Detail: http://zenith.homelinux.net/cotc/viewcase.php?cfj=2790 =================== CFJ 2790 (Interest Index = 0) ==================== Wooble is a player. ======================================================================== Caller: Wooble Judge: coppro Judgement: FALSE ======================================================================== History: Called by Wooble: 26 Apr 2010 12:52:04 GMT Assigned to coppro: 04 May 2010 13:25:14 GMT Judged FALSE by coppro: 04 May 2010 17:40:19 GMT ======================================================================== Caller's Arguments: On Sun, Apr 25, 2010 at 9:51 PM, Aaron Goldfein wrote: > Registrar's Census > FIRST-CLASS PLAYERS (19) > > Nickname E-mail address Since Status > ------------------------------------------------------------------- > ais523 ais523@bham.ac.uk 28 Apr 08 SA > allispaul allispaul@gmail.com 26 Feb 10 A > Andon aozeba@gmail.com 01 Mar 10 A > BobTHJ pidgepot@gmail.com 17 Jan 08 S > comex comexk@gmail.com 01 May 07 SA > coppro rideau3@gmail.com 07 Mar 09 SA > ehird penguinofthegods@googlemail.com 26 Feb 09 S > Epaeris hermitchipmunk@gmail.com 18 Apr 10 A > G. kerim@u.washington.edu 31 Oct 09 SA > Ienpw III james.m.beirne@gmail.com 04 Aug 09 S > Murphy emurphy42@socal.rr.com 27 Oct 07 SA > Phoenix benuphoenix2@gmail.com 17 Dec 09 S > Sgeo sgeoster@gmail.com 27 Jun 08 S > Spitemaster bennerguy@gmail.com 08 Mar 10 A > Taral taralx@gmail.com 28 Apr 07 S > Tiger jonatan.kilhamn@gmail.com 04 Feb 09 SA > Warrigal ihope127+w@gmail.com 21 Sep 09 SA > woggle woggling@gmail.com 05 Mar 10 A > Yally aarongoldfein@gmail.com 07 Feb 09 SA [...] > Left in 2010: > > d Normish Partnership 2 root@normish.org 12 Aug 08 17 Jan 10 > a Darth Cliche kennercat@gmail.com 22 Sep 09 26 Jan 10 > a Quazie quazienomic@gmail.com 27 Apr 09 26 Jan 10 > a woggle woggling@gmail.com 23 Dec 07 26 Jan 10 > v Wooble geoffspear@gmail.com 17 Nov 09 30 Jan 10 > v Walker charles.w.walker@googlemail.com 05 Dec 09 30 Jan 10 > d IBA c/o comex? 21 Aug 09 02 Mar 10 > v Pavitra celestialcognition@gmail.com 25 Jan 08 14 Apr 10 > CoE: This report neither lists me as a player nor lists the purported deregistration that would have needed to have occurred were I not a player. It is either an incorrect self-ratifying statement that I'm not a player, or an ILLEGAL report violating R2139's requirement to include the dates on which I registered and deregistered (in which case I lack the standing to make both this then-incorrect CoE and to publish an NoV.) ======================================================================== Judge coppro's Arguments: Per CFJ 2779, messages sent to the lists when the lists were not fully functioning were valid. Likewise, per CFJ 2781 (and by eir own admission in the arguments for CFJ 2780), Anabel (then Wooble) did send the message purporting to deregister, making eir deregistration valid. E has not since reregistered. The fact that the Registrar's report did not list Anabel as a player is irrelevant; it was explicitly doubted and did not self-ratify. The deregistration section of the report does not self-ratify; Anabel (having reregistered) is now free to issue an NoV against the report. ========================================================================