); Judged TRUE by Peekee (7 May); overturned on Appeal (19 May); Judged TRUE by Elysion (24 May) Wes became the High Oligarch on Wed, 3 May 2000 12:48:35 +0300. CFJ 1211: Called by Eris (2 May 2000); DISMISSED by Kelly (3 May) The announcement required by Rule 1927 must contain the number of new units of Currency the Executor intends to Mint. CFJ 1210: Called by Palnatoke (1 May 2000); Judged TRUE by Murphy (6 May) Kelly is not the nickname of a Player[.] CFJ 1209: Called by lee (17 Apr 2000); Judged FALSE by Chuck (24 Apr) The change to the minimum wage on March 30, 2000 was invalid and the subsequent minimum wage PO's issued April 1, 2000 were incorrect. CFJ 1208: Called by Elysion (14 Apr 2000); Judged TRUE by Blob (19 Apr) The Herald's Report was last ratified after 01Feb2000[.] CFJ 1207: Called by Murphy (13 Apr 2000); Judged FALSE by Wes (14 Apr) An Official Report ratified according to Rule 1791 (Ratification Without Objection) is ratified by an Officer, not by Rule 1791 itself. Rule 1791 is an Instrument, but Officers are not Instruments, so Rule 1550 (Ratification) does not attempt to prohibit this method of ratification. CFJ 1206: Called by Peekee (1 Apr 2000); Judged TRUE by Sherlock (7 Apr); overturned on Appeal (14 Apr); reassigned to Anthony (14 Apr); Judged FALSE by else...if (18 Apr) Peekee did not gain 2 Blots due to Tardiness, because of Oerjan's Probate. CFJ 1205: Called by Steve (24 Mar 2000); Judged TRUE by elJefe (31 Mar); Motion 1205.1 Granted by Maud (1 Apr) Wes committed the Class 1 Crime of Promotor Misrepresentation when he distributed Proposal 3988 (Harsher Blot Penalties), on Thu, 16 Mar 2000 18:20:25 -0800. CFJ 1204: Called by t (16 Mar 2000); Judged FALSE by lee (16 Mar) A message that is sent to the email address of a Public Forum but not distributed to any Players has not been sent to a Public Forum. CFJ 1203: Called by Blob (15 Mar 2000); Judged TRUE by Peekee (17 Mar); overturned on Appeal (4 Apr); Judged TRUE by Eris (5 Apr) The Auction for High Oligarch started on Monday, 06 Mar 2000 at 23:40:31 -0800 has ended. CFJ 1202: Called by Blob (15 Mar 2000); DISMISSED by Steve (17 Mar) 23:40:31 -0800 has ended. CFJ 1201: Called by Blob (15 Mar 2000); Judged TRUE by Elysion (19 Mar) The Auction for Middle Oligarchs started on Monday, 06 Mar 2000 at 23:40:31 -0800 has ended. CFJ 1200: Called by Blob (15 Mar 2000); Judged TRUE by t (17 Mar) The Auction for Low Oligarchs started on Monday, 06 Mar 2000 at 23:40:31 -0800 has ended. CFJ 1199: Called by Murphy (27 Feb 2000); assigned to Oerjan (27 Feb); Judged FALSE by Crito (6 Mar) The Rules required the Clerk of the Courts to dismiss CFJ 1198. CFJ 1198: Called by Kelly (23 Feb 2000); DISMISSED by Steve (1 Mar) Peekee violated Rule 1809 when he failed to vacate the Payment Order denominated as avt583 when he determined, in the course of Judging CFJ 1193, that the Order in question was improperly issued. CFJ 1197: Called by Kelly (23 Feb 2000); Judged FALSE by Anthony (26 Feb); overturned on Appeal (3 Mar); Judged TRUE by Palnatoke (15 Mar) Wes violated Rule 1809 when he failed to stay the Payment Order denominated as avt583 when Chuck called the CFJ assigned the number 1193. CFJ 1196: Called by Anthony (14 Feb 2000); Judged TRUE by Sherlock (15 Feb) On Fri, 11 Feb 2000 23:39:06 +0800, [Anthony] made a legitimate proposal for a rule change. CFJ 1195: Called by Peekee (13 Feb 2000); DISMISSED by Wes (17 Feb) Doing what is explicitly prohibited (and possibly penalized) by the Rules is a breach of the Rules, however if something is not prohibited but just penalized by the Rules then doing it is not a breach of the Rules but merely part of the Agora. CFJ 1194: Called by Peekee (13 Feb 2000); Judged TRUE by t (16 Feb) A breach of the Rules in Agora is considered (By Agora) to be illegal. CFJ 1193: Called by Chuck (2 Feb 2000); Harlequin defaulted (13 Feb); Judged TRUE by Peekee (15 Feb); overturned on Appeal (24 Feb); Judged FALSE by Palnatoke (26 Feb) The Payment Orders, designated avt582 through avt593, and issued by t in a message dated Thu, 20 Jan 2000 15:51:29 +0200 (EET), are invalid.